Welch: It’s our money; we know where, how it’s used best

Voluntary distribution of charity — rather than taxation — supports what is most important to communities.

By Todd Welch / Herald Columnist

There’s a powerful truth that’s been buried under decades of government overreach, political doublespeak, and media spin: Your money belongs to you.

Not the government. Not elected officials. Not unelected bureaucrats or their campaign donors.

You earned it. And you should decide how it’s used.

Yet every year, millions of Americans hand over a massive portion of their paycheck to the government — under threat of fines, audits and penalties — only to watch it be squandered. The money that’s supposed to help those in need is often rerouted to pet projects, special-interest deals, and bloated payrolls for friends of politicians who’ve never created anything of real value.

This isn’t charity. This isn’t efficient. And it sure isn’t justice.

The government doesn’t create wealth; you do.

Let’s get one thing straight: Government doesn’t generate wealth;it consumes it. Every dollar it spends first had to be taken from someone who earned it. And while taxes may be necessary for essential services, we’ve long passed the line of “essential.”

We’ve entered an era where elected leaders treat our paychecks like their playground. They hand out our money to buy votes, reward loyalty and fund waste that would bankrupt any private organization in months. Meanwhile, real people struggle, while the government machine grows fat and unaccountable.

But imagine a different model. A better one. One where we, the people keep what we earn and invest it with purpose.

We know better than the government ever will.

You know your neighborhood. Your church. Your school. You don’t need a bureaucrat to tell you where need exists; you see it every day.

And because you see it, you can act with far more clarity, precision and compassion than any federal program ever could.

When we keep more of our money, we can:

• Give directly to charities we’ve vetted.

• Help families cover rent, groceries, or child care.

• Invest in local businesses that create jobs.

• Support vocational training programs and mentorship.

• Fund community centers, addiction recovery or crisis shelters.

The money stretches further. The help arrives faster. And dignity stays intact, because people aren’t reduced to case numbers or data points in a government database. They’re seen. They’re loved. They’re restored.

Charity is most powerful when it’s voluntary

Taxation is not generosity. It’s not kindness. It’s not noble. It’s compulsory; and it’s often misused.

Charity, on the other hand, is a choice. It’s rooted in love, not obligation. It dignifies both the giver and the receiver.

When we take responsibility for the needs around us — when we stop outsourcing compassion to a bloated government — we make that government unnecessary. We shrink its footprint and expand human connection. We replace red tape with relationships. Dependency with dignity.

This is how you make government assistance irrelevant; not through politics, but through people.

Buying local is a form of giving, too.

Let’s go a step further.

Every time you buy local — when you choose a small shop over a mega-retailer, a farmer’s market over a big box — you’re doing more than just consuming. You’re circulating wealth within your community.

You’re helping someone hire. Pay a mortgage. Expand inventory. Build a future. And when people build wealth, they give more. They sponsor Little League teams, fund scholarships, support charities, and serve those around them.

A thriving local economy creates a thriving local culture of generosity.

The vision: People over politics.

This isn’t just about economics; it’s about reclaiming a culture.

It’s about returning power to where it belongs: the people. It’s about saying no more to politicians who use our money to pad their influence. It’s about saying yes to a future where we give because we want to, not because we’re forced. It’s about building a society rooted in accountability, not entitlement.

We don’t need another government program. We need courage. Discipline. Generosity. Vision.

Let’s keep our money. Let’s give it intentionally. Let’s support our communities. Let’s eliminate government intervention by doing the work better, because no government can ever replace the power of a free, responsible, and generous people.

It’s your money. Own it. Use it wisely. And change the world with it.

Todd Welch is a columnist for The Herald, addressing local and state issues. He lives in Everett.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Aug. 6

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Six areas of climate impacts expected for Snohomish County.
(Snohomish County Climate Resiliency Plan)
Editorial: Buidling climate resiliency with or without the EPA

Abdication of federal efforts on the climate crisis leaves a duty at the local and state levels.

Welch: It’s our money; we know where, how it’s used best

Voluntary distribution of charity — rather than taxation — supports what is most important to communities.

Douthat: Conspiracies are real; it’s theories that can be traps

Theories can explain what remains as unexplained, but theories must withstand the facts.

Harrop: A welcome bit of inconsequential controversy

Some ‘genes-jeans’ word play in TV ad provides a chance to mock those who take it seriously.

Comment: U.S. can survive Trump’s tariffs; they’re still insane

Dismantling the global trading order is to cast away American power.

Comment: No Trump name should appear above the Kennedy Center

Melania Trump is no patron of the arts. And Donald Trump has acted against Kennedy’s vision.

2024 Presidential Election Day Symbolic Elements.
Editorial: A recap of The Herald’s primary endorsements

Primary elections, setting the November ballot, are no time for voters to sit on the sidelines.

Comment: We need a better plan to reform Social Security

The Trump administration is on to something with its ‘baby accounts,’ but it must go bigger.

Saunders: You can’t talk of 2 states when Hamas holds hostages

The recognition of Palestine by countries can only delay resolution of the famine ongoing in Gaza.

Comment: Attack on transgender kids isn’t just cruel; it’s a threat

Dismantling health care for transgender kids for their “protection,” could be repeated for other care.

Washington state's Congressional Districts (Washington State Redistricting Commission)
Editorial: State lawmakers right to skip Gerrymandering Games

While red and blue states look to game the midterms, Washington is wisely staying out of that fray.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.