Paxton, Karns ‘neck and neck’ in battle for 5th spot in M’s rotation

PEORIA, Ariz. — The Seattle Mariners are entering the final week of their spring camp and, still, neither James Paxton nor Nathan Karns has emerged as a favorite to fill the rotation’s final slot.

“It’s very close,” Mariners manager Scott Servais said. “Neck and neck. They both have struggled at times. They’ve both looked OK for an inning or two here or there. It’s very close.”

The competition resumes Sunday when Paxton starts against the Chicago Cubs in Mesa. Then it’s Karns’ turn on Monday for a start in Peoria against Kansas City. Both are also in line to start the final two spring games.

Karns missed a chance to separate himself Wednesday when he gave up nine runs in 21/3 innings against Oakland. That led to a between-starts bullpen workout Friday that focused on his mental approach.

“He needs to start getting some confidence back as well,” Servais said. “I don’t think it was mechanical issues (Friday). It was more of his approach, where his mind is and getting after it.”

Paxton dropped down to a minor-league game last Tuesday after getting spanked by the Athletics in his previous start for seven runs in two innings.

The loser in the battle appears likely to start the season at Tacoma. Servais indicated the Mariners are backing away from the idea of putting the odd-man out into the bullpen.

“We’ve kicked the idea around a little bit,” he acknowledged, “but I think you’ve got to be careful that, if you do that, you can lose the ability to keep them stretched out.

“That if there is an issue (in the rotation), you don’t have an option to go to them.”

Furbush on hold

Lefty reliever Charlie Furbush still can’t shake the lingering tightness in the lower deltoid of his shoulder and now, after his latest examination, sounds like a pitcher who doesn’t expect to return to active duty for a while.

“I haven’t played catch in two days now,” he said. “I feel ready to play catch. I just think they’re trying to make sure. Once we get this game plan and start moving forward, we’ll have more of a timeline.

“That should give me some clarity on what the next three or four weeks will look like.”

Furbush, 29, missed the final three months last season because of biceps tendinitis and small tear in his rotator cuff.

“Overall, I feel pretty good,” he said, “so it’s just still not quite there yet. A little bit (of tightness). It’s something that I would like to go away. Once that little tightness goes away, I don’t see why it shouldn’t be fine.”

Furbush said he hasn’t yet undergone another magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) exam but admitted: “I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s the route. Just to gain some more clarity. Obviously, it’s unfortunate that I’m not ready for opening day.”

Catching competition

Catcher Rob Brantly, once viewed as an insurance acquisition, has played his way into competition with Steve Clevenger to serve as the backup to starter Chris Iannetta.

Brantly is 5-for-14 (.357) in 12 games since arriving in a March 12 waiver claim from the Chicago White Sox.

“Clevenger missed some time, being sick for a while,” Servais said, “and Brantly took advantage of some playing time. Brantly has swung the bat very well. I’ve also been very pleased with the progress that Clevenger has made defensively.”

Both are left-handed hitters — and both are out of options, which means either one would need to pass through waivers in order to be sent to the minors.

Clevenger is 8-for-28 (.286) in 11 games.

Short hops

Shortstop Ketel Marte returned to the lineup after missing two games because of the flu. … Plans called for outfielder Franklin Gutierrez, slowed recently by the flu, to drop down to minor-league games to catch up on missed at-bats. Lax rules in those games permit players to bat every inning. … Servias is also battling the flu. He said he planned to tough it out Saturday in the sun. Wisconsin toughness.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Everett AquaSox pitcher Jurrangelo Cijntje throw against the Tri-City Dust Devils at Funko Field on May 10, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Shari Sommerfeld / Everett AquaSox)
AquaSox beat Tri-City Saturday to win home series

Everett AquaSox pitching dominated in front of a season-high 3,531… Continue reading

Arlington head girls basketball coach Joe Marsh looks to the court as the Eagles defeat Shorecrest, 50-49, to advance to the state semifinals at the Tacoma Dome on Thursday, March 5, 2020. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Joe Marsh, Arlington High School girls basketball coach, dies at 57

Marsh, considered one of the state’s all-time great high school basketball coaches, lost a four-year battle with stage 4 prostate cancer on Wednesday.

Edmonds-Woodway pitcher Lukas Wanke delivers a pitch during a district baseball playoff game against Monroe on May 10, 2025 at Edmonds-Woodway High School. (Qasim Ali / The Herald)
Edmonds-Woodway downs Monroe in district baseball quarterfinal

The Warriors are a win away from state, Monroe needs two more wins to advance.

Stanwood’s TJ McQuery works with a man on first during a playoff loss to Kentlake on Tuesday, May 14, 2024, at Kent Meridian High School in Kent, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Weekend prep baseball roundup for May 9-10

TJ McQuery strikes out 12 to lead Stanwood past Terrace.

Weekend prep boys soccer roundup for May 9-10

Abdala Hassani scores 4 to lead Chargers.

Everett’s Anna Luscher (6) swings during a Class 3A District 1 softball championship game between Snohomish and Everett at Phil Johnson Fields in Everett, Washington on Thursday, May 16, 2024. Everett won, 10-0. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Weekend prep roundup for May 9-10

Everett softball wins two, advances in district tournament.

The Everett Silvertips warm up ahead of Game 6 of the WHL Playoffs First Round against the Seattle Thunderbirds at accesso ShoWare Center in Kent, Washington on April 7, 2025. (Photo courtesy: Dexter Guiang / Come as You Are Hockey)
Silvertips Director of Scouting breaks down 2025 draft class

Brooks Christensen speaks to The Herald about Everett’s 11 new prospects drafted on May 7-8.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for April 27-May 3

The Athlete of the Week nominees for April 27-May 3. Voting closes… Continue reading

Archbishop Murphy senior Ivan Juarez Oropeza contests with Anacortes senior Logan Baumgaertner for the ball during the Wildcats' 3-0 win in the District 1 2A Boys Soccer quarterfinals in Everett, Washington on May 8, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Archbishop Murphy boys soccer advances to district semis

Zach Mohr scores on a free kick and penalty kick in the 3-0 win against Anacortes.

Everett AquaSox pitcher Ashton Izzi throws a pitch against the Tri-City Dust Devils at Funko Field on May 8, 2025. (Photo courtesy of Shari Sommerfeld, Everett AquaSox)
AquaSox fall to Dust Devils

Although the Everett AquaSox outhit the Tri-City Dust Devils on… Continue reading

Prep baseball roundup for Thursday, May 8

Perreault no-hitter keeps Terrace season alive.

Prep roundup for Thursday, May 8

Edmonds-Woodway soccer shuts out Everett in district playoffs.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.