Lone Lake is popular among fly fishers. (Mike Benbow photo)

Lone Lake is popular among fly fishers. (Mike Benbow photo)

Head to this Whidbey lake if you’re seeking peace and quiet

Lone Lake, a selective-rules fishery located near Bayview, offers small crowds and good fall fishing

By Mike Benbow / Special to The Herald

WHIDBEY ISLAND — Back in the 1990s, Lone Lake on Whidbey Island produced nice trout that mostly were caught and taken home every year by a small number of anglers who fished the 101-acre lake.

“I couldn’t help wondering how big the fish would get if Lone was a selective (regulations) fishery,” said Dale Dennis of Arlington, then the Conservation Committee chairman for the Evergreen Fly Fishing Club in Everett.

In 1997, Dennis worked with the state to have the regulations changed so that anglers couldn’t use bait, needed to use flies or lures with a single, barbless hook and could keep only one fish a day that was at least 18 inches in length.

The new rules worked, partly because the lake had a high nutrient count that produced a large number of insects for fish food. But it also produced significant weed growth that made boating difficult, so officials put a number of sterile grass carp into the lake to eat the weeds.

A nice rainbow trout is landed and released after taking a chironomid fished under a strike indicator. (Mike Benbow photo)

A nice rainbow trout is landed and released after taking a chironomid fished under a strike indicator. (Mike Benbow photo)

The carp have done their job too well and have essentially denuded the lake of weed growth other than algae, cutting back on the number and types of insects. But the lake has continued to have good numbers of Daphnia, tiny planktonic crustaceans that are available year-round and seem to sustain the fish quite well.

In recent years, the fish in Lone have averaged 15 to 18 inches in length and a few have grown to 20 inches and more. The lake suffered a lack of oxygen and a fish kill recently, but the problems have been fixed and the fishery is recovering well.

Lone remains one of the few fisheries in the region with special regulations and larger fish, and it’s location on southern Whidbey Island near the community of Bayview — which requires a ferry ride for many anglers — keeps the lake from being overrun.

It’s a good lake for fall fishing because many people are focused on hunting, so crowds are even less likely.

Jerry Buron tries to fish Lone at least one day each week unless the weather is too windy or too rainy. The lake is open year-round, so Buron’s trips usually stop only when the water gets too hot in the summer.

Buron likes Lone because it doesn’t get the crowds that visit Pass Lake, a selective-rules fishery in Skagit County that produces bigger fish. He also finds it calmer and quieter, noting that his enjoyment of a fishing trip involves more than just the number or size of the fish he catches.

Pass Lake, which is located along a major highway, is too noisy and too busy, Buron said. “I never have trouble finding parking at Lone,” he added.

Buron, of Marysville, is among many of the fly fishers who live off the island and enjoy fishing the lake.

On a recent trip he said he landed and released 10 fish, most of them around 12 to 13 inches long that were planted in the lake last spring.

His favorite fly was a small black leech with a fluorescent orange bead fished under a strike indicator about 5 to 6 feet down. He said the bead is easy to see in the water and appears to attract the fish. Others have done well fishing small chironomids, say a size 18, at similar depths.

Still others say there can be some good insect hatches in Lone in October and they can do pretty well on dry flies fished on the surface if they see insects hatching.

Either way, Lone can be a good lake to fish in the fall. It’s also a place to watch through the winter because it often picks up in February if there are a few warm, sunny days that can encourage an insect hatch.

Talk to us

More in Sports

A look at the Seattle Sounders’ new crest and secondary images unveiled on Tuesday. (Seattle Times photo)
Sounders unveil new crest, colors as 50th season approaches

The new look, which gives a nod to the past, will start being worn by the team next season.

Silvertips’ Andrew Petruk (26) fights for the puck during a game between the Everett Silvertips and Victoria Royals at the Angel of the Winds Arena on Saturday, Sept. 23, 2023. The Silvertips won, 5-3. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Some good, some bad for Silvertips in season-opening split

Everett was missing three key players over the weekend but significantly outshot its two opponents.

Washington's Sami Reynolds bats during a Women's College World Series game this past June in Oklahoma City. (UW Athletics photo)
The Herald’s 2022-23 Woman of the Year in Sports: Sami Reynolds

The Snohomish grad capped an outstanding five-year career with an All-American season and one of the biggest moments in UW history.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Sept. 18-24

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Sept. 18-24. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Prep roundup for Tuesday, Sept. 26

Prep roundup for Tuesday, Sept. 26: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

The 1987 Cascade boys soccer team poses for a photo in front of the Space Needle in Seattle. (County Sports Hall of Fame photo)
County Sports Hall of Fame Class of 2023 bio: 1987 Cascade boys soccer

The 1987 Cascade boys soccer team won the AAA title and kicked off a run of five straight appearances in the state title game.

Arlington’s Caleb Reed is thrown into the air by lineman Dylan Scott after scoring a touchdown against Ferndale on Friday, Sept. 22, 2023, at Arlington High School in Arlington, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Prep football power rankings after Week 4

Here are our top 8 local teams after all the action from Friday and Saturday.

Monroe’s Mason Davis (1) celebrates with Trent Bublitz (11) after Bublitz’s touchdown reception against Edmonds-Woodway on Friday, Oct. 14, 2022, at Edmonds School District Stadium in Edmonds, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Reader poll: Make your picks for Week 5 prep football games

Do you think you can beat the experts in our weekly high… Continue reading

Mike Thomas (6) owner of the Everett Royals, shares a laugh after practice at Archbishop Murphy High School on February 2, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Everett’s new arena football team announces owners, coach

The franchise had been shrouded in mystery since the league announced it was relaunching in April.

Most Read