Senate wants to curb protests over Pentagon contract awards

When firms such as Boeing and Lockeed Martin dispute the process it can delay programs for months

By Christian Davenport / The Washington Post

They did everything they could to prevent a protest over a contract for a new stealth bomber. Air Force officials had a “red team” of outside attorneys shadowing every step of the procurement process. They added layers of scrutiny, even though it delayed the award. They wanted to make sure any agreement could withstand challenges from the toughest inside-the-Beltway legal muscle.

Then, after the $80 billion contract was awarded to Northrop Grumman in 2105, Air Force officials sat down with the losers, Boeing and Lockheed Martin, to explain how the process unfolded.

It wasn’t enough. Boeing and Lockheed protested the decision, arguing that the selection process was “fundamentally flawed,” holding up the weapons program for several more months, while the legal dispute was heard.

Concern over the growing number of such protests — the “lawfare” that critics say hinders the government’s ability to move ahead with important programs and services — has prompted action by the Senate.

In this year’s defense spending plan, the Armed Services Committee has included a provision that would force large contractors — those with annual revenue of at least $100 million — to pay for the delays their challenges cause should they be on the losing side of a protest.

The legislation is of special interest in the Washington area, where many of the nation’s largest defense contractors are headquartered and where law firms have established entire practices around federal procurement law.

It is relatively easy to file a protest — the saying in the industry is that the cost is little more than the price of a postage stamp. For years, the number of protests has grown, to 2,789 last year from 2,475 in 2012. As the stakes increase, so do the challenges. An increasing number of high-value contracts — those worth $100 million or more — are being challenged, said Ralph White, who oversees the Government Accountability Office’s bid protest division.

Once a contract is protested to the GAO, the agency has 100 days to rule on the challenge. In the meantime, work comes to a halt.

Aneesh Chopra, the former U.S. technology officer, said at a recent panel discussion hosted by Nextgov and Government Executive that losing contractors exploit the system with such frequency that “we should have a shame list and shame the private vendors who protest and don’t win.”

The Senate provision wouldn’t do that. But its “loser pays” provision could force contractors to think twice about the cost of suing their customer.

“The big five defense contractors file a bid protest on autopilot whenever they lose. And this is targeted to help curb that behavior,” said a Senate aide who spoke on the condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly on the legislation.

Gene Dodaro, the comptroller general, warned that it would be difficult to enact the provision.

“To implement this requirement, GAO would need to develop procedures for tracking the amount of time spent on each protest,” he wrote. He also pushed back against a proposal that would force the GAO to speed to the review of a protest to 65 days from 100.

The stealth-bomber deal was a once-in-a-generation contract, one that could shape the contours of the defense industry for years. So Air Force officials knew they “couldn’t make a mistake,” said William LaPlante, then the assistance secretary of the Air Force for acquisitions. “Which of course is hard to do when you have humans involved and thousands of pages of documentation.”

The GAO ultimately upheld the award to Northrop, after weighing the matter for three months. But when a program is held up like that it can be “very disruptive,” said LaPlante, now a senior vice president of the McLean, Virginia-based Mitre Corp.

Although it won that one, Northrop last year lost a protest over a $359 million Air Force contract for electronic warfare technology that was awarded to BAE Systems, a move that is not uncommon among the top defense contractors. Lockheed Martin, General Dynamics, Raytheon and Booz Allen Hamilton filed numerous protests between 2005 and 2015, according to a Pentagon review.

Few contractors consider their legal challenges frivolous.

“We take the decision to file a protest very seriously,” said Todd H. Blecher, a spokesman for Boeing’s defense, space and security unit. “On those occasions when we have decided to file a protest, it was because we believed fundamental errors were made in awarding the contract.”

The Aerospace Industries Association said it was opposed to the measure because “rather than discouraging frivolous bid protests, this provision would create a disproportionate burden on companies that file protests in good faith,” spokesman Dan Stohr said. “They invest significant time and resources to consider the facts very carefully and make an informed business decision whether to protest a particular contract award.”

It is not just new acquisitions that are targeted with protests. Some companies have challenged decisions to hang on to programs after the work was awarded to a competitor, allowing them to continue to bill the government until the dispute is resolved.

Without speaking directly about the Senate provision, La Plante said that although the government has to be held accountable for holding a fair and thorough process, companies shouldn’t be able to gum up the system so easily.

“We need to push accountability out into the system, so that it’s not just on the government,” he said. “These companies feel accountability to their shareholders, and that’s why they protest. But there has to be accountability to the warfighter and to the Department of Defense.”

Despite the growth in the number of protests, it is still tiny compared with the number of procurements. And companies need a remedy in case they have been mistreated, said Alan Chvotkin, executive vice president and counsel of the Professional Services Council, a trade group.

