The Seahawks’ Jerramy Stevens is tackled by Pittsburgh’s Chris Hope and Troy Polamalu (rear) during Super Bowl XL on Feb. 2, 2006 in Detroit.

The Seahawks’ Jerramy Stevens is tackled by Pittsburgh’s Chris Hope and Troy Polamalu (rear) during Super Bowl XL on Feb. 2, 2006 in Detroit.

Art Thiel: Let’s revisit that mistake of a Super Bowl in 2006

Much of this pre-Super Bowl week is devoted to saluting the game’s 50th anniversary. But nobody is saying much in Seattle about the Seahawks’ 10th anniversary of their first Super Bowl appearance. It just sits in the attic, like the gag trophy for the winner of the three-legged race at the family’s summer reunion picnic.

For all those Amazon newbies who are arriving in Seattle at a 1,000-a-day rate, here’s a brief history of the Game That Shall Never be Spoken Of XL (as opposed to the Game That Cannot Be Unseen XLIX):

What? Are you kidding me, ref?! Fercripesakes! I don’t freakin’ care that Jerome Bettis is from Detroit! How can you penalize a quarterback for a low block when he is chasing the guy who intercepted his pass?! …

I could go on, but: Steelers 21, Seahawks 10.

It was the worst-officiated game in Super Bowl history, a fact you will not see acknowledged this week in San Francisco/San Jose/Santa Clara/Wherever ahead of the Carolina-Denver disagreement.

The NFL employs a battalion of death-eaters to swoop over the history books to devour the impure. But the death-eaters missed one guy: Bill Leavy, the game’s lead official.

So overcome by guilt and shame was Leavy, that at a Seahawks preseason game in 2010 to discuss rules changes, unprompted, he astonishingly owned up — in Seattle — to his misdeeds that afternoon at Detroit’s Ford Field.

“It was a tough thing for me,” Leavy told reporters at the Seahawks’ practice facility. “I kicked two calls in the fourth quarter, and I impacted the game, and as an official you never want to do that. It left me with a lot of sleepless nights, and I think about it constantly. I’ll go to my grave wishing that I’d been better. I know that I did my best at that time, but it wasn’t good enough.

“When we make mistakes, you got to step up and own them.”

Interesting he didn’t own it until Mike Holmgren left as coach. The NFL never booked Levy for another Seahawks game while The Big Show stomped the sidelines. Might have looked like the bear scene in “The Revenant.”

All the players and coaches from that team have moved on. Most of the fans who were here haven’t. But neither do they dwell, at least not since Pete Carroll has distracted them with four 10-win seasons in a row, two Super Bowl appearances and one championship, part of a 60-36 regular-season record and 8-4 in the playoffs.

A decade later, it is time to rehabilitate that Super Bowl run, at least to a place in the living room where it can be discussed.

It was a hell of a regular season, 13-3. With Walter Jones, Steve Hutchinson, Matt Hasselbeck and Shaun Alexander, the Seahawks pounded the Redskins and Panthers in the playoffs. They had a fair shot against a good but not great Steelers team led by a rookie galoot named Ben Roethlisberger. He completed nine passes. And won.

Officiating atrocities aside, the Seahawks made the Super Bowl in their 30th year. That doesn’t sound like much, but when a survey after 40 years of the NFL landscape is taken that includes the Carroll era, the Seahawks as a franchise have finally filled out the uniform.

The Seahawks’ three Super Bowl appearances tie them with the Cleveland/Los Angeles/St.Louis/Los Angeles Rams for 14th. Four teams have made eight appearances: Pittsburgh, Dallas, New England and now Denver. So the Seahawks are middling, but the NFL until the free-agency era began was lopsided.

The Seahawks’ lone Super Bowl win means they are one up on 13 NFL teams. Or, as John Clayton likes to say, let’s put it this way: In half a century of Super Bowls, nearly half the teams have failed to win one.

Four teams have never reached the Super Bowl: The Lions, Browns, Jaguars (1995 expansion) and Texans (2002 expansion).

If Super Bowl history is considered over the past 20 years, the Seahawks are wearing big boy pants. The demarcation is important, because after the 1993 collective bargaining agreement that permitted real free agency for the first time, the business of team-building changed so radically that measures of comparable success before 1995 are almost irrelevant.

