Research shows the value of deliberation in polarized times

Name-calling seems to be something that comes with language, whether we like it or not. A common response by children years ago, before cyber-bullying, was in a rhyming rejoinder, “Sticks and stones may break my bones, but names can never hurt me.”

There was no truly satisfactory adult form of that response — which is just as well, for it isn’t clear that names can never hurt us. In fact, the development of social media has meant that today’s name-calling isn’t limited to school yards. It now has easy access to global reach and is a weapon capable of breaking our spirit.

For all that, is name-calling capable of damaging our economy? Common sense would tell us that it is, but sadly we don’t yet know because we cannot yet measure it. For the most part, in today’s economics, if something isn’t measured it really doesn’t exist. Of course, common sense isn’t measurable either so its role in economic theory or policy is, at best, indeterminate.

Seeing the importance of social media, and its name-calling, economic researchers have begun to explore ways to learn more about its impact on the economy — whether it is directly measurable or not.

One of the initial problems that economic explorers face is that social media contains wildly diverse elements that range from schoolyard-level taunting and name-calling to timely, important information.

The social media mix itself echoes political speech, which has reintroduced absurdity into its language. Superlatives abound, but now we have something that resembles a comparative-superlative hybrid. Individuals are “worse than Hitler,” for example, as if merely being Hitler’s equal wouldn’t be quite enough.

The impact of these words, however, isn’t clear. We would think that the constant flow of pejoratives, insults, and hyperbolic comparisons would tend to affect the outlook of consumers, for example, but that conclusion had never been subjected to rigorous analysis.

Under the assumption that political rhetoric and social media tended to segregate people’s opinions, researchers at the New York Federal Reserve examined the data they had collected in its Survey of Consumer Expectations (SCE) to see if polarization affected consumers’ outlook.

Entitled, “Political Polarization in Consumer Expectations,” the three researchers, Oliver Armantier, John H. Conlon, and Wilbert von der Klaauw, examined the SCE survey data and compared the expectations of voters in Democratic counties with those in Republican counties—their affiliation determined by whether they voted for Donald Trump or Hillary Clinton.

What they found was that for at least two years, “polarization predated the election,” and that Democratic counties were more optimistic about the future than Republican counties. After the election, as we might expect, Republican counties were more optimistic than their Democratic counterparts. That makes sense, but there is one aspect of the data that is difficult to explain. The Democratic counties didn’t become less confident. It turns out that, as the authors note, “both groups became more optimistic after the election.”

Like all good exploratory research, the New York Federal Reserve study raises more questions than it answers. Political analysts will certainly want to understand why losing an election would raise consumers’ optimism. And in the broader, economic theory sense, at a minimum, we need to know more about the relationship between elections and consumer expectations. Then, perhaps we can get a better handle on how polarization affects consumer outlook.

Another good example of exploratory research in this area of the effects of language may be found in a report, “Can Words Get in the Way? The Effect of Deliberation in Collective Decision-Making.” The authors, Matias Iaryczaower, Xiaoxia Shi, and Matthew Shum — of Princeton, University of Wisconsin, and Caltech, respectively,-developed a mathematical model of the U.S. Appellate Court system decisions. More specifically, they looked at the appellate courts’ mistakes and tried to determine if deliberations were effective in reducing judicial errors. What they found was that “deliberation lowers the incidence of incorrect decisions when judges tend to disagree” or are ill-informed before hearing a case. Otherwise, deliberation just gets in the way.

How important are these two diverse reports? Each in its own way is blazing a trail for us that will lead to a better economy and a better society.

We need only to look at the U.S. Senate to see the convergence of these two exploratory research paths. The Senate is sometimes referred to as “the world’s greatest deliberative body,” but the increasing numbers of key party-line votes suggests that polarization has taken over and little deliberation is going on. To estimate the impact of this change on democracy and on the economy, we will have to know more about the deliberation process and about the effects of political polarization — and these exploratory research reports are showing us a way.

