Boeing workers walk outside of Boeing’s Everett assembly plant on April 21, 2020 in Everett. (Olivia Vanni / Herald file)

Boeing workers walk outside of Boeing’s Everett assembly plant on April 21, 2020 in Everett. (Olivia Vanni / Herald file)

Editorial: Counting the costs of Boeing-Airbus trade battles

Government subsidies and the tariffs that resulted hurt trade and allowed a competitor to rise.

By The Herald Editorial Board

The pending agreement to end a 17-year-long trade struggle that pitted the United States against the European Union — with billions of dollars and euros levied in tit-for-tat tariffs over government subsidies for Boeing and Airbus — is welcomed news.

It’s especially good news for a major Snohomish County employer eager for encouraging developments after a year that saw the aircraft giant struggle to get its 737 Max re-certified and back in service after two air disasters, even as it and the rest of the airline industry were hit with the worldwide downturn in air travel forced by the pandemic.

As President Biden seeks to re-normalize relationships with EU and NATO nations that the previous administration had relished in souring, the announced end to the long-running Boeing-Airbus dispute over each government’s subsidies marked an initial and significant step in calming trade tensions and soon ending costly and unproductive tariffs.

But for all involved the return flight to Normal is likely to hit some turbulence, specifically the ebbing government use of tax subsidies to win concessions from corporations and the rise of a major competitor to Boeing and Airbus.

Among those most affected by the trade deal’s wrinkles: Washington state’s own subsidy agreements with Boeing that were offered to win assurances that Boeing planes would continued to be built in the state.

Even before this week’s agreement, Boeing appeared last year to recognize that the trade dispute over its competition with Airbus was no longer in its or anyone’s interest. It went to the state Legislature asking lawmakers to — at least temporarily — suspend a preferential business and occupation tax break that had saved it millions of dollars since 2003 and which was extended in 2013 in a deal to convince it to build the next-generation 777X at its Everett plant.

The Legislature agreed, while also arranging for the eventual resumption of the tax incentive. Two conditions were put on the B&O tax break’s restoration: that the United States and EU would resolve its subsidy dispute before the World Trade Organization, and that Boeing would agree to commit to a specific level of aerospace apprenticeship positions within its workforce.

Given a new opportunity to guarantee greater job assurances in return for that significant subsidy, the concession on apprenticeships seemed a meager win.

“Everyone is fairly equally unhappy,” House Speaker Laurie Jinkins, D-Tacoma, said in March of 2020, as the deal neared eventual approval.

The discontent grew even greater later that fall when Boeing announced that because of a combination of factors, including the pandemic’s near shutdown of air travel, it was consolidating its 787 Dreamliner production in South Carolina and shutting down its 787 lines in Everett, where the innovative composite aircraft was first built. The departure meant the loss of hundreds of jobs in Everett.

“I understand the serious market forces Boeing faces today,” said Gov. Jay Inslee in October. “What I don’t understand is why the company can’t commit to restoring production here when the market for this plane improves.”

Everett’s loss of production of the 787 to a non-union plant in South Carolina should in the future raise doubts in lawmakers’ minds about the certainty of what tax incentives can actually deliver in the long term, at least where world trade is involved.

Yet the eventual agreement between the United States and the EU may resolve any future disputes over subsidies; by preventing them in the first place. Under terms of the proposed deal, according to EU officials cited by Bloomberg reporters, the Airbus-Boeing deal requires that all future development of passenger aircraft be done without government subsidies.

Such a requirement would appear to remove significant leverage from governments in winning concessions from either aircraft manufacturer in the future, but Boeing and Airbus — and their respective nations — may have a larger concern regarding competition, one which appears responsible for helping to break the 17-year impasse: China and its work toward building its own jet airliners.

The Commercial Aircraft Corporation of China (Comac) is building a single-aisle jet, the C919, that is aimed at the markets for Boeing’s 737 Max and Airbus’ A320. The C919 may win its airworthiness certification and make its first commercial flights within the year. Comac has also entered into a deal with Russia’s United Aircraft Corporation to build a wide-body jet, the CR929, designed to compete with Boeing’s 787. The CR929 is expected to make its first flight in 2023 with mass production starting by 2026.

China may not have designs on competing with Boeing or Airbus in the global market, Richard Aboulafia, vice president for the Teal Group aviation consultancy, told The Washington Post.

“China’s plan for aircraft is less about global competition, and more about indigenous substitution: They seem to be preparing for a future where China has de-coupled from the West,” Aboulafia said.

But loss of even a portion of that market remains a concern for Boeing and Airbus, who have been the major suppliers of jets to Chinese and other Asian airlines.

Boeing Chief Executive Dave Calhoun told Bloomberg last week, that as the pandemic recedes, Chinese airlines are expected to account for a quarter of expected growth in jet sales over the next decade.

The subsidies that both Boeing and Airbus have courted over the years — and the damaging and ultimately fruitless tariffs with which their governments retaliated — have provided China time to find its footing as a potential competitor to both jetmakers.

What would have been the result if Boeing and Airbus had skipped the battles over subsidies and just paid their tax bills?

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Everett mayor Cassie Franklin delivers her State of the City address on Friday, March 28 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Editorial: The state of Everett amid the state of play

In her state of the city speech, Mayor Cassie Franklin makes the case for optimism amid dark clouds.

Comment: An ‘impossible trinity’ of goals for Trump’s tariffs

Trump wants revenue, manufacturing and foreign policy wins; he can’t get all three, if any.

Arrest of Mahmoud Khalil: Protect freedom of speech for all

It’s been weeks since Mahmoud Khalil was abducted from his home in… Continue reading

Trump’s, Musk’s cuts to education are most damaging

In my long life of service to my community, I have never… Continue reading

Property owners abuse Perrinville Creek watershed

This case history of property owners ignoring the law for instant self-gratification… Continue reading

Douthat: Trump’s Signalgate denials not impressing non-MAGA

Even 60 percent of Republicans polled said the scandal was a serious one.

Genna Martin / The Herald
Piles of wires, motherboards and other electronic parts fill boxes at E-Waste Recycling Center, Thursday. 
Photo taken 1204014
Editorial: Right to repair win for consumers, shops, climate

Legislation now in the Senate would make it easier and cheaper to fix smartphones and other devices.

The WA Cares law is designed to give individuals access to a lifetime benefit amount that, should they need it, they can use on a wide range of long-term services and supports. (Washington State Department of Social and Health Services)
Editorial: Changes to WA Cares will honor voters’ confidence

State lawmakers are considering changes to improve the benefit’s access and long-term stability.

A press operator grabs a Herald newspaper to check over as the papers roll off the press in March 2022 in Everett. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald file photo)
Editorial: Keep journalism vital with state grant program

Legislation proposes a modest tax for some tech companies to help pay salaries of local journalists.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, March 31

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Hegseth isn’t unholding standards he vowed he would

Veterans are among the most critical of the Defense secretary for his lapse of security and protocol.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.