Different casts

  • By Roger Phillips The Idaho Statesman
  • Wednesday, April 20, 2011 12:01am
  • Sports

Spring can be a cruel season for fly anglers. Rivers are either closed to fishing or running high and murky.

This year¹s snowpack is ranging from 100 to 160 percent of normal, so it¹s likely many rivers will be tough to fish even when they reopen Memorial Day weekend.

Many fly angle

rs head to reservoirs in the spring, but others sit on the sidelines because lakes and reservoirs require a different set of skills, tactics and gear.

For Mike Benbow’s Fly Fishing blog click <a href=" http://www.heraldnet.com/section/BLOG50
“>here

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

But if you learn a few basic lake techniques, you will be surprised how effective you can be at catching fish.

Spring is usually the best time of year to fish stillwater because fish are waking up from the long winter and are hungry and aggressive.

Water temperatures and conditions are prime for trout. The ones that live in lakes tend to be of larger average size than those in rivers, and you can catch some real monsters.

For a look at what kind of gear you’ll need to go fly fishing, click here

Lloyd Rogers of Boise has been flyfishing for trout in stillwater for more than 40 years.

The 73-year-old spends about 100 days a year fishing lakes and reservoirs in several states. He often sees fly anglers making the common mistake of fishing the middle of a lake with a floating line and dragging a fly behind them in hopes of getting a strike.

Some people are overwhelmed by the size of a lake and don¹t know where to fish.

Rogers says an easy way to narrow it down is fish areas that are 10 feet deep or shallower. He fishes from a float tube or pontoon boat and casts toward the shore and strips his fly back.

Trout often feed in as little as a foot of water, and, unlike river fish that are often keying in on one insect, lake fish tend to be opportunists that will eat whatever is in front of them.

Rogers focuses on two key areas: the shallows along a shoreline and the weed beds in 4 to 6 feet of water.

He looks for trout feeding on bait fish in the shallows and on insects in or near the weed beds.

Mike Smith of Eagle is another angler who exclusively fishes stillwater, and he targets big trout.

“If you want to catch a better quality of fish, you¹ve got to fish the lakes,” he said.

Smith likes minnow patterns, and in spring he often uses a tandem rig with a larger fly up front like a minnow or leech pattern trailed by a smaller fly that imitates an aquatic insect.

He fishes sinking lines with about 10 feet of fluorocarbon leader and frequently fishes a 2X or 3X tippet (about a 6- to 8-pound test).

He ties his flies to his leader with a loop knot, such as a Rapala knot, which gives the flies better action than a clinch knot or similar knot that tightens against the eye of the hook.

Smith warns that while a double-fly rig can be effective, it can also be risky because it leaves a hook dangling when you¹re fighting a fish, which can snag on weeds, rocks, a log or other structure.

Both anglers use depth finders and pause and count after a cast so they know to what depth their fly has sunk before they start stripping it back (to learn how, read about sinking lines in the basic stillwater gear section later).

They also alternate the stripping speed depending on water conditions and the fish¹s mood. In early spring when water temperatures are below 45 degrees, fish tend to be lethargic and less likely to chase a fly that¹s quickly retrieved.

When temperatures reach the high-40s and low-50s, trout are more aggressive, and you can use a faster strip.

Another key to stillwater trout fishing is detecting strikes, which can be more subtle than many anglers realize. Keep your rod tip in the water or within inches of the surface and maintain constant contact with your fly.

If you feel any resistance when stripping, set the hook. If you learn to strip strike, which is setting the hook by pulling the line rather than lifting the rod, you can keep your fly at about the same depth if you miss a strike.

Both men said fish are likely to cruise the shallows during early morning and evening, then move into deeper water during the day.

Neither Rogers nor Smith spends much time fishing deeper than 10 feet. They say fish will rest in deeper water, but do most of their feeding in shallower water.

To find fish, Rogers said he will typically start at the downwind end of a lake or reservoir because that¹s where the food usually accumulates.

Smith said if he¹s on an unfamiliar lake, he will do a quick pass and watch his fish finder for schools of fish before he starts casting.

Both spend lots of time on the water because they never know when fish will go on the bite.

“You¹ve got to give it all day,” Smith said.

It¹s common to have the best fishing of the day during a span of an hour or two, and it¹s not always during those prime morning and evening periods.

Smith said his best fishing tends to be on cloudy or overcast days. Storms can put fish off the bite momentarily, but they usually resume feeding shortly after it passes.

Both men use flies that imitate a fairly small variety of a trout¹s diet, including bait fish, leeches and aquatic insects like chironomids, damselflies and mayflies.