James McCusker is a Bothell economist, educator and consultant.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

Think Tank Cowork in Everett, Washington on July 19, 2022. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
The first co-working space opens in downtown Everett

Think Tank Cowork’s owner hopes the facility will inspire other business owners to call Everett home.

New LGI Homes on Thursday, May 12, 2022 in Sultan, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
The real estate market took an abrupt turn this spring

Mortgage rates are up, but home inspections, seller concessions are back on the table for buyers.

The Lab@Arlington is a new one-stop shop for entrepreneurs and inventors located at 404 N. Olympic Ave. (Photo credit: TheLab@Arlington)
New Arlington business incubator opens

TheLab@Arlington is a new one-stop shop for entrepreneurs, inventors and business owners.

Patrons view the 787 exhibition Thursday morning at the Boeing Future of Flight Musuem at Paine Field on October 8, 2020. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Paine Field was county’s No. 1 tourist attraction. Not now

Snohomish County officials hope festivals and outdoor activities will fill Paine Field tourist gap.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Stanwood in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Stanwood Chamber of Commerce ‘can’t keep the doors open’

The chamber is set to shut down at the end of the month due to financial challenges.

Maria Rios, a ferry worker of 13 years, helps Frank and Fran Butler, both of Washington, D.C., check out as the couple purchases food on Thursday, July 21, 2022, aboard the MV Suquamish ferry between Mukilteo and Clinton, Washington. Rios said food service returned to the Suquamish about three weeks prior. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Drink up! Happy hour on the Mukilteo-Clinton ferry is back

More galleys are reopening as pandemic restrictions scale back. Get out of your car for concessions just like at the ballpark.

OnTrac Logistics has leased a building now under construction at Bay Wood Business Park on Everett's waterfront. The shipping company will open a facility there later this year that will employ 400 people. (Artist Rendering/Broderick Group.)
New Everett shipping facility to generate 400 jobs

OnTrac Logistics has leased a new building on the 12½-acre Baywood Business Park on Everett’s waterfront.

The Flying Heritage & Combat Armor Museum at Paine Field in Everett. (Janice Podsada / The Herald) 20220419
Flying Heritage Museum to reopen with new owner at Paine Field

Walmart heir Steuart Walton bought the historic aircraft and artifacts. The museum is set to reopen within the year.

Renee's Contemporary Clothing store at 2820 Colby Ave. on July 11, 2022. The iconic downtown Everett store is closing in August after 29 years in business. (Janice Podsada/The Herald)
Renee’s, another iconic downtown Everett store, is closing

After 29 years in business, the longstanding clothing shop will shutter. In-person sales slowed when stores reopened.

FILE - The logo for Boeing appears on a screen above a trading post on the floor of the New York Stock Exchange, Tuesday, July 13, 2021. Boeing is reporting a money-losing quarter as both its civilian-airplane division and the defense business are struggling. Boeing said Wednesday, April 27, 2022,  that it lost $1.24 billion in the first quarter and took large write-downs for several programs.  (AP Photo/Richard Drew, file)
Boeing sees best month for aircraft deliveries since 2019

The company delivered 51 passenger and cargo planes in June, its best month for deliveries in recent years.

The Alderwood Towne Center, a 105,000 square-foot strip mall, is located at 3105-3225 Alderwood Mall Blvd. The mall, which has been sold, is home to 20 businesses, including anchor tenants Marshalls and Michaels. Photo Credit: CBRE Group.
Lynnwood strip mall near Link Light Rail Station sold

Alderwood Towne Center, home to 20 businesses, could eventually be redeveloped to take advantage of light rail.

James Berntson shows how his farm uses a trellis system to control tomato plants on Tuesday, June 21, 2022, at Radicle Roots Farm in Snohomish, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Backyard business: Snohomish farm thrives on less than one acre.

James Berntson grew Radicle Roots Farm using smart crop planning and organic practices.