If a worker pays no dues, why get union benefits?

Anti-union groups’ short-sighted activism raises questions of fairness.

The Olympian editorial board

The “right-to-work movement” in this country protests a bit too much. Ultimately the movement’s fight is against all unions.

That is pretty short-sighted thinking. There is a correlation historically between the weakening of labor unions in the U.S. economy and the widening of income inequality. Unions provide a check against cavalier management, and they support a wage floor that makes it more likely that wages keep up with inflation.

Nonetheless, the fight against labor organizing continues. And the current battle against public-sector unions is coming to a head at the U.S. Supreme Court in a case known as Janus vs. AFSCME in the state of Illinois.

The strict legal issues deal with whether public sector workers who benefit from pay contracts, but opt out of membership, should have to pay “agency fees” to the unions that negotiated their compensation contracts. The argument for opting out is workers have a right of free association.

Under the law as it is applied today, workers can opt out of paying dues if they opt out of belonging to a union, but they remain on the hook for their so-called fair-share of costs for bargaining. That should not be an issue, but it is the target for interests angling to upend the law.

The opt-in or opt-out argument is a fair one — workers should be given a chance to make an informed decision.

But the attempt to dangle a free ride as an incentive for workers to opt out is not fair.

Of course the end game here is to undermine membership in unions. Ultimately, this might weaken labor groups as players in the crafting or negotiating of policies that govern working conditions. As importantly, a victory over the unions might defang their role in electoral politics.

So far, the public in Washington has supported the role of public — sector unions in state and local government.

There is no question that employee pay has risen as a result of unionization. There were exceptions — such as when Washington’s state-worker unions agreed to temporary pay cuts during the depth of the Great Recession.

The Washington Federation of State Employees’ executive leader, Greg Devereux, recently told The Olympian’s and News Tribune’s reporter Walker Orenstein that WFSE has grown its membership from about 20,000 when he joined the organization in the 1994 to more than 43,000 represented workers today. The latter includes nearly 36,000 dues payers.

The percentage of workers opting out of paying dues is less than 10 percent and shrinking, according to WFSE.

However the Supreme Court sorts out this case, it’s worth asking: If workers can opt out of paying a share of contract bargaining costs, should they also opt out of benefits?

Should state employees opting out be entitled to health-insurance benefits at the rate they receive them — with taxpayers picking up 85 percent of premiums? Or should they pay a higher percentage? Should opting-out employees receive cost of living raises at the same level as those who pay dues or agency fees?

It’s easy to imagine legal roadblocks to creating such a two-tier system of pay and benefits.

We ask this question only partly in jest. If a worker’s right of free speech or free association is interfered with by requiring the agency-fee payment, should there morally be any right for the worker to cash in on benefits he or she isn’t paying for?

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, May 25

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - A worker cleans a jet bridge at Paine Field in Everett, Wash., before passengers board an Alaska Airlines flight, March 4, 2019. Seattle-based Alaska Airlines owns Horizon Air. Three passengers sued Alaska Airlines on Thursday, Nov. 2, 2023, saying they suffered emotional distress from an incident last month in which an off-duty pilot, was accused of trying to shut down the engines of a flight from Washington state to San Francisco. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Editorial: FAA bill set to improve flight safety, experience

With FAA reauthorization, Congress proves it’s capable of legislating and not just throwing shade.

The author’s 19-year-old niece, Veronika, was among seven people killed by a gunman on May 23, 2014, in Isla Vista, Calif.
Comment: I lost my niece to gun violence 10 years ago this week

Since then, Washington state voters and lawmakers have taken bold steps to discourage gun violence.

Comment: Reroute of Harvey Field runway not worth flood risk

Without a projected need for expansion, the work risks flooding impacts to wildlife and residents.

Forum: How we employ hope in our work toward what we hope for

When reaching goals takes time, do we use hope to sustain us or to redefine what we sought in the first place?

Forum: As goes Boeing, so goes state funding for schools

Boeing tried to update the 737 on the cheap. The state has done the same in funding schools.

Tufekci: Scarlett Johanson’s voice isn’t only thing AI is after

Humanity’s collective creative output is being repurposed and monetized as AI companies see fit.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, May 24

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The vessel Tonga Chief, a 10-year-old Singaporean container ship, is moored at the Port of Everett Seaport in November, 2023, in Everett. (Ryan Berry / The Herald file photo)
Editorial: Leave port tax issue for campaign, not the ballot

Including “taxing district” on ballot issue to expand the Port of Everett’s boundaries is prejudicial.

Schwab: MAGA GOP threatens supply chain of gobs to smack

Even if you ration your gobs, the week’s Republican outrages have created a nationwide shortage.

Alternative is needed to 8-hour shutdown of I-5

I was in the catastrophic I-5 backup on May 16 trying to… Continue reading

Herald, please bring back Today in History, professional sports scores

First off, thank you for continuing to publish The Herald. I have… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.