A man carries items in a plastic bag as he walks down Evergreen Way on in October in Everett. Everett is looking at a ban on the bags. And two state lawmakers are proposing bills for a statewide ban. (Andy Bronson / Herald file photo)

A man carries items in a plastic bag as he walks down Evergreen Way on in October in Everett. Everett is looking at a ban on the bags. And two state lawmakers are proposing bills for a statewide ban. (Andy Bronson / Herald file photo)

Editorial: Statewide plastic bag ban a good place to start

Plastic bags are only a small part of the pollution problem, but it’s a simple and inexpensive fix.

By The Herald Editorial Board

While bans of plastic shopping bags at grocery stores already are in effect in about 20 cities in the state — including in Edmonds, Mukilteo and Tulalip’s Quil Ceda Village — and are being considered by Everett and Snohomish, a proposal to ban single-use plastic bags statewide would make Washington only the second state in the U.S. to make that move.

Considering the experience of the state’s cities where such bans already are in effect — as well as that of California and elsewhere — state lawmakers should now bring a statewide ban and how it would work up for discussion.

Rep. Strom Peterson, D-Edmonds, and Sen. Kevin Ranker, D-Orcas Island, announced their intention to introduce legislation when the session begins in January. Peterson was on the Edmonds City Council when it passed its ban in 2009.

The bills would bar stores from distributing the plastic bags and charge a 10-cent fee for the use of paper bags provided by stores, encouraging shoppers to bring their own reusable bags.

The intention of the ban is the reduction of a portion of the plastic that finds its way into the state’s waterways, Puget Sound, Salish Sea and ocean, and as litter, in landfills and in recycling.

A 2014 report by Scientific American found that the full range of plastic pollution — because it isn’t biodegradable but breaks down into tiny microplastics that contain and absorb toxic chemicals — are ingested by birds and marine life. A European Commission study cited by the magazine, found that 90 percent of North Sea birds had plastics in their stomachs. Another report blamed the ingestion of plastics for tens of thousands of deaths of birds and marine wildlife worldwide.

It’s worth asking, however, whether such a ban would make a difference and reduce the amount of plastic pollution.

The Washington Policy Center has argued against the bans considered and passed by cities and is gearing up to fight the statewide proposal. Todd Myers, director for WPC’s Center for the Environment, in earlier online commentaries, has criticized the bans as addressing only a tiny portion of the plastic pollution and questions whether replacing plastic bags with reusable cotton bags is actually less harmful for the environment because of the use of fertilizers and pesticides necessary to produce cotton, which then find their way downstream.

Myers told The Seattle Times that to make a difference environmentally, a shopper would have to use a cotton bag every week for six years.

But then, that’s kind of the idea behind the reusable bags. And cotton isn’t the only option, as most shoppers already have noticed among the range of inexpensive bags available near the counters of most grocery stores.

An examination of California’s 2016 ban of plastic bags by San Francisco public broadcaster KQED a year after the ban began, found that it would take about 130 uses of one cotton bag — less than half of Myers’ estimate of more than 300 times — to equal one use of a single-use plastic bag. But other reusable bags needed far fewer uses to equal that of plastic bags. Polyester bags needed to be used 42 times to equal a plastic bag. Woven polypropylene bags needed to be used only 11 to 13 times to justify the switch from a single-use plastic bag.

Opponents also point to how most of us use the single-use bags to line kitchen trash cans or pick up pet waste. But while that reuse sends the bags to the landfill, a significant number of the bags find their way into recycling. The bags themselves aren’t considered recyclable, and when mixed with recyclable plastics, drive down the market value of those plastics and complicate recycling efforts. The KQED report cited a San Jose recycler who reported that the ban meant fewer of the plastic bags were getting caught in their equipment, which had reduced down-time by up to 50 percent.

Critics also point out that the bags represent just a small portion of the plastic contamination.

It is small in comparison to other plastics, but not insignificant. And a ban on plastic bags also is something that can be done without major costs or inconvenience to shoppers. The Los Angeles Times Editorial Board, reviewing the California ban a year after it took effect, reported that Californians adjusted quickly to the switch to reusable bags.

Single-use plastic bags — to recycle a cliche — are low-hanging fruit. Their elimination will leave far too much that needs to be addressed in the way of single-use plastics — plastic straws, bottles, lids and cups, snack bags and wrappers and other food containers — that all contribute to waste and pollution.

But where else does one start but with the stuff that’s easiest to pick?

Talk to us

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Oct. 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The A-8 proposal for Everett City Council districts, which were approved by voters in 2018, will be presented for public input in six virtual meetings over a week starting Thursday, Sept. 10. (City of Everett)
Editorial: Everett’s future depends on voters’ council choices

With five seats on the ballot, and at least three new members, voter participation is key.

Paul Benz
Paul Benz: Three short words — of, by and for — explain democracy

Lincoln’s Gettysburg Address described our government’s basis, authority and who it was meant to serve.

Juan Peralez
Juan Peralez: Meager SNAP increase an insult to our nation

The nation’s poorest would get $1 more a day in food stamps, insufficient to feed families with kids.

Generosity of many to Greater Providence Campaign saving lives

I was happy to see Marshall and Katherine Cymbaluk recognized in The… Continue reading

Comment: Ready to ditch Facebook? Here’s what to take with you

You can suspend or leave your account, but you should take the ‘memories’ you’ve posted with you.

Comment: Pastors in ‘Blacked-Robed Regiment’ get history wrong

Trying to emulate Revolutionary War clergy, the conservative ministers dishonor the Founders’ ideals.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Oct. 15

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - In this Oct. 28, 2020, file photo, a voter turns sideways as he eyes the opening of a ballot drop box before placing his ballot inside it in Seattle. A record number of voters participating in November's election was among Washington state's top stories for 2020. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Editorial: Ballots are in the mail; mark ‘em and get ‘em in

Your vote in the Nov. 2 election will determine who represents your voice regarding local issues.

Most Read