POLL RESULTS: M’s making right move with roster teardown

However, the voters are evenly split on whether the execution of Seattle’s plan has been successful.

The voters have spoken, and while they mostly agree with the Seattle Mariners’ path of action, they’re evenly split on whether the execution of their plan has been acceptable.

This week’s Seattle Sidelines poll asked readers to weigh in on the Mariners’ roster teardown. Seattle general manager Jerry Dipoto has spent the last month trading away a huge portion of last year’s team that won 89 games, dealing big-name players like Edwin Diaz, Robinson Cano and James Paxton in order to shed salary and replenish a depleted farm system. The net result is that the Mariners will likely be much worse next season, but hopefully have more pieces for building a foundation in the future.

So what do people think of what the Mariners have done? Here’s how you voted:

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

What's your opinion of the Mariners' roster teardown, trading away multiple veterans in exchange for prospects? (Poll Closed)
  •  
     
  •  
     
  •  
     
 
Total Votes: 87

Add the two together and nearly 80 percent of the voters said the teardown is the right call. However, it was almost dead even on whether the return was adequate. Both the good call/bad return and good call/good return options received 39 percent of the vote, though the bad return option picked up one more vote. Just 22 percent of the voters said it was the wrong move.

Just hours after the poll was published the Mariners finalized the last two of those deals listed in the original post, which weren’t yet official. The deal with the New York Mets remained as speculated with closer Diaz, second baseman Cano and $20 million flipped for outfielder Jay Bruce, reliever Anthony Swarzak, two blue-chip prospects in outfielder Jarred Kelenic and pitcher Justin Dunn, and prospect pitcher Gerson Bautista.

Meanwhile, the deal with the Philadelphia Phillies turned out to involve more than just shortstop Jean Segura. The Mariners sent Segura and relievers Juan Nicasio and James Pazos to Philly in exchange for first baseman Carols Santana and shortstop J.P. Crawford.

So here’s the current tally:

OUT

SP James Paxton, RP Edwin Diaz, RP Alex Colome, RP Juan Nicasio, RP James Pazos, C Mike Zunino, 2B Robinson Cano, SS Jean Segura, OF Guillermo Heredia, P Michael Plassmeyer (minors), $20 million.

IN

RP Anthony Swarzak, C Omar Narvaez, 1B Carlos Santana, SS J.P. Crawford, OF Mallex Smith, OF Jay Bruce, P Justus Sheffield (minors, blue chip), P Justin Dunn (minors, blue chip), P Erik Swanson (minors), P Gerson Bautista (minors), OF Jarred Kelenic (minors, blue chip), OF Dom Thompson-Williams (minors), OF Jake Fraley (minors).

Phew!

Dipoto has taken a break since Monday, and he suggested nothing else would happen before baseball’s winter meetings get underway Sunday in Las Vegas. So we have a chance to catch our breath before speculating further about the futures of players like outfielder Mitch Haniger and starting pitcher Marco Gonzales.

It will be years before we have any idea whether it was worth it for the Mariners to conduct this teardown — Kelenic, who may be the best long-term prospect of the bunch, is only 19 and was playing rookie ball the past season. But it’s been 17 years since Seattle last experienced playoff baseball, and based on this vote it seems the majority of the fan base is willing to wait a little while longer, provided it increases the chances of the drought ending in the future.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Sports

Jackson baseball players cheer before starting their next exercise during practice on Wednesday, May 28, 2025 in Mill Creek, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Jackson baseball’s bond of ‘brothers’ carries team to semis

The Timberwolves will play Friday for a spot in the Class 4A title game.

Jeff Page spent 47 years coaching track & field at Lake Stevens, including 32 as the program's head coach. The boys and girls teams totaled 33 Wesco titles, and the boys won the 2022 4A State Championship during his stint as head coach. (Photo courtesy of Jeff Page)
Turning the Page: Lake Stevens track coach set to retire

Jeff Page to close out 47-year coaching career with Vikings after state championships.

Reid Nicol signs his WHL Scholarship and Development Agreement with the Everett Silvertips alongside his family on May 28, 2025. (Photo Courtesy: Everett Silvertips)
Silvertips sign top draft pick Reid Nicol

Everett selected the 15-year-old center with the fifth overall pick in the 2025 Draft on May 7.

Vote for The Herald’s Prep Athlete of the Week for May 18-24

The Athlete of the Week nominees for May 18-24. Voting closes at… Continue reading

Prep state tournament results and schedule

Here’s a look at what’s happening this postseason.

Shorewood's Meiron Bereket dribbles past Bellevue's Masora Takashima during a 3A State boys soccer quarterfinal game on May 24, 2025 at Shoreline Stadium. (Qasim Ali / The Herald)
Shorewood boys soccer clinches first state semifinal in 11 years

The No. 1 Stormrays prevailed 7-6 in penalties over No. 8 Bellevue after a scoreless match.

Milkar Perez of the Everett AquaSox prepare to catch a ball at Funko Field on May 26, 2025 (Photo courtesy of Evan Morud / Everett AquaSox)
AquaSox comeback bid falls short

Everett hits two solo homers in the ninth but loses 4-3 to Spokane.

Jackson players celebrate teammate MJ Holcomb scoring during the game against Edmonds-Woodway on Wednesday, April 2, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
State prep baseball roundup for Saturday

Timberwolves win two, bound for state semis.

Oklahoma City Thunder guard Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (2) reacts after scoring in the fourth quarter. (Carlos Gonzalez / The Minnesota Star Tribune / Tribune News Services)
Jerry Brewer: Foul artists have ruled the NBA playoffs

John Wall had a theory about foul-baiting NBA stars. The former Washington… Continue reading

(From left to right) Erica Wheeler, Gabby Williams and Zia Cooke approach the bench during a 102-82 win over the Las Vegas Aces on May 25, 2025 at Climate Pledge Arena in Seattle, Washington. (Photo courtesy of Seattle Storm)
Storm wins three straight, Loyd returns to Seattle

The Storm beat Las Vegas 102-82 on Sunday by dishing out a season-high 32 assists.

Snohomish junior Abby Edwards delivers a pitch during the Panthers' 3-2 loss to Liberty in the 3A State Softball semifinals in Lacey, Washington on May 24, 2025. (Joe Pohoryles / The Herald)
Snohomish softball falls in the 3A state semifinal

The Panthers miss out on third straight championship appearance with 3-2 loss to Liberty.

Edmonds-Woodway's Alex Plumis wards off Monroe's Cody Duncan during a 3A State second-round game on May 23, 2025 at Mercer Island High School. (Qasim Ali / The Herald)
Edmonds-Woodway boys soccer stuns Monroe with shootout win at State

The No. 11 Warriors won penalties 4-3 after a thrilling 2-2 game.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.