Blame Holmgren for Hawks’ poor ‘D’

  • Scott M. Johnson / Pro Football Report
  • Thursday, November 30, 2000 9:00pm
  • Sports

Sooner or later, the fingers will point toward Steve Sidwell. When you’re the coordinator of the league’s worst defense, eventually some blame comes your way.

But the culprit for Seattle’s porous defense this season might actually be on the other side of the ball. Mike Holmgren, not Sidwell, is to blame for the defensive woes. It was Holmgren who decided to transfuse his defense with younger bodies at the expense of some very serviceable veterans.

Just look at some of the defensive players Holmgren sent packing.

Sam Adams is a key member of the NFL’s top-ranked defense in Baltimore, and his addition has been a big reason why defensive end Rob Burnett is on pace to set a career high in sacks. Adams has also been a valuable run-stuffer for the Ravens – something the Seahawks have been missing this season.

Sorry, the video player failed to load.(Error Code: 101102)

Then there’s Brian Walker, who is the starting strong safety for Miami’s stingy defense. He was named the AFC’s defensive player of the week following a 17-7 win over San Diego three weeks ago. With the subpar play of Seattle’s safeties this season, Walker probably would have been an improvement at that position.

As for linebacker Darrin Smith, he moved into the New Orleans Saints’ starting lineup in Week 7, and the Saints have gone 6-1 since. Although he is playing out of position at middle linebacker, Smith is leading the team in tackles.

Defensive end Phillip Daniels has six sacks for the Chicago Bears, more than any Seahawks defensive lineman this season. And safety Darryl Williams ranks second on the Cincinnati Bengals in tackles and interceptions.

Daniels was the only one Holmgren wanted to keep, yet he and Williams are the only ones not playing for a playoff contender. To be fair, Holmgren’s decisions regarding Adams and Smith had more to do with personality than play on the field. And Walker spent all of 1999 trying to overcome a recurring hamstring problem.

But it’s still worth noting that the former Seahawks have moved on and are doing well. And their replacements aren’t.

Even though Holmgren has expressed regret over losing Daniels – quick to add, however, that the Seahawks didn’t have the cap room to pay the $25 million he received from Chicago – the defensive end is the only one who has been even adequately replaced. Second-year player Lamar King has been the Seahawks’ most consistent defensive lineman this season, even if he isn’t putting up Daniels’ sack numbers.

The other fill-ins are struggling. Middle linebacker George Koonce has been a warrior, but his best days are behind him. Safety Reggie Tongue, Holmgren’s prized free agent, has been so slow to pick up Sidwell’s system that he was benched in favor of Kerry Joseph. And Adams’ replacement, Riddick Parker, doesn’t have the size to demand double teams or stop the run.

Holmgren had the opportunity to get some defensive help in the draft, with BYU middle linebacker Rob Morris and Boston College defensive tackle Chris Hovan on the board for both of the Seahawks’ first-round picks. By the time Seattle addressed its defensive holes, the Seahawks had to settle for lesser-known players like Isaiah Kacyvenski, Tim Watson and John Hilliard.

Ask Holmgren, and he’ll tell you the team is generally better off in the long run for losing some of its defensive starters. And he’d point out that the offensive players drafted – namely Shaun Alexander, Chris McIntosh and Darrell Jackson – have shown promise.

Maybe the moves will pay off at some point. But for now, the current Seahawks will have to spend the postseason watching their former teammates on television.

  • Kickoff: 10:05 a.m. Sunday.

  • TV/radio: CBS-TV (Channel 7); KIRO radio (710 AM)

  • Stars to watch: Seahawks – One of the Seahawks’ constants this season has been Jon Kitna, who has played in all but one game despite being benched in Week 6. The most effective offensive player has been Ricky Watters, who needs 129 rushing yards to hit the 1,000-yard mark for the sixth consecutive season. Watters needs 46 yards to become the 13th player in NFL history to surpass the 10,000-yard milestone for a career. OLBs Chad Brown (six sacks) and Anthony Simmons (110 tackles) have been the anchors on defense.

    Falcons – QB Doug Johnson is expected to make his first start, replacing Everett native Chris Chandler. RB Jamal Anderson is running behind a makeshift offensive line, but he’s still in position to hit the 1,000-yard mark. Anderson needs 179 more yards to get there. CB Ray Buchanan ranks third in the NFL with six interceptions, and he has been credited with 19 passes defensed. K Morten Andersen has scored at least one point in 266 consecutive games, an NFL record. He currently ranks third on the NFL’s all-time scoring list, with 1,916 points.

  • Breaking down the game: This could develop into the Jamal Anderson-Ricky Watters show.

    Both teams should rely on their running games. Atlanta will go with a rookie quarterback who is making his first start, while the Seahawks are probably better off testing the Falcons’ run defense instead of their big-play cornerbacks.

    To the Seahawks’ advantage is the play of their offensive line. The big guys up front have been opening up holes for Watters, who has taken advantage to the tune of 4.4 yards per carry – his highest average since 1993. Anderson, behind a young line riddled with injuries, has been held to 3.7 yards per rush.

    Both defenses will probably stack things up front and dare the opposing quarterback to beat them. For this week at least, the Seahawks have an advantage there with the relatively experienced Jon Kitna.

    Despite featuring two of the NFL’s bottom three defenses, this one might be light on offense.

  • Pick: Falcons lose, 10-9.

  • Injury report: Seahawks – QB Brock Huard (bruised kidney) is doubtful; DE Matt LaBounty (concussion) is questionable. Falcons – T Bob Whitfield (neck) is questionable; DT Ed Jasper (hand), S Johndale Carty (knee), WR Brian Finneran (back) and TE Reggie Kelly (knee) are probable.

