BCS title game: More like stale leftovers

NEW ORLEANS — Like an old nightmare, the Alabama Crimson Tide defense just kept coming and coming after No. 1-ranked LSU.

And speaking of old nightmares, Tigers, how’s about that Jordan Jefferson?

Cheered and scorned — sometimes on the same night — by LSU fans throughout his four seasons, quarterback Jefferson found himself Monday in the crosshairs of Alabama’s ferocious defensive attack.

He froze in his tracks. And with him, rigor mortis consumed the LSU offense.

Five field goals by the Crimson Tide’s Jeremy Shelley proved to be more than enough.

Alabama’s 21-0 victory over the Tigers gave the Tide its second Bowl Championship Series title in the past three seasons. It also avenged a 9-6 overtime loss to LSU during the regular season.

Rematch?

This was more like stale leftovers.

For the first 55 minutes Monday at the Superdome, the two best teams in college football again failed to score a touchdown.

But the differences this time were significant. With more than six weeks to prepare for the revenge match, Alabama coach Nick Saban deftly put together a game plan that stifled LSU in every way.

Jefferson’s running ability? Saban had someone in crimson waiting at every turn.

The Tigers’ option game, said to have blossomed in the second half of the season? Saban had it covered, sideline to sideline, like a glove.

The Alabama offense, which sputtered in the game at Tuscaloosa? By simply giving sophomore quarterback A.J. McCarron more protection, the Tide was able to throw for 234 yards and move the first-down chains all night long.

The LSU defense didn’t play poorly. But with Jefferson and the offense providing nothing, it failed to get a turnover or force the Tide to punt more than twice.

Why LSU coach Les Miles didn’t go to his bench and change quarterbacks is a mystery. While Jefferson was sitting out the first four games of the season with legal troubles, senior Jarrett Lee became the LSU starter and led the Tigers to significant victories — beating Rose Bowl champ Oregon and Orange Bowl victor West Virginia in September.

But when Lee, known as the better passer, threw two ill-advised interceptions in the November game at Alabama, Miles lifted him in favor of Jefferson.

Lee, for some reason, was seldom seen on the field again.

If he was ever going to return to the huddle, Monday was the night. At halftime, Jefferson had only 26 passing yards and LSU had but one first down.

More than that, though, the Crimson Tide defense was draped across the line of scrimmage, daring Jefferson to try to beat it with his passing.

No chance.

While Jefferson looked like the proverbial deer caught in the BCS headlights, McCarron was coolly either handing the ball to Trent Richardson or Eddie Lacy or finding his tight end, Brad Smelley.

McCarron, who hails from Mobile, Ala., had played “scared” in the November game, according to some. But there were times Monday when he seemed the most confident player on the field.

He finished with 234 yards passing, completing 23 of 34 with no interceptions. And though LSU would stiffen and force Alabama to settle for field goals, the score kept mounting.

McCarron was selected the game’s most outstanding offensive player.

LSU, to be blunt, had no outstanding offensive players. But Miles will have the entire off-season to ponder that.

It was the sixth time that Miles and Saban had matched wits on the football field. Miles had won the previous two, but the series is now tied at three apiece.

Whatever shortcomings Alabama was alleged to have — its inferior outside speed, its field goal kicking, McCarron, et al — Saban silenced them in the Tide’s preparation.

LSU’s Darth Vader feelings about Saban will continue. He coached the Tigers to the 2003 BCS title, before leaving for the NFL’s Miami Dolphins and — traitorously, LSU fans say — returning to coach at a bitter rival.

After Monday’s game, Miles said, “I told the team after the game I did not see it coming. And that’s my fault.”

Rematch?

Like a lot of sequels, Monday’s failed to inspire.

But the Tide rolled like a convincing champion.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Marysville Getchell boys wrestling stays perfect

The Chargers win a double dual on Thursday night to start the season 7-0.

Jackson dominates multi-team meet

The Timberwolves win nine events in Lynnwood on Thursday.

Monroe boys start season 4-0 with strong finish

The Bearcats took down the Meadowdale 68-56 on Wednesday thanks to multiple quality contributions.

Edmonds-Woodway boys wrestling moves to 3-0 in duals

The Warriors force two technical falls against Woodinville to stay perfect on Wednesday.

Seahawks defensive lineman Jarran Reed closes in on quarterback Philip Rivers during a game in 2018. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks expect a Disney movie against them Sunday

Philip Rivers, a 44-year-old grandfather, could play for the visiting Colts in Seattle.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Nov. 30 – Dec. 6

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Nov. 30-Dec. 6. Voting closes… Continue reading

Glacier Peak freshman Aliyah Jazmin (right) positions herself in front of Shorewood junior Karmin Kasberg during the Grizzlies' 77-46 win against the Stormrays at Glacier Peak High School on Dec. 9, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Glacier Peak girls basketball rolls past Shorewood

The new-look Grizzlies remain undefeated with 77-46 win on Tuesday.

Shorewood’s Maya Glasser reaches up to try and block a layup by Shorecrest’s Anna Usitalo during the 3A district playoff game on Friday, Feb. 14, 2025 in Shoreline, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shorecrest girls pick up first win in nailbiter

Anna Usitalo’s 24 points paced the Scots on the road.

Shorewood outlasts Jackson in tight meet

Prep boys wrestling roundup for Tuesday, Dec. 9: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To… Continue reading

Kamiak and Shorecrest sweep multi-team meets

Prep boys swimming roundup for Tuesday, Dec. 9: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To… Continue reading

Seahawks center Jalen Sundell (61) blocks for running back Kenneth Walker III in a game against the Arizona Cardinals on Sunday, Nov. 9, 2025 at Lumen Field in Seattle, Washington. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Jalen Sundell returns to Seahawks practice, position unclear

Jalen Sundell is returning. To play what position? Coach Mike Macdonald said… Continue reading

Seattle Seahawks receiver Jaxon Smith-Njigba scores a touchdown against the Atlanta Falcons at Mercedes-Benz Stadium on Sunday, Dec. 7, 2025. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Soaring Seahawks eye NFC’s top playoff seed

At 10-3, the Seattle Seahawks are practically a lock to be one… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.