‘Crunch’ time for Mariners fighting for roster spots

PEORIA, Ariz. — The spring calendar shows an open date Tuesday for the Seattle Mariners in their 33-game Cactus League schedule. It’s what comes next that matters most.

“For our competitions in camp,” manager Scott Servais said, “it is crunch time. The fifth starter spot. Where we’re at at first base. Backup catcher, that’s a competition there.”

And the bullpen. Don’t forget the bullpen.

Even with the herd of relief candidates thinning notably in recent days, there’s still at least one spot still available, probably for a right-hander, in the seven-man unit.

That there is competition at backup catcher rates as a mild surprise and underscores how quickly Rob Brantly made an impression after being acquired March 12 in a waiver claim from the Chicago White Sox.

“The reports coming in were that he was an offensive player,” Servais said. “That he had success at the minor-league levels with the bat. Defensively, he’s been better (than expected).

“He’s made a little adjustment with his throwing. Just a minor tweak that Dan Wilson and I threw at him, and he took it and ran with it. I like the player. I like what he brings. It makes it interesting for us. Another option.”

The Mariners initially viewed Brantly as spring depth in the event of an injury to either starter Chris Iannetta or projected backup Steve Clevenger. If the latter two remained healthy, they’d try to retain Brantly by sneaking him through waivers.

Not anymore; Brantly has a chance to win a job.

“Both of those guys are out of options,” Servias said of Brantly and Clevenger, “so you have to make your choice.”

Clevenger has seemingly done nothing to jeopardize his status. His defense has also been better than anticipated, and he drew high marks Saturday from Servias for his handling of Felix Hernandez.

“He had a lot of challenging balls to block,” Servais said. “He not only blocked them, he kept them very close to him. We feel this guy has improved.

“When we first acquired him, I called him, and I said, ‘Hey, man, I know you can hit a little bit. You’ve got to catch.’ He’s been open to the things that Dan Wilson and I have thrown at him, but there still is competition.”

Clevenger and Brantly each offer the benefit of being a left-handed complement to Iannetta, who is a right-handed hitter. Whoever wins the job figures to start 60-plus games; Iannetta has never started more than 105 games in his 10-year career.

The Mariners are approaching decision time regarding a right-handed-hitting first baseman to serve as Adam Lind’s platoon partner because Dae-Ho Lee has a late March opt-out clause in his minor-league contract.

The choice initially seemed to be between Lee and Jesus Montero, who is out of options. But both have been outplayed by Stefen Romero, who has an option remaining. Keeping Romero, though, means the club risks losing the other two.

The Mariners, by their actions, continue to indicate Luis Sardinas is their choice over Chris Taylor and Shawn O’Malley as the roster’s utility infielder. Sardinas started Monday in center field and will likely draw future duty at first base.

“Being a super super-utility player,” Servais said, “is a plus. If you have to pinch-run late in the game (for Lind or the other first baseman), you burn two players. You not only have to use a pinch-runner, you have to put a guy in there at first.”

That won’t be necessary if Sardinas proves capable of playing first base.

Six of the seven bullpen spots appear set with closer Steve Cishek and three other right-handers: Joaquin Benoit, Tony Zych and Joel Peralta; and two lefties in Vidal Nuno and Mike Montgomery.

If lefty Charlie Furbush beats the odds and is ready by opening day, the Mariners — if they want to keep their preferred mix of five righties and two lefties — face a choice between Montgomery, who is out of options, and Nuno, who has one left.

The Mariners could opt for Nathan Karns as their fifth righty reliever if he gets beaten out by lefty James Paxton in the competition for final rotation spot.

General manager Jerry Dipoto recently raised that possibility.

“We want to take the 12 guys who give us the best chance win day after day,” Dipoto said. “We feel that, at any certain point, those two guys (Karns and Paxton) are going to be among our best 12.”

The Mariners have four other right-handed bullpen candidates still in camp: Donn Roach, Casey Coleman, Mayckol Guaipe and Blake Parker.