  • Little-known fact: The last time Mike Holmgren was part of a coaching staff that lost nine games in a season, he was a 20-something assistant for Sacred Heart Cathedral High School in San Francisco.

  • Arizona (3-9) at Cincinnati (2-10), 10 a.m. Sunday: What’s more pathetic? The fact that Cardinal fans are happy to have Jake Plummer back or Bengals fans praying that Scott Mitchell’s knee can hold up? Although both these teams figure to pick among the top five selections in next spring’s draft, they’ll both pass on Drew Brees. Unfortunately for both cities, they’ve already invested too much in quarterbacks Plummer and Akili Smith. Too bad we’ll never know how good David Boston and Peter Warrick could have been. Pick: Cardinals lose, 9-6.

  • San Francisco (4-8) at San Diego (1-11), 1:05 p.m. Sunday: Smell a pattern here? That collective sigh came from the Southern California area, where the best football this season was being played by Cal State Northridge. At least the Chargers are off the hook following a win over Kansas City. And the 49ers are off the hook from becoming San Diego’s first victim. Welcome back to the loser’s bracket, Lightning Bolts. Pick: Chargers lose, 24-10.

  • Cleveland (3-10) at Jacksonville (5-7), 1:15 p.m. Sunday: By comparison, this Jaguars team is a Super Bowl contender. Oh, wait. They lost to the lowly Seahawks, didn’t they? The Browns are beyond lowly, in part because their quarterback is out for the season. Then again, they were pretty abysmal when he was healthy, too. Pick: Browns lose, 20-6.
    Talk to us

    > Give us your news tips.

    > Send us a letter to the editor.

    > More Herald contact information.

  • More in Sports

    Simon VanderWel of King's throws the shot put during the May 29-31, 2025 Class 1A state track and field meet at Zaepfel Stadium in Yakima.  (Photo courtesy of Donna Beard)
    King’s wins boys and girls state high school track titles

    King’s High School brought home two state titles on Saturday,… Continue reading

    Kimberly Beard of King's prepares to release a throw during the Washington Hammer State Championships at The Evergreen State College in Olympia on Sunday, June 1, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Donna Beard)
    King’s Kimberly Beard wins state hammer throw title

    Kimberly Beard of King’s High School dominated the girls division… Continue reading

    Lake Stevens junior Keira Isabelle Tupua winds up to throw the discus at the WIAA Track & Field State Championships in Tacoma, Washington on May 30, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
    Keira Isabelle Tupua overcomes family turmoil at track & field state

    The Lake Stevens junior places top four in two events while missing her biggest supporter.

    Everett AquaSox catcher Andrew Miller prepares to bat against the Spokane Indians at Funko Field on June 1, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Evan Morud, Everett AquaSox)
    AquaSox flex muscles in 13-4 victory over Spokane

    Powered by five home runs, including three consecutively, the Everett… Continue reading

    Shorecrest senior Jackson Sketchley winds up for his third attempt, where he set the winning mark of 194 feet-eight inches, in the 3A Boys Javelin Throw at the WIAA Track & Field State Championships at Mount Tahoma High School in Tacoma, Washington on May 31, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
    Shorecrest’s Sketchley wins 3A Boys Javelin at state

    The senior is the lone 3A boys athlete from the area to win a title.

    Shorewood’s Niki Genadiev and Daniel Bruno runs after the ball during the 3A state championship game against Mercer Island on Saturday, May 31, 2025 in Puyallup, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Shorewood “family” comes up short in state title game

    The Stormrays couldn’t finish a late rally in a 3-2 loss to Mercer Island.

    Glacier Peak’s Mateo Ganje, left, receives the baton from Isaiah Owens in the 4A boys 4x100 relay final on Saturday, May 31, 2025 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Glacier Peak’s Ganje goes three-for-three on podium

    Glacier Peak boys, Lake Stevens girls 4x100 each place second at 4A state track championships.

    Runners pass by the stands at Mt. Tahoma high school in the 3A girls 3200 meter final on Saturday, May 31, 2025 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Shorewood’s Enriquez claims girls 3A pole vault crown

    The senior is the lone 3A girls athlete from the area to win a title.

    Kamiak’s Miller Warme yells as he crosses the finish line in the 4A Boys 110 Hurdles final on Friday, May 30, 2025 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Kamiak’s Warme, Arlington’s Scott take third in 4A Track

    The Knights hurdler and Eagles thrower were two of seven area athletes to reach podium.

    Shorewood’s Jaden Marlow looks to his left as he crosses the finish line in the 3A Boys 110 Hurdles final on Friday, May 30, 2025 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Shorewood’s Marlow earns two top-four places at state track

    The junior takes fourth in the 110 hurdles and third in the pole vault.

    Shorewood’s Niki Genadiev takes a penalty kick during the 3A state semifinal game against Ingraham on Friday, May 30, 2025 in Puyallup, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
    Genadiev nets hat trick, Shorewood advances to title game

    Niki Genadiev scored all of No. 1 Shorewood’s goals in a 3-1 state semis win over No. 12 Ingraham.

    Jeff Page spent 47 years coaching track & field at Lake Stevens, including 32 as the program's head coach. The boys and girls teams totaled 33 Wesco titles, and the boys won the 2022 4A State Championship during his stint as head coach. (Photo courtesy of Jeff Page)
    Turning the Page: Lake Stevens track coach set to retire

    Jeff Page to close out 47-year coaching career with Vikings after state championships.

    Support local journalism

    If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.