Tax fairness would restore infrastructure, equality

Roads are crumbling, bridges require repairs, schools need upgrades and public pension systems remain underfunded. How can states and cities find the money to address any of these problems? One way could be through their tax codes.

According to a new report, if the rich paid the same state and local tax rate as the middle class, states and cities would have hundreds of billions of dollars more a year in public revenue.

Last month, the nonpartisan Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy found that the poorest 20 percent of households pay on average more than twice the effective state and local tax rate (10.9 percent) as the richest 1 percent of taxpayers (5.4 percent).

That preceded the new report from the left-leaning groups Good Jobs First and the Keystone Research Center which finds that if tax laws were changed to compel the highest income earners to pay the same rate as everyone else, states and localities would rake in up to $128 billion a year in new revenue. If just the top 1 percent of earners were compelled to pay the typical middle-class tax rate, the report says the change would raise more than $68 billion in new annual revenues.

To put those numbers in context, consider that the price tag of other public priorities is just a fraction of the money that could be raised by equalizing tax rates. For instance, the report notes that free community college would cost $6 billion a year, and universal pre-kindergarten in all states would cost roughly $24 billion. Similarly, the report notes that the total annual price tag of backfilling public pension shortfalls is $30.5 billion. It also finds that five states that would reap the most revenue from equalizing tax rates — Texas, Florida, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts and Ohio — are among those with the largest pension shortfalls.

Of course, despite its findings, the report is likely to have no effect in many state legislatures, as it follows a 2014 election that saw tax-averse Republicans increase their power in the nation’s statehouses.

The National Conference of State Legislatures reports that the GOP now controls more than 55 percent of the country’s 7,383 legislative seats — the most the GOP has controlled since 1920.

Many Republican lawmakers are championing proposals for new state tax cuts, some of which could further widen the gap between the rates paid by the rich and the poor. Indeed, in a recent story headlined “States Consider Increasing Taxes for the Poor and Cutting Them for the Affluent,” The New York Times notes “of the 10 or so Republican governors who have proposed tax increases, nearly all have called for increases in consumption taxes, which hit the poor and middle class harder than the rich.” Some of those governors are simultaneously proposing big income tax cuts that benefit the wealthy.

Meanwhile, Republican governors running for president in 2016 will likely jockey to show who is more devoted to tax cuts and budget cuts. Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker, for instance, has proposed both higher education cuts and property tax cuts in his most recent annual budget. Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal already has signed the largest tax cut in his state’s history and has pushed cuts to higher education funding. New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie has handed out record amounts of corporate tax breaks while declining to make actuarially required payments into his state’s pension system.

The political question, then, is: Will Democrats counter with a different vision? The facts about tax fairness are certainly compelling — the numbers prove that the system could be at once more equal and raise more resources for public priorities. But those numbers will only become a reality if there is a serious political counterweight to the GOP — and that remains a big if.

David Sirota’s email address is ds@davidsirota.com.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

November 29, 2023: Gaza Pause
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Nov. 29

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Macro photo of tooth wheel mechanism with imprinted RECEIVE, GIVE concept words
Editorial: Get back into charitable habit for Giving Tuesday

Inflation sapped donations for charities last year; things may be looking up this year for more.

Carbon auctions, gas prices: Figures aren’t oil company profits

Thanks for mentioning our estimates of the impact of the tax on… Continue reading

Call park’s Wintertide Lights what they are, Christmas lights

The recent story about the return of Wintertide Lights at Legion Park… Continue reading

Comment: Palestinians — and Israel — need a new Marshall plan

The Marshall Plan rebuilt Germany for Europe’s benefit. The same must be done for the Mideast.

Comment: Biden, Trump cling to myth of manufacturing’s decline

It’s a ‘Chicken Little’ cry that sounds like they’re backing the middle class, but it’s costing consumers.

Owners of Country Rose/The Paint Bungalow, Donna Mains (left) and Kathleen Shalan in their shop in October, 2021 in Arlington. The gift store also stocks Annie Sloan paint as well as being a women's apparel boutique. (Andy Bronson / The Herald file photo)
Editorial: Stroll, don’t scroll on Small Business Saturday

Shopping local stores is a great way to find gifts and supports local economies and your neighbors.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Nov. 28

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Harrop: Trade-offs for moms working remotely are their choice

Some parents will willingly trade advancement opportunities for a better work-life balance.

Comment: Naming birds after people — especially bigots — ignorant

It’s better to name birds for characteristics and habitat for dead white men, better left forgotten.

Comment: Today’s Congress genteel compared to slavery era’s

There were some 70 violent altercations between Congress members during debates over slavery.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Nov. 27

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.