Of the nearly 3,000 protests filed last year, more than 20 percent were sustained by the GAO, a jump from years past. And in 46 percent of the cases, the protesters found some form of relief, such as the agency starting the competition over again.

And just because a company loses a protest doesn’t mean the challenge is frivolous, said White, of the GAO.

“A company could have all kinds of valid reasons to think they weren’t treated fairly and still maybe not prevail in a protest,” he said.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

FILE - In this file photo dated Monday, March 11, 2019, rescuers work at the scene of an Ethiopian Airlines plane crash south of Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.  The number of deaths in major air crashes around the globe fell by more than half in 2019 according to a report released Wednesday Jan. 1, 2020, by the aviation consultancy To70, revealing the worst crash for the year was an Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 MAX on March 10 that lost 157 lives. (AP Photo/Mulugeta Ayene, FILE)
Former Boeing test pilot pleads not guilty in 737 Max case

He’s the first person to be charged with a crime in connection with the Indonesia and Ethiopia crashes.

Top (L-R): Kim Daughtry, Steve Ewing. Bottom (L-R): Gary Petershagen, Marcus Tageant.
Developers court Lake Stevens council incumbents with over $20K

Over half of the campaign dollars for four candidates came from people tied to real estate or property development.

People hold signs in protest of the vaccine mandate after Boeing announced it would terminate workers who do not comply on Friday, Oct. 15, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Some Boeing workers protest in Everett over vaccine mandate

The Boeing Company announced earlier this week that its workers must be vaccinated by Dec. 8.

FILE - In this March 14, 2019 file photo, Ethiopian relatives of crash victims mourn at the scene where the Ethiopian Airlines Boeing 737 Max 8 crashed shortly after takeoff killing all 157 on board, near Bishoftu, south-east of Addis Ababa, in Ethiopia. Relatives of some of the passengers who died in the crash will mark the two-year anniversary of the disaster on Wednesday, March 10, 2021, by seeking a reversal of government orders that let Boeing 737 Max jets fly again.  (AP Photo/Mulugeta Ayene, File)
Boeing pilot involved in Max testing is indicted in Texas

He’s accused of giving the FAA false information about systems that played a role in two deadly crashes.

Traffic drives in view of a massive Boeing Co. production plant, where images of jets decorate the hangar doors, Friday, April 23, 2021, in Everett, Wash. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
Boeing says workers must get the COVID vaccine by Dec. 8

“Compliance with these requirements is a condition of employment,” says an internal company presentation.

The Boeing 737 Max 10 airplane landing at Boeing Field in Seattle on June 18. (Chona Kasinger / Bloomberg)
Boeing ramps up 737 Max but 787 deliveries are still blocked

Boeing last month maintained its steady trickle of sales as it navigates the aviation downturn.

A handful of Northwest Union Carpenter members picket in front of the new Marysville civic center construction site on the sixth day of a region wide union carpenter strike on Wednesday, Sept. 22, 2021 in Marysville, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Carpenters strike ends with new contract and a $10 raise

Roughly 500 union members were working on projects in Snohomish County. It was among the largest strikes in 18 years.

FILE - In this March 20, 2020, file photo, the Amazon campus outside the company headquarters in Seattle sits nearly deserted on an otherwise sunny and warm afternoon. Amazon said Monday, Oct. 11, 2021 it will allow many tech and corporate workers to continue working remotely indefinitely, as long as they can commute to the office when necessary. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Amazon to allow employees to work remotely indefinitely

Although most cannot work remotely because their duties include grabbing orders and delivering them.

With new owners demanding the Grand Apartments' longtime residents leave, Stephen Teixeira, 52, documents issues at the Rockefeller Avenue building, on Thursday, Oct. 7, 2021 in Everett, Washington.  (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Life at the Grand Apartments in Everett is now a ‘nightmare’

Longtime residents say the new owner, an investment company, is trying to bully them out of the building.

Bob Martin, 80, owner of the The Stag Barber and Styling in Snohomish. (Andrea Brown / The Herald)
$90,000 fine doesn’t stop defiant Snohomish barber

Bob Martin appealed a state penalty for ignoring coronavirus rules and lost. It has not cut into his business.

A handful of Northwest Union Carpenter members picket in front of the new Marysville civic center construction site on the sixth day of a region wide union carpenter strike on Wednesday, Sept. 22, 2021 in Marysville, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Carpenters union strikes a deal, and members are set to vote

Workers are back on the job with a tentative agreement that includes a 15.43% raise over three years.

Ryan Welch, a produce clerk, restocks grapes at the Sno-Isle Food Co-op on Friday, Sept. 17, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett’s Sno-Isle Food Co-op approaches its 25th anniversary

The enterprise hopes to add more square footage and more classroom space to the store on Grand Avenue.