Overager conundrum

Well, with Dan Gendur now back from rookie camp with the Vancouver Canucks, the Tips officially have overager decisions to make.

Everett brought six overagers in this preseason: forwards Gendur, Ondrej Fiala, Brennan Sonne and Brandon Campos, defenseman Dane Crowley and goaltender David Reekie. Of course, teams are allowed just three overagers. Two of those six (Fiala and Crowley) are still away at NHL camps and may not return. Neveretheless, it’s possible the Tips will be forced to pare three of those players from their roster.

If Fiala and Crowley both return, it’s a mess. Now don’t me wrong, it’s not a bad mess to have, having so many qualified candidates for the positions. But the logistics of the situation could really get tangled. Consider:

– Fiala may be the best player among the group, being a second-round NHL draft pick. However, he’d burn both an overager and a Euro spot, and the Tips have two other viable Euros in Lukas Vartovnik and Vitali Karamnov. He’d also be playing on a reconstructed knee.

– As a backup last season Reekie was as good as any starter in the league. But can a team afford to burn an overage spot on a backup goaltender?

– Sonne gives the appearance of being a role player, but he also fills some niches, being a good fighter, a good leader and money in a shootout.

– Campos has untapped offensive abilities, having been a big-time scorer in the BCHL.

You have to figure Gendur has a spot, and if Crowley returns he’d have one too. After that it all depends on how general manager Doug Soetaert wants to dominoes to fall on the roster. I wouldn’t be surprised to see the final decisions taken all the way to the overager deadline on Oct. 11.

So I’m curious. How would you all sort out the overager situation, should everyone return?

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Silvertips goalie Raiden LeGall (right) stands with his hometown goalie coach Tim Morison on the ice at Angel of the Winds Arena. (Photo courtesy of Tim Morison)
Silvertips goalie raises thousands of dollars for mental health causes

Raiden LeGall and his hometown goalie coach’s custom merchandise fundraiser grosses over $12k

Wortham’s 31 leads Stanwood girls basketball past Shorecrest on Tuesday

Prep roundup for Monday, Dec. 15: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To report results… Continue reading

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for Dec. 7-13

The Athlete of the Week nominees for Dec. 6-13. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Silvertips forward Jesse Heslop (left) pushes through the neutral zone during Everett's 9-4 win against Victoria at Angel of the Winds Arena on Oct. 4, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Silvertips display ‘versatility’ in comeback win vs. Spokane

After mistakes put team in 4-2 hole, Everett climbs back for 6-4 win on Saturday.

King's senior Kaitlin Cramer (right, in black) receives a pass from senior teammate Kaleo Anderson (left) during the Knights' 66-53 win against Kamiak at Kamiak High School on Dec. 12, 2025. (Herald Staff)
King’s girls basketball pulls away from Kamiak

The Knights utilize a fourth-quarter run to win 66-53 in Friday’s back-and-forth contest.

Seahawks kicker Jason Meyers boots one of his six field goals against the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday, Dec. 14, 2025 at Lumen Field in Seattle, Washington. (Photo courtesy of the Seattle Seahawks)
Seahawks coach Mike Macdonald credits analyst for timeout usage

Mike Macdonald hands out game balls in the locker room following Seahawks… Continue reading

Arlington wins Saturday’s A-Town Throwdown

Prep boys wrestling roundup for Saturday, Dec. 13: (Note for coaches/scorekeepers: To… Continue reading

Glacier Peak wins Everett Tournament

Everett’s Cianega sisters win titles at 190 and 235 Saturday.

Jackson junior Jaelyn Phaysith pressures Highline's quarterback into a throwaway during the Timberwolves' 23-7 win against the Pirates at Pop Keeney Stadium on Dec. 11, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Jackson girls flag football among Wesco pioneers

In first WIAA season, the Timberwolves show progress in 23-7 win against Highline on Thursday.

Winter prep sports roundup teaser.
Mac Crews’ double-double leads Arlington past Stanwood

Everett dominates Cascade in cross-town clash on Saturday.

Freshmen lead the way for Edmonds-Woodway on Saturday

Brooke Blachly drains six 3s for Archbishop Murphy on Friday.

Marysville Getchell boys stay perfect

The Chargers win a double dual on Thursday to start the season 7-0.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.