PUD fights to stop another potential fleecing of public power customers

  • By Don McManman
  • Friday, March 4, 2005 9:00pm
  • Opinion

Take time today to thank the folks at the Snohomish County PUD for mounting a lonely crusade to keep your power bills as low as possible.

And I’m not talking about the Enron mess.

Rather, the PUD appears to be alone in publicly questioning the Bonneville Power Administration about a scheme to manipulate debt from a failed nuclear plant program. You may remember the program’s centerpiece, best known as the Washington Public Power Supply System, or WPPSS (whoops!) for short. The PUD believes BPA may be taking money earmarked to repay the nuke debt and using it to help investor-owned utilities (IOUs), like Puget Sound Energy, transmit their power. The PUD would rather that BPA money be used to lower rates of public power agencies, like the PUD itself or Seattle City Light.

At least that’s the gist of questions brought forward by the PUD’s Steve Marshall in a December utility meeting in Portland. PUD Commissioner Kathy Vaughn and General Manager Ed Hansen had his back.

Don’t get me wrong. Today’s courage on the part of the PUD doesn’t excuse the comatose bumbling of the utility’s former leaders as the switches were being lined up for what would become the West Coast energy train wreck. Pollyanna herself was running the PUD in 1998, when Bonneville predicted energy shortages in the coming years. Back then, even a high school economics student could tell you what happens when demand goes up and supply doesn’t.

Instead, utility managers across the Northwest, including the PUD’s and Bonneville’s, opted for the Jiminy Cricket approach: Wish upon a star and, by golly, everything will be OK. Trouble was, Jiminy turned out to be Pinocchio, and his nose got longer every day as the energy crisis grew longer.

After the PUD woke up from its binge – and saw the credit card bill – it showed the guts that few other utilities had: It went after the thieves of Enron and, more importantly, continues to shame the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission into not swooning for every Texan with a fat swagger and an even fatter checkbook.

That’s the campaign that’s getting all the press. But the PUD has another bone to pick, and this one also has ramifications for every public power utility in the Northwest. The PUD – in the form of Steve Marshall – took its case to Bonneville’s hometown in December.

Here’s the deal: Because Bonneville ordered the three nuclear plants, only one of which was finished, it is obligated to pay off the old WPPSS bonds. In recent years, Bonneville and Energy Northwest, the successor agency to WPPSS, have agreed to what’s known as a debt optimization program. Because of federal and state law, Energy Northwest has access to cheaper borrowing than does Bonneville. So, under the debt program, Energy Northwest refinances its old bonds, essentially pushing ultimate nuke payoff farther into our children’s future. Lower bond payments today allow Bonneville to use extra cash. But to what purpose?

If Bonneville is using the money to improve its transmission system, which benefits private companies, isn’t the ongoing debt actually a subsidy to privately owned utilities? If it is, the debt plan probably violates federal law – as well as meaning higher rates in your bill next month. You’ll see higher rates next decade, as well, because we’ll be paying on the nuclear bonds far beyond their original payoff date.

To be fair, not everyone at Energy Northwest – including its CEO – was enthusiastic about the debt plan. And Energy Northwest’s Executive Board requires that Bonneville certify it uses refinancing benefits to only pay down higher priced debt. But you can’t separate one dollar bill from another 3 billion churned together in the cement mixer of BPA’s budgeting process.

Bonneville maintains the debt plan saves ratepayers $100 million a year. But at the Portland meeting, BPA didn’t lay out any figures to indicate what would happen if the entire debt plan savings was applied to immediate rate relief.

Then there’s the problem of using borrowed dollars to finance current living expenses – not a good option whether it’s employed by someone with a swollen credit card account or by a federal power marketing agency.

Yet, if the debt plan is such a boon to the region, why did Bonneville hatch it outside of its regular public disclosure channels? And why is BPA Administrator Steve Wright badmouthing the PUD for bringing up the matter at all?

