The madcap Christmas comedy “Inspecting Carol” is showing through Dec. 22 at the Phoenix Theatre in Edmonds. Pictured are, standing, Jay Jenkins as Larry, Stacey Gilbert as MJ, Ian Wight as Bart and Ray Miller as Walter, sitting, Oliver Sargent as Tiny Tim, John Fry as Phil and Susan Connors as Dorothy. (James Sipes)

The madcap Christmas comedy “Inspecting Carol” is showing through Dec. 22 at the Phoenix Theatre in Edmonds. Pictured are, standing, Jay Jenkins as Larry, Stacey Gilbert as MJ, Ian Wight as Bart and Ray Miller as Walter, sitting, Oliver Sargent as Tiny Tim, John Fry as Phil and Susan Connors as Dorothy. (James Sipes)

‘Inspecting Carol’ turns the Dickens Christmas classic on its head

The Phoenix Theatre in Edmonds stages the madcap comedy that originated 28 years ago in Seattle.

Most theater companies stage an annual “A Christmas Carol” show for the holidays. Here’s a play that makes fun of that.

In the madcap Christmas comedy “Inspecting Carol,” showing through Dec. 22 at the Phoenix Theater in Edmonds, we get a behind-the-scenes look at a struggling theater’s annual clumsy production of “A Christmas Carol.” Rehearsals are at a standstill, Tim is no longer Tiny, Scrooge wants to do the play in Spanish, and the play’s funding is on hold pending an inspection.

“Inspecting Carol” was written by Daniel J. Sullivan, the former artistic director of the Seattle Repertory Theatre. When the show premiered at the Rep in 1991, it was an indisputable hit that helped jump-start Sullivan’s Broadway career as a director and playwright. (The theater company reprised “Inspecting Carol” 21 years later, starring several members of the original cast.)

Sullivan, who went on to direct Broadway’s “Proof” and “A Moon for the Misbegotten,” crossed Nikolai Gogol’s “The Inspector General” with Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol” to write one hilarious and heartwarming play. His show makes a caricature of the typical theater company — folks from the ’90s Seattle theater scene inspired each character.

“Sullivan, with the help of his company, wrote it to poke fun at theaters’ annual production of ‘Christmas Carol,’ and some of the people they were making fun of, and some people in the production, I know or knew,” said Keith Dahlgren, director of the show.

There’s Sidney (Jim Thompson), who plays Jacob Marley and Fezziwig, who is constantly clanging his ghostly chains, even as Fezziwig. There’s Walter (Ray Miller), cast as the three spirits of Christmas, who is new to “A Christmas Carol,” but doesn’t get much rehearsal time, so he’s having a hard time learning his lines. And there’s the star of the show, Larry (Jay Jenkins), who plays Scrooge, but is bored by Dickens’ tale and wants to rewrite it.

Jenkins, who has been with Phoenix Theatre for 10 years, said the juxtaposition of characters — the ones played “backstage,” like his Larry, and the ones played “on stage,” like Larry’s Scrooge — make the show within a show very funny.

“Larry, himself, is sort of the epitome of a theater actor,” said Jenkins, who most recently played George in Phoenix’s “Moon Over Buffalo” in 2016. “He’s not only emotional, but also very arts-oriented and very tuned in to the plight of humanity. Which makes him the opposite of what Scrooge is.”

This is Dahlgren’s third holiday show with Phoenix and his second time directing “Inspecting Carol.” He also was the director for The Outcast Players’ production of the Sullivan original at Historic Everett Theatre in 2003.

“The way it’s written, it sets up this house of cards and then just knocks it down,” Dahlgren said of “Inspecting Carol.” “It’s laugh-out-loud funny.”

Taking a page from Sullivan’s script, so to speak, Dahlgren also created a comedy show called “Citizen Scrooge” — a cross between “Citizen Kane” and “A Christmas Carol” — for Unexpected Productions, an improv company at Pike Place Market. In 2011, he also directed “Jacob Marley’s Christmas Carol” for The Bathhouse Theater in Seattle.

Jenkins said “Inspecting Carol” is yet another great alternative to an annual staging of “A Christmas Carol.” No joke.

“We’ve all seen ‘A Christmas Carol’ a hundred thousand times, so it’s hilarious to see how this show deconstructs it,” Jenkins said. “With all the changes and accidents that happen, how this troupe twists the ‘Christmas Carol’ we all know too well, makes it really fun.

“The play they put on (for the inspector) is not quite what it’s supposed to be.”

Sara Bruestle: 425-339-3046;

If you go

Phoenix Theatre’s production of “Inspecting Carol” is showing through Dec. 22 at the Edmonds theater, 9673 Firdale Ave. Show times are 7:30 p.m. Saturday and Sunday, plus a 2 p.m. Sunday matinee. Tickets are $25 adults, $20 seniors, students, military. Limited tickets online; more available at the box office. Call 206-533-2000 or go to for more information.

More in Life

Twin sisters do makeover magic to local homes in HGTV series

New “Unsellable Houses” focuses on transforming modest Snohomish County homes into hot properties.

2020 Infiniti QX50 luxury SUV specializes in passenger contentment

Newly added connectivity and driver-assist technology bring this five-passenger compact up to speed.

Meet the author whose novel ‘The Ghost Bride’ is a Netflix series

Yangsze Choo will be in Everett to talk about her second book, just as the series based on her debut is airing.

Rockhounds unearth a righteous gemstone near Darrington

It’s the discovery of a lifetime — an 8-ton nephrite jade boulder.

Everett’s biggest little spot for music is Black Lab Gallery

With live shows almost every weekend, it’s become the place to hear up-and-coming local musicians.

Got time to spare? 9 things you can do while you’re waiting

Ten minutes is enough time to change your clothes or change your life, depending on what you choose to do.

Snow days start out grand but quickly cause cabin fever

The recent bout of snowy weather made her family feel all of the emotions. Here’s a day-by-day recap.

Rick Steves on what’s new for travelers in Great Britain

Many travelers are curious about how Brexit is affecting tourists — from his experience, it isn’t.

Interior designer Kelly DuByne shows off Pantone’s Color of the Year, classic blue, with a setting featuring an antique Victrola cabitnet painted with the color and staged with neutral colors and strong white accents. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
This year’s Color of the Year is a timeless hue — classic blue

A Lake Stevens interior designer calls it a “grounded” tone, easily worked into existing color palettes.

Most Read