(Joe Wieland is still in camp but appears ticketed for the rotation at Triple-A Tacoma. Reliever Justin De Fratus returned last week on a minor-league deal but isn’t viewed as likely candidate at the start of the season.)

Parker began the spring with five scoreless outings but raised concerns Saturday with a shaky performance when brought back after one day of rest.

“He was down a lot last year (because of an elbow injury),” Servais said. “We’ve taken it easy on how much we’ve used him and how much rest he’s gotten between his outings.

“The last time out, we brought him back one day sooner, and he wasn’t quite as sharp. But he has had a good spring. He’s opened some eyes.”

Guaipe and Coleman have each pitched better after some early wobbles, but Roach is emerging as a serious late candidate.

Once slotted for the Tacoma rotation, Roach has eight scoreless innings in his last three outings. He closed out Monday’s 6-3 victory over the Dodgers with three brisk innings.

“He can give you length,” Servais said. “We want to keep him stretched out so that if it doesn’t work in the bullpen, he can be a (starting) option for us in Tacoma. Yes, he is in the mix.”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Silvertips goalie Raiden LeGall (right) stands with his hometown goalie coach Tim Morison on the ice at Angel of the Winds Arena. (Photo courtesy of Tim Morison)
Silvertips goalie raises thousands of dollars for mental health causes

Raiden LeGall and his hometown goalie coach’s custom merchandise fundraiser grosses over $12k

Lake Stevens’ Keira Isabelle Tupua reacts to beating Glacier Peak on Friday, Jan. 24, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lake Stevens girls improve to 5-1

The Vikings had four players score in double digits in their league opener.

Winter prep sports roundup teaser.
Kamiak boys swimming picks up two wins

Edmonds-Woodway, Lake Stevens and Cascade also win swimming duals on Tuesday night.

Wortham’s 31 leads Stanwood girls basketball past Shorecrest on Tuesday

Prep roundup for Monday, Dec. 15: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Dec. 7-13

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Dec. 6-13. Voting closes at… Continue reading

The Washington men's soccer team celebrates winning the national championship after a 3-2 overtime victory over North Carolina State on Monday, Dec. 15, 2025 at First Horizon Stadium in Cary, North Carolina. (Photo courtesy of Washington Athletics)
Washington men’s soccer claims program’s first national title

Harrison Bertos nets the winning goal in overtime as Huskies win 3-2 over NC State

Silvertips forward Jesse Heslop (left) pushes through the neutral zone during Everett's 9-4 win against Victoria at Angel of the Winds Arena on Oct. 4, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Silvertips display ‘versatility’ in comeback win vs. Spokane

After mistakes put team in 4-2 hole, Everett climbs back for 6-4 win on Saturday.

King's senior Kaitlin Cramer (right, in black) receives a pass from senior teammate Kaleo Anderson (left) during the Knights' 66-53 win against Kamiak at Kamiak High School on Dec. 12, 2025. (Herald Staff)
King’s girls basketball pulls away from Kamiak

The Knights utilize a fourth-quarter run to win 66-53 in Friday’s back-and-forth contest.

Seahawks kicker Jason Meyers boots one of his six field goals against the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday, Dec. 14, 2025 at Lumen Field in Seattle, Washington. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks coach Mike Macdonald credits analyst for timeout usage

Mike Macdonald hands out game balls in the locker room following Seahawks… Continue reading

Arlington wins Saturday’s A-Town Throwdown

Prep boys wrestling roundup for Saturday, Dec. 13: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To… Continue reading

Glacier Peak wins Everett Tournament

Everett’s Cianega sisters win titles at 190 and 235 Saturday.

Jackson junior Jaelyn Phaysith pressures Highline's quarterback into a throwaway during the Timberwolves' 23-7 win against the Pirates at Pop Keeney Stadium on Dec. 11, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Jackson girls flag football among Wesco pioneers

In first WIAA season, the Timberwolves show progress in 23-7 win against Highline on Thursday.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.