Good questions, and I’m glad the PUD is asking them. For someone who’s watched energy sleight of hand for many years, to see the Snohomish County PUD stand up and ask questions that are equally tough and pertinent makes the air a bit fresher, the sun a little brighter – and, I hope, rates a little lower for every ratepayer in the Pacific Northwest.

Former newspaper reporter Don McManman is a public affairs consultant who has worked with Energy Northwest and BPA in the past. He lives in Shoreline. Reach him at mcmanma@attglobal.net.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

THis is an editorial cartoon by Michael de Adder . Michael de Adder was born in Moncton, New Brunswick. He studied art at Mount Allison University where he received a Bachelor of Fine Arts in drawing and painting. He began his career working for The Coast, a Halifax-based alternative weekly, drawing a popular comic strip called Walterworld which lampooned the then-current mayor of Halifax, Walter Fitzgerald. This led to freelance jobs at The Chronicle-Herald and The Hill Times in Ottawa, Ontario.

 

After freelancing for a few years, de Adder landed his first full time cartooning job at the Halifax Daily News. After the Daily News folded in 2008, he became the full-time freelance cartoonist at New Brunswick Publishing. He was let go for political views expressed through his work including a cartoon depicting U.S. President Donald Trump’s border policies. He now freelances for the Halifax Chronicle Herald, the Toronto Star, Ottawa Hill Times and Counterpoint in the USA. He has over a million readers per day and is considered the most read cartoonist in Canada.

 

Michael de Adder has won numerous awards for his work, including seven Atlantic Journalism Awards plus a Gold Innovation Award for news animation in 2008. He won the Association of Editorial Cartoonists' 2002 Golden Spike Award for best editorial cartoon spiked by an editor and the Association of Canadian Cartoonists 2014 Townsend Award. The National Cartoonists Society for the Reuben Award has shortlisted him in the Editorial Cartooning category. He is a past president of the Association of Canadian Editorial Cartoonists and spent 10 years on the board of the Cartoonists Rights Network.
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, June 11

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer testifies during a budget hearing before a House Appropriations subcommittee on Capitol Hill in Washington on Thursday, May 15, 2025. (Al Drago/The New York Times)
Editorial: Ending Job Corps a short-sighted move by White House

If it’s jobs the Trump administration hopes to bring back to the U.S., it will need workers to fill them.

Marcus Tageant (Courtesy of City of Lake Stevens)
Welch: Marcus Tageant embodied the spirit of Lake Stevens

I served with Marcus on the city council, witnessing an infectious devotion to his community.

Comment: Why Trump’s Guard deployment is threat to democracy

Trump claims rebellion and invasion; there is neither. Policing protests must be left to states.

Comment: Hegseth renaming ships dishonors memory of ‘warriors’

Navy vessels were named for Harvey Milk, Cesar Chavez and others in recognition of their service to country.

Goldberg: Watch carefully; this is what autocracy looks like

Trump, in stepping past state officials, has over-reacted to discourage legitimate protest of his actions.

A rendering of possible configuration for a new multi-purpose stadium in downtown Everett. (DLR Group)
Editorial: Latest ballpark figures drive hope for new stadium

A lower estimate for the project should help persuade city officials to move ahead with plans.

A rendering of the new vessels to be built for Washington State Ferries. (Washington State Ferries)
Editorial: Local shipyard should get shot to build state ferries

If allowed to build at least two ferries, Nichols Brothers can show the value building here offers.

Comment: Reclaim and fly the American flag for ‘No Kings Day’

For those defending the nation’s ideals, there’s no better complement to a protest sign than the flag.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, June 10

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Comment: Trump’s tariffs could ground aerospace’s rebound

Just as Boeing and Airbus had worked out most of their supply chain kinks, the threat of tariffs looms.

French: Trump, as he hoped, gets his excuse for conflict

It’s on the slightest of pretenses, but Trump is getting the showdown he desired in California.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.