Kwan never golden, but sometimes transcendant

  • Mark Starr Special to The Herald
  • Saturday, November 21, 2009 11:56pm
  • SportsSports

At its best, there is no sport to rival figure skating for sheer elegance and beauty. But when those five Olympic rings begin to squeeze, it can turn downright ugly.

I’ve seen ladies leap with insouciance and land with incredulity on their butts, men endure face-plants into the ice, ladies dropped from on high by a wobbly partner, dancers’ legs sliced open by their partner’s blade.

But for one night — one night only — I saw perfection. Okay, maybe only eight of the nine judges held up the perfect 6.0 mark for artistry, but the crowd’s judgment — 18,000 folks in delirium — confirmed that we had witnessed something of unsurpassed beauty.

Skating to the celestial notes of “Lyra Angelica”, Michelle Kwan never appeared ice-bound, seemingly floating above it until she soared with unrestrained joy toward the heavens. Afterwards, the 17-year-old Kwan said the music made her think of angels and clouds … “that I’m free and I’m going to cloud nine.”

Indeed there was only one thing wrong with Kwan’s bravura performance: it happened in the wrong place — Philadelphia rather than Nagano, Japan — and at the wrong time — the Olympic Trials rather than the Olympics, which would be held a month later. To win the Olympic gold medal — to fulfill her dream of etching her name in skating history as a legend — Kwan would have to go to cloud nine one more time.

She didn’t make it up there, perhaps not even to cloud eight. Kwan didn’t skate badly in Nagano. Skaters have won Olympic gold with worse performances. But while she didn’t make a single major error, caution ruled the night. Kwan didn’t soar, didn’t radiate joy and never left us breathless. Still, having already won the short program, she may have figured a competent skate would be enough to claim the gold.

What she didn’t figure on was 15-year-old Tara Lipinski hitting the ice like a house on fire. If Kwan was a throwback to the days when artistry was paramount, Lipinski was a harbinger of a new era where artistry took a back seat while jumps ruled the sport.

When Lipinski hit her trademark triple loop-triple loop combination, her smile was incandescent. Near the end of her program, Tara unleashed another dazzling, three-jump combination. And after her final spin, even before the crowd had erupted in tribute, Lipinski added a bravura bit of salesmanship. She raced across the ice at the judges, flashing a winner’s smile, her arms raised in triumph.

Six of the nine judges agreed. Kwan had to settle for silver and endure some relentless second-guessing. Lipinski had lived in the Olympic village, marched in Opening Ceremonies and fully engaged the Games. Kwan had isolated herself — all business, no play — as she had always done at competitions. Had Lipinski imbibed of the Olympic magic while Kwan had gone flat sitting in her hotel room?

That question would haunt Kwan over the next four years, during which she would win four more U.S. and three world crowns. Though she once again skated brilliantly at the U.S. championship, a month before the 2002 Salt Lake City Olympics, this time nobody wrote odes to her performance. She hadn’t repeated her mistake, her fans said, of peaking too early.

Nor would Kwan make the mistake of keeping her distance from the Games. She stayed in the Olympic village (or at least had a cameo there), marched in Opening Ceremonies and was conspicuous cheering on the Americans at a hockey game.

In the end, it made no difference. Kwan would once again win the short program. And once again, a young and less ballyhooed skater — Sarah Hughes — would rise to the occasion with the skate of her life and seize the gold medal.

This time Kwan not only lost, she looked lost. She landed her combination jump on two feet, then later fell on a triple flip. Sitting stunned on the ice, disbelief crept in her eyes. By the time she found her feet, the energy had been sucked out of her body, the smile wiped off her face. This time Kwan’s consolation prize would be colored bronze.

Kwan made it back to the Olympics once again in 2006, but, due to injury, left Italy without competing. She would retire, a class act and indisputably the greatest skater of her generation, with nine national titles, five world championships — and those two Olympic heartbreakers.

So is Kwan that legend she dreamed of becoming as a young girl? Perhaps not by her golden standards. But what about by yours?

Mark Starr has been a national sports correspondent for Newsweek since 1982 and has attended 10 Olympics. Look for his columns each Sunday in The Herald leading up to the 2010 Vancouver Games.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Silvertips forward Shea Busch participates in the Florida Panthers development camp at Baptist Health IcePlex in Fort Lauderdale, Florida on July 1, 2025. Florida selected Busch in the fourth round of the 2025 NHL Entry Draft on June 28. (Photo courtesy Shea Busch)
Shea Busch experiences whirlwind NHL Draft week

The Florida Panthers selected the Silvertips forward in the fourth round on June 28.

Rome Odunze scans the field in a scrimmage at his youth football camp at Archbishop Murphy High School on July 10, 2025. The former University of Washington star is entering his second NFL season with the Chicago Bears. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Odunze ‘gives back’ in Everett youth football camp

The former University of Washington star hosts a single-day camp at Archbishop Murphy on Thursday.

The New York Yankees' Aaron Judge, top right, celebrates with teammates after hitting a walk-off sacrifice fly ball during the 10th inning against the Seattle Mariners at Yankee Stadium on Thursday, July 10, 2025, in New York. (Justin Casterline / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Yankees walk off Mariners on Judge’s sac fly for series sweep

Seattle blows 5-0 lead after Bryan Woo takes no-hitter into eighth inning.

Raleigh says Munoz tipped pitches during Yankees’ comeback

The Yankees had a bead on Seattle Mariners closer Andrés Muñoz. That’s… Continue reading

Midfielder Christian Soto dribbles up field during Snohomish United's 5-1 win against the Tacoma Stars at Stockers Fields on July 9, 2025 (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Snohomish United keeps playoff hopes alive in home finale

With 5-1 win against Tacoma, the USL2 club’s focus on local talent keys success in inaugural season.

Silvertips forward Carter Bear fields questions after the Detroit Red Wings selected him 13th overall in the 2025 NHL Entry Draft in Los Angeles on June 27, 2025. (Photo courtesy Natalie Shaver / CHL)
Two weeks after Draft, Silvertips’ Bear still can’t believe it

The Red Wings’ first-rounder reflects on draft night and his experience at Detroit’s development camp.

AquaSox down Devils for consecutive wins

The AquaSox were on a 2-10 stretch coming into the series.

Cam Schlittler’s strong debut freezes Mariners

The Mariners fell to the Yankees, 9-6, on Wednesday night.

Storm flies too close to the Sun, loses in an upset

Connecticut snapped a 10-game losing streak to beat Seattle 93-83 on Wednesday morning.

Giancarlo Stanton of the New York Yankees flips his bat after hitting a three-run home run in the sixth inning against the Seattle Mariners at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, July 8, 2025, in New York. (Evan Bernstein / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Raleigh, Judge heat up homer race at Yankee Stadium

In the battle of baseball’s biggest sluggers, Aaron Judge… Continue reading

Seattle Seahawks linebackers Derick Hall (58) and Boye Mafe (53) celebrate a defensive play during the 2024 season. (Rio Giancarlo / Getty Images / The Athletic)
Season to reveal long-term plans for Seahawks linebackers

The Seattle Seahawks selected edge rusher Boye Mafe with… Continue reading

Silvertips defenseman wins U20 Ball Hockey World Title with Canada

Rylan Pearce helps Canada win gold at the ISBHF U20 World Championships in Slovakia.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.