Oh for the days of Moon, Leaf and … Birnbaum?

  • By John Sleeper / Herald College Writer
  • Sunday, September 12, 2004 9:00pm
  • Sports

SEATTLE – The semi-retired writer had seen enough. The 40-plus-year veteran of watching, evaluating and writing about college football couldn’t resist one rolling-eyed salvo at the current state of affairs of quarterbacking at the state’s two largest institutions of higher learning.

“Five Division I quarterbacks in Washington,” he said, “and not one will make you forget Steve Birnbaum.”

While it may be premature to make comparisons of the five signal-callers who saw action the last two weeks in Washington and Washington State uniforms to the obscure Birnbaum, who played the brunt of his career on a Cougar team that recorded exactly one conference victory between 1998 and 1999, his point is well taken.

In programs whose quarterback tradition proudly lists such flashy names as Drew Bledsoe, Sonny Sixkiller, Timm Rosenbach, Marques Tuiasosopo, Jason Gesser, Steve Pelleur, Jack Thompson, Chris Chandler, Ryan Leaf, Don Heinrich, Mark Rypien, Brock Huard, Cody Pickett, Damon Huard, Billy Joe Hobert, Mark Brunell, Cary Conklin and Warren Moon, neither team has a complete grasp on who will start their respective games on Saturday.

Because in their last outings, most turned up Birnbaums.

Washington State coach Bill Doba was anything but decisive when asked whether Josh Swogger held onto his starting job after falling victim to his own receivers’ slippery hands. Swogger’s confidence appeared to melt in a 6-for-27 passing day in the Cougars’ 20-12 loss to Colorado Saturday.

Will Doba stick with Swogger against Idaho or will he opt for one Alex Brink, a redshirt freshman who was 12-for-23 for 251 yards in Swogger’s relief? In his first collegiate game, Brink showed considerable star potential, although he did throw an interception that Buffaloes linebacker Joe Sanders turned into a 51-yard touchdown.

Doba’s dilemma: Do you quit on Swogger this early in favor of developing a kid who apparently has “it,” an intangible quality all stars have, but whose learning curve is near vertical?

Washington’s problem is similarly puzzling, but considering the Huskies open the Pacific-10 Conference season Saturday at home against UCLA, much more pressing.

Head coach Keith Gilbertson has said he probably will stick with junior starter Casey Paus against the Bruins, but left room for more than a little wiggle.

In his starting debut Sept. 5 against Fresno State, Paus threw three interceptions, all of which the Bulldogs turned into touchdowns, either directly or indirectly.

Paus’ other numbers weren’t disastrous for a first game – 18-for-39 for 183 yards. His mistakes were relatively few, but catastrophic, which opened public debate that only a quarterback controversy can produce.

Perhaps Paus’ job is relatively safe because his backup, sophomore Isaiah Stanback, was equally appalling against Fresno State.

Stanback, who played wide receiver last season, completed just one in five passes, including an interception that went for a touchdown. A fumbled exchange between Stanback and fullback James Sims resulted in another Bulldog touchdown.

Then there’s redshirt freshman Carl Bonnell, who played sparingly against Fresno State and did some good things. His potential as both a runner and a passer appears unlimited, but his inexperience took him out of the race for the starting job in fall camp.

Bonnell’s possible effect on the UW program appears equal to that of Brink in that of WSU. Stick him into the lineup now and close your eyes. He’s likely to make both astonishing plays and baffling mistakes, often back to back.

So what is a head coach to do?

This is why they make the big bucks. Once they make the decision on Saturday’s starter, they can only stand there and watch from the sidelines. If the decision blows up on them, they can look forward to Hurricane Ivan criticism from alums and media.

Because the problem is that, in choosing between young quarterbacks in the embryonic stages of their development, the difference between Bledsoe and Birnbaum isn’t always immediately apparent.

John Sleeper is The Herald’s college writer.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Monroe's Halle Keller drives past Meadowdale's Payton Fleishman during a Feb. 14, 2025 3A District 1 playoff game at Meadowdale High School. (Qasim Ali / The Herald)
Last-second layup powers Monroe past Mavs

The Bearcats staged a 50-49 road upset in a district playoff clash.

Shorecrest’s Cassie Chesnut leaps in the air to block a shot by Shorewood’s Bridget Cox during the 3A district playoff game on Friday, Feb. 14, 2025 in Shoreline, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shorecrest girls win rubber match against Shorewood

Cassie Chesnut’s 28 points, 18 rebounds pushes the Scots to District 1 3A semifinals with 53-38 win.

Freshman leads Jackson to 4A district swim title

Syunta Lee sets two meet records as Timberwolves edge Lake Stevens.

Shorecrest wins 3A district swim title

Snohomish’s Torsten Hokanson sets two meet records and leads two winning relays.

Snohomish’s Kendall Hammer yells in celebration with teammate Snohomish’s Sienna Capelli after she makes a shot and is fouled during the game on Thursday, Jan. 9, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Prep basketball roundup for Friday, Feb. 14

Snohomish, Stanwood girls cruise into district semis.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Feb. 2-8

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Feb. 2-8. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Mountlake Terrace’s Svayjeet Singh leaps in the air after the basketball during the 3A district loser-out playoff game against Snohomish on Thursday, Feb. 13, 2025 in Mountlake Terrace, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Snohomish upsets Mountlake Terrace for first playoff win in 11 years

Bryson Wheat scored 25 in Panthers’ 49-43 win to advance to the District 1 Boys 3A quarterfinals

Julio Rodríguez (left) and manager Dan Wilson (right) of the Seattle Mariners react after the game against the Oakland Athletics at T-Mobile Park on Sept. 27, 2024, in Seattle, Washington. (Steph Chambers / Getty Images / Tribune News Services)
Dan Wilson begins first spring training as M’s manager

An anxious eagerness to get through the first of… Continue reading

Marysville Getchell junior Bubba Palocol reverses directions while dribbling against Arlington during a playoff matchup at Arlington High School on Saturday, Feb. 24, 2024, in Arlington, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Prep basketball roundup for Thursday, Feb. 13

Marysville Getchell, Lakewood boys each earn district wins

Kenneth Walker III runs with against the New York Jets at MetLife Stadium on Dec. 1, 2024. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks hire run game coach

Justin Outten added to staff as Mike Macdonald continues attempts to bolster rushing attack.

Balanced scoring attack leads Gonzaga

Zags take over second place in WCC with 88-77 win over USF.

Shorewood senior Bridget Cox (11) elevates to get a shot over Everett senior Aimelie Hovde-Girard (21) in Shorewood's 41-30 win in the opening round of the District 1 3A Girls Tournament on Wednesday, Feb. 12, 2025 in Shoreline, Washington. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Shorewood girls basketball avoids Everett upset bid in 41-30 win

Glasser’s ‘dagger’ 3 caps second-half run, pushes No. 5 Stormrays to 3A District 1 Quarterfinals

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.