Regulators in Idaho want $300K to study fish consumption

BOISE, Idaho — Environmental regulators want $300,000 to study just how many fish Idaho residents really eat, to help determine toxics criteria meant to protect people’s health without putting unduly strict limits on pollution that industry and others can legally discharge into the state’s waterways.

Department of Environmental Quality Director Curt Fransen told the Senate Resources and Environment Committee Wednesday the issue arose last year.

That’s when the federal Environmental Protection Agency rejected Idaho’s human health criteria for nearly 90 toxic pollutants present in surface waters because it determined that the state’s fish consumption estimates were too low.

Under the Clean Water Act, there’s a calculation for how much toxics can be discharged in Idaho waterways by industry, municipalities and others, based on human fish consumption.

Fearing the EPA will set water quality standards that burden the economy, Fransen now wants to hire social scientists to survey people across Idaho, to find out just how much fish they consume.

“The basic notion is, there are toxic materials in water, it ends up in fish, and if people eat those fish, it ends up in people, creating a health risk,” he said. “They believe the fish consumption rates may be higher than the default we used.”

A survey would include not only fishers from Idaho’s Indian tribes but passionate recreational “meat anglers” in the state who use their pastime to fill their freezers.

The issue has a long history.

In 2006, the state adopted an estimate that its residents eat about a pound of fish from Idaho waters monthly. Six years later, however, the EPA decided that wasn’t high enough, Fransen said.

For instance, Oregon recently adopted a standard for consumption that was 10 times higher than Idaho’s.

Given the EPA decision, Fransen told the Senate panel that Idaho has two options.

“Do nothing, and allow EPA to promulgate its own toxics criteria. Our second choice is, do a fish consumption study, so we have actual numbers,” he said.

He anticipates that the state will find that people’s fish consumption will exceed the rejected standard, but will allow the state to set toxics guidelines that aren’t as stringent as what the EPA might demand.

“Other studies from around the Northwest indicating that fish consumption rates could be higher,” he said.

Lawmakers on the panel said the issue is very important to businesses whose activities have an impact on Idaho’s waterways. Sen. John Tippets, R-Montpelier, pointed out he works for a phosphate mining and processing company, Agrium Conda, with activities in southeastern Idaho.

“This issue has the potential to impact anyone that has the potential to impact the quality of water,” Tippets said.

Others on the panel cautioned against trying to adopt a standard for fish consumption that was too low, given that human health is potentially at stake.

“I just hope that we keep in mind, that we try to keep it to a higher level, just for health purposes,” said Sen. Michelle Stennett, D-Ketchum.

Legislative budget writers are still considering whether to give the agency the money.

More in Local News

Fatal car crash reported on Highway 92 near Lake Stevens

The 3 p.m. accident and investigation stopped traffic in both directions near Machias Road.

Firefighters come to the rescue and give mom new stroller

Donations to the Good Neighbor Program covered the $143.20 cost.

Mayor tries new tactic to curb fire department overtime

Stephanson says an engine won’t go into service when the only available staff would be on overtime.

Cheering families welcome Kidd, Shoup after 6 months at sea

“I get back Daddy back today,” said one homemade sign at Naval Station Everett.

Paine Field fire chief will be allowed to retire

In his letter, the airport director noted Jeff Bohnet was leaving while under investigation.

Stanwood man, 33, killed in crash near Marysville

Speed may have been a factor, the sheriff’s department said.

County plans to sue to recoup costs from ballot drop-box law

A quarter-million dollars could be spent adding 19 ballot boxes in rural areas.

County frees up $1.6M for Everett’s low-barrier housing

The plan appears on track for the City Council to transfer land ahead of next month’s groundbreaking.

Jamie Copeland is a senior at Cedar Park Christian Schools’ Mountlake Terrace campus. She is a basketball player, ASB president, cheerleader and, of course, a Lion. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Cedar Park Christian senior stepping up to new challenges

Jamie Copeland’s academics include STEM studies, leadership, ASB activities, honor society.

Most Read