It’s like the dead-ball, live-ball split in baseball’s history. The game was so changed the old standards were marginalized.

Since 1995, the first year of major player movement, New England has made seven Super Bowl appearances. Pittsburgh and Denver have made four. The Seahawks are tied with the New York Giants and Green Bay Packers at three. The Colts, Panthers, Ravens, Rams and 49ers have two.

It’s probably little solace this week to Seahawks fans, who at this time a year ago were hanging on to every word Marshawn Lynch wasn’t saying, but the franchise has moved to the fast lane.

Except for one bad referee and one bad play, they would be 3-0 in Super Bowls, the NFL’s leading mark.

So on the 10th anniversary Friday of the 2006 Super Bowl in Detroit, it’s time to take the game out of the attic and talk about it as if it no longer has cooties.

The 2015 loss? Let’s talk in 2025.

Art Thiel is co-founder of sportspressnw.com

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Shorecrest’s Emma Lund and Edmonds-Woodway’s Jane Hanson fight for possession during the game on Sept. 23, 2025 in Shoreline, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shorecrest girls soccer overcomes early slip-up to salvage draw

Scots extend undefeated streak to five with 1-1 tie against Edmonds-Woodway on Tuesday.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Sept. 14-20

Who won last week’s vote? Arlington, Everett, King’s, Monroe, Terrace athletes nominated this week.

Monroe sophomore Shannara Peebles serves the ball during a District 1 3A quarterfinals match against Monroe in Stanwood, Wash., on Tuesday, Nov. 12, 2024. The Spartans won 3-1. (Taras McCurdie / The Herald)
Monroe stays perfect Tuesday with sweep of Everett

Snohomish’s Heidi Chambers dominates as Snohomish beats Marysville Pilchuck 3-0.

Jackson, Mountlake Terrace, Lake Stevens each win 7-0

Seven different players punch in goals for Timberwolves on Tuesday.

Glacier Peak wins in near sweep of Lake Stevens

The Grizzlies win 11 of 12 events to knock off Vikings Tuesday.

Members of the Shorewood High School boys cross country team lift the 3A district trophy at the District 1/2 Cross Country Championships at Lakewood High School on Nov. 2, 2024. Max Billett (center with trophy) bested teammate Otto Erhart (left of Billett) to win the individual medal. (Taras McCurdie / The Herald)
Shorewood dominates league meet

The Stormrays crossed the finish line Tuesday in bunches against Lynnwood and Mariner.

J.P. Crawford (3) of the Seattle Mariners celebrates with Dominic Canzone (8) of the Seattle Mariners after hitting a grand slam in the second inning against the Houston Astros at Daikin Park on Sunday, Sept. 21, 2025, in Houston. (Tim Warner / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Mariners near AL West title after sweeping Astros

Magic numbers, odds, tiebreakers in play this week.

Lake Stevens volleyball sweeps Glacier Peak to stay undefeated

Cascade and Stanwood also notch sweeps Monday.

Jackon’s Samuel Song hits the ball during a doubles match against Kamiak on Monday, Sept. 30, 2024 in Mill Creek. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Jackson takes down Shorewood in battle of unbeatens

The Timberwolves improve to 9-0 while the Stormrays drop to 7-1 after Monday’s 6-1 meet.

The Seattle Kraken begin the NHL regular season on Oct. 9. (Steph Chambers / Getty Images / The Athletic)
Seattle Kraken enter season with low expectations

Over the summer, only three fan bases had less confidence in their… Continue reading

Seahawks cornerback Derion Kendrick shouts during Seattle's game against the New Orleans Saints on Sunday, Sept. 21, 2025 at Lumen Field in Seattle, Washington. (Steph Chambers / Getty Images / The Athletic)
Yet another Seahawks DB is shining off the bench

It is hard to imagine any member of the Seattle Seahawks being… Continue reading

Silvertips forward Zackary Shantz looks for a pass around Wild defenseman Darian Rolsing during Everett's 4-3 shootout win against Wenatchee at Angel of the Winds Arena on Sept. 20, 2025. Shantz had a natural hat trick to overcome a 3-0 deficit and force overtime. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Shantz hat trick sparks comeback win for Tips

Everett wins season-opener 4-3 in shootout against Wenatchee on Saturday.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.