Basic stillwater gear
Æ Float tube or pontoon boat. They¹re easily portable and inexpensive. They not only get you where the fish are, but put you in the right casting position to catch them.
Æ Sinking lines. Learning all the different sinking lines can be complex and almost worthy of a separate article, but here are the basics. Sinking fly lines differ in how many inches they sink per second, which is rated 1 though 6 and often written in Roman numerals. The number equates to how quickly the line sinks, so a Type 5 or (Type V), would sink about 5 inches per second.
Each line also has a certain depth that is its sweet spot. Water gets denser at depths, so the line tends to stall at certain depths. The stall depth for a Type 1 line is 2 to 4 feet, and a Type 7 will stall at 15 to 25 feet.
You will usually see a Type 1 line referred to as ³intermediate,² which can be confusing because it has a sink rate of about an inch per second.
Intermediate lines are effective for fishing the shallows, or when fish are cruising near the surface.
Light and heavy lines have their pros and cons. A light line sinks very slowly, so it takes a long time to reach fish holding in deeper water. A heavier line will keep sinking even as you strip it, so it¹s hard to keep your fly in shallow water and more prone to sinking to the bottom and snagging.
Type 3 is a popular all-around line because it sinks reasonably fast and stays in water from 5 to 10 feet deep, which is usually a good range for fly anglers in most lakes.
Æ Floating line. This is what you want for dry fly fishing, which is still an option on stillwater. You can also fish a weighted fly with floating line and get it down to a reasonable depth, but weighting a fly changes its action when it¹s retrieved. As a rule of thumb, a sinking line is more effective because the fly and line stay at about the same depth when you retrieve them, but with a weighted fly under a floating line, the fly rises through the water column as it¹s stripped.
Æ Depth finder. Most serious stillwater anglers use a depth finder. You can buy one for less than $100, and there are models designed for float tubes or pontoon boats. They let you know the depth, where fish are located and whether the bottom is muddy, rocky or weedy.
Æ Flies. Here¹s an open secret about stillwater fishing ‹ you don¹t need a big selection for lakes and reservoirs. About a half dozen patterns will do in most situations.
Here Mike Smith¹s favorite stillwater flies: chub minnow imitation, pheasant tail, Rickard¹s stillwater nymph, black and brown seal buggers, burgundy stillwater bugger, and a damsel nymph.
Æ Five-weight rods are the most popular for river fishing, but most lake anglers prefer a 6- or 7-weight rod.
They cast the heavier sinking lines better, handle wind better, and can pull heavy fish out of the weeds, or keep them from going into them.
Serious lake anglers usually carry more than one rod with each rigged with a different line.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Kamiak’s Miller Warme yells as he crosses the finish line in the 4A Boys 110 Hurdles final on Friday, May 30, 2025 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Kamiak’s Warme, Arlington’s Scott take third in 4A Track

The Knights hurdler and Eagles thrower were two of seven area athletes to reach podium.

Shorewood’s Jaden Marlow looks to his left as he crosses the finish line in the 3A Boys 110 Hurdles final on Friday, May 30, 2025 in Tacoma, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shorewood’s Marlow earns two top four places at track states

The junior takes fourth in the 110 hurdles and third in the pole vault.

Shorewood’s Niki Genadiev takes a penalty kick during the 3A state semifinal game against Ingraham on Friday, May 30, 2025 in Puyallup, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Genadiev nets hat trick, Shorewood advances to title game

Niki Genadiev scored all of No. 1 Shorewood’s goals in a 3-1 state semis win over No. 12 Ingraham.

Jackson baseball players cheer before starting their next exercise during practice on Wednesday, May 28, 2025 in Mill Creek, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Jackson baseball’s bond of ‘brothers’ carries team to semis

The Timberwolves will play Friday for a spot in the Class 4A title game.

Jeff Page spent 47 years coaching track & field at Lake Stevens, including 32 as the program's head coach. The boys and girls teams totaled 33 Wesco titles, and the boys won the 2022 4A State Championship during his stint as head coach. (Photo courtesy of Jeff Page)
Turning the Page: Lake Stevens track coach set to retire

Jeff Page to close out 47-year coaching career with Vikings after state championships.

Owen Murray signs his WHL Scholarship and Development Agreement with the Everett Silvertips, which selected him with the 31st overall pick in the 2025 WHL Prospects Draft. (Photo Courtesy: The Everett Silvertips)
Silvertips reach terms with second-round draft choice

Owen Murray, the 31st overall pick, signs a WHL Scholarship and Development Agreement.

Everett's Colt Emerson (1) celebrates with Lazaro Montes after the infielder's sacrifice fly lifted the AquaSox to a win in the 10th inning at Funko Field on Thursday, May 29, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Evan Morud / Everett AquaSox)
Colt Emerson Walks Off Spokane in 10

The Everett AquaSox overcome a 5-run deficit, win in extra innings.

The New York Knicks' Jalen Brunson (11) drives against the Indiana Pacers' Tyrese Haliburton (0) during the third quarter in Game Five of the Eastern Conference finals at Madison Square Garden on Thursday, May 29, 2025, in New York. (Al Bello / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Jalen Brunson gives Knicks new life against the Pacers

Jalen Brunson was being picked on defensively by the… Continue reading

Reid Nicol signs his WHL Scholarship and Development Agreement with the Everett Silvertips alongside his family on May 28, 2025. (Photo Courtesy: Everett Silvertips)
Silvertips sign top draft pick Reid Nicol

Everett selected the 15-year-old center with the fifth overall pick in the 2025 Draft on May 7.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for May 18-24

The Athlete of the Week nominees for May 18-24. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Prep state tournament results and schedule

Here’s a look at what’s happening this postseason.

Shorewood's Meiron Bereket dribbles past Bellevue's Masora Takashima during a 3A State boys soccer quarterfinal game on May 24, 2025 at Shoreline Stadium. (Qasim Ali / The Herald)
Shorewood boys soccer clinches first state semifinal in 11 years

The No. 1 Stormrays prevailed 7-6 in penalties over No. 8 Bellevue after a scoreless match.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.