It is not de facto gun registration

In Thursday’s Herald there is a letter by Mike Meisner that claims I-594 is gun registration and an attempt to end private gun ownership.

First he argues that making it harder for criminals to buy a gun will not deter anyone from getting their hands on one; this is like saying locking your doors doesn’t stop thieves. Yes, some criminals will still easily get guns, but not all of them.

Next he argues that I-594 won’t stop legally authorized gun owners from committing crimes. These people usually don’t commit crimes because they are responsible. Trusting people who have thus far proven trustworthy is a risk most of us are willing to take to protect our Second Amendment rights.

Finally he argues that this new law will force people to register their guns, like car registration, and restriction on alcohol. He reminds us that despite these restrictions people still drive drunk. Well, yes, drunk driving is still a big problem, and even if I-594 is passed, gun violence will likely still be a problem. However, since the crackdown on drunk driving, there are far less alcohol-fueled collisions.

Thursday’s letter lacks a stated thesis, but it seems to be: I-594 won’t stop all violent crime, therefore let’s make sure it doesn’t pass. And while we’re at it, why don’t we get rid of alcohol laws and license requirements? Since some people still drive drunk we may as well make it legal for 12 year olds to do it.

Jay Vandenberg


Talk to us

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Friday, April 23

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

This July 17, 1969 photo made available by NASA shows the Earth as the Apollo 11 mission travels towards the moon. It’s estimated that about 600 million people around the world watched as Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin landed on the moon in 1969. (NASA via AP)
Editorial: Climate action offers a better life at lower cost

There is no alternative to climate action in which we pay nothing. We are already paying.

Commentary: Aviation jobs need skilled workers trained here

ATS and others are hiring again; workers with skills learned in high school and college have a head start.

Comment: What troop pullout means for U.S. global security

Leaving Afghanistan allows the U.S. to reposition itself as the world’s strongest democracy.

Harrop: Polls on happiest countries, states good for a smile

Can we really measure happiness — and our location’s part in it — when we differ on what makes our day?

Comment: Elections have consequences, even union votes

The union must respect the decision of Amazon workers, and it needs to listen to those workers.

Comment: What keeps officials from reaching climate solutions

Fifty years ago there seemed bipartisan accord on environmental issues; why and how has that changed?

Medicare Advantage has been lifesaver during covid

I couldn’t be more grateful for my Medicare Advantage, my health care… Continue reading

Most Read