Orwell could have written script from Guantanamo

  • Eugene Robinson / Washington Post Columnist
  • Monday, April 2, 2007 9:00pm
  • Opinion

WASHINGTON – Here’s what the Bush administration has done to the values, traditions and honor of the United States of America: An accused terrorist claims he confessed to heinous crimes so that agents of the U.S. government would stop torturing him, and no one is shocked or even surprised. There’s reason to believe, in fact, that what the suspect says about torture is probably true.

There’s also reason to doubt that the suspect – Abd al-Rahim al-Nashiri, held in U.S. custody without charges for more than four years – is the Zelig-like innocent bystander he claims to be. But we can’t be sure, because George W. Bush disgraced himself and his country by ordering extrajudicial kidnappings of war on terror suspects, indefinite secret detention, and interrogation by “alternative” methods that the civilized world calls torture.

Last Friday, the Defense Department released a heavily redacted transcript of a March 14 hearing, held at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, to determine whether Nashiri should be classified as an “enemy combatant.” I apologize for resorting to cliche, but the only way to describe this amazing, infuriating document is to call it Orwellian. Reading it gives you the chills.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

None of the members of the military tribunal sitting in judgment is named. The officer serving as Nashiri’s “personal representative” likewise is not named. Unclassified evidence is presented in summary – an unnamed “recorder” reads a document quoting statements by witnesses that attest to Nashiri’s involvement in the 1998 bombings of U.S. embassies in Tanzania and Kenya, in which 224 people died, and the 2000 bombing of the USS Cole, which killed 17 U.S. sailors. The witnesses are not present so, of course, there is no opportunity to challenge their statements.

Nashiri’s representative, a lieutenant commander in the U.S. Navy, presents a stunning response: “The Detainee states that he was tortured into confession and once he made a confession his captors were happy and they stopped torturing him. Also, the Detainee states that he made up stories during the torture in order to get it to stop.”

The response states that Nashiri confessed under torture not only to the East Africa and USS Cole bombings, but also to the 2002 bombing of the French oil tanker Limburg, some bombings and rocket attacks in Saudi Arabia, a plan to bomb American ships in the Persian Gulf, and “a plan to hijack a plane and crash it into a ship.” Oh, and he also told investigators that Osama bin Laden had acquired a nuclear bomb.

“I just said those things to make the people happy,” Nashiri tells the tribunal.

Nashiri denies having anything to do with terrorism, although he acknowledges taking money from bin Laden. He paints himself – unconvincingly, in my view – as a simple merchant who makes poor choices in friends and has a habit of being in the wrong place at the wrong time.

The Navy captain serving as president of the tribunal gets around to asking Nashiri about the alleged torture. Who did it? They were Americans, Nashiri says. When did it happen? “From the time I was arrested five years ago, they have been torturing me.”

Only George Orwell could have written what comes next in the transcript. The following is what we are allowed to know of Nashiri’s response when asked how he was tortured:

“What else do I want to say? (REDACTED). Many things happened. There were doing so many things. What else did they did? (REDACTED). They do so many things. So many things. What else did they did? (REDACTED). After that another method of torture began. (REDACTED). They used to ask me questions and the investigator after that used to laugh. And, I used to answer the answer that I knew. And, if I didn’t reply what I heard, he used to (REDACTED). So many things happened. I don’t in summary, that’s basically what happened.”

I guess that’s how the U.S. government extracts information from detainees: (REDACTED).

The Pentagon told reporters that Nashiri’s claims were censored because of “national security concerns” about disclosing where detainees were held and how they were treated. But that would be unnecessary if Nashiri were lying, since no harm could come from disclosing a bunch of made-up stories. The censorship only makes sense if some or all of what Nashiri alleges is true.

But we’re not permitted to know what he alleges.

Orwell had it figured out: “Ignorance is Strength.”

Eugene Robinson is a Washington Post columnist. Contact him by writing to eugenerobinson@washpost.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, June 1

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

A rendering of the new vessels to be built for Washington State Ferries. (Washington State Ferries)
Editorial: Local shipyard should get shot to build state ferries

If allowed to build at least two ferries, Nichols Brothers can show the value building here offers.

Demonstrators gather as part of the National Law Day of Action outside the Supreme Court in Washington, May 1, 2025. (Tierney L. Cross/The New York Times)
Comment: Justice is blind; it shouldn’t be silenced

Politicians play a dangerous game by accusing judges who rule against them of defying the voters’ will.

State should split ferry contract to keep jobs, speed up build

On Jan. 8, Gov.-elect Bob Ferguson, transportation leaders from the Senate and… Continue reading

Has Trump read Paine’s ‘Common Sense’?

Will Donald Trump, who says he “runs the world” and approved a… Continue reading

Youth Forum: Zoos today provide education and protection

Zoos today allow better understanding of animal needs and are aiding in saving species from extinction.

Youth Forum: Students need hands-on learning of animal dissection

It can help students decide a career path in life sciences; because of USDA oversight it’s safe.

Forum: New stadium a civic project that can deliver on its vision

Along with keeping the AquaSox in town, it offers a wealth of broader public benefits for Everett.

Forum: Pope Leo’s election a welcome reminder to protect workers

His choice of Leo XIII as his namesake is important for his attitudes toward dignity, justice and labor.

The Buzz: On the menu: tacos, tainted lettuce, free-range ostrich

While Trump was enjoying TACO Tuesday, RFK Jr. had his eye on a wobble of bird flu-stricken ostriches.

May 28, 2025: Trump Budget Bill
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, May 31

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Trump doesn’t want to fix Harvard; he wants to control it

Crippling Harvard and its students would hit all of higher ed and U.S. leadership in research and more.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.