Make authentic bagels, even outside New York

  • By J.M. Hirsch Associated Press
  • Tuesday, October 2, 2007 4:31pm
  • Life

It’s easy to dismiss bagels as a why-bother sort of baking project.

After all, it has been many years since the best bagel outside New York was frozen and bagged. The proliferation of excellent bagel shops has left few corners of this country starved for quality specimens.

But exceptionally good bagels are so easy to make. With just a bit of planning and a stand mixer — or some particularly muscular arms — fresh bagels can be on the breakfast table in about 20 minutes.

Mind you, that 20 minutes comes after about an hour of mostly painless effort the night before. But what a small price for deli-style bagels hot from the oven without having to schlep to the bagel shop.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

While recipes for bagels abound, Johnson &Wales University baking instructor Peter Reinhart perfected the technique for getting that deli taste and texture at home in his book, “The Bread Baker’s Apprentice.”

Here’s what you need to know:

Flour

The chewy nature of bagels means they need a flour with a high gluten (protein) content. The best are special flours milled for bagel shops. Reinhart suggests asking to buy several pounds from your local shop.

Failing that, unbleached white bread flour works just fine.

No bread flour? Testing Reinhart’s recipe with regular all-purpose flour produced wonderful bagels.

Whole-wheat flour (including white whole-wheat flour) did not work well. Reinhart says he is working on a recipe specifically for whole-wheat bagels.

Water

New Yorkers will argue that real bagels are made with real New York water.

“That’s the myth they’ve spun really well,” Reinhart says. “New York just happens to have really good water. But I don’t think that’s the difference” between an acceptable bagel and an exceptional one.

He does suggest using bottled spring water if your water is heavily chlorinated or particularly hard.

Malt

Bagel shops add barley malt syrup to the dough because it adds a subtle — but important — flavor. The syrup, which resembles molasses, is widely available at natural foods grocers, many supermarkets and online.

Honey is an acceptable substitute (and testing numerous batches with honey produced great bagels).

Reinhart advises against using malt powder. The powder is more powerful than the syrup and can weaken the gluten in the dough.

Mixing

Bagel dough is tough stuff. You will want an oomphy stand mixer to do the kneading. Reinhart suggests checking your mixer’s manual for directions on handling stiff doughs. Some machines will say to use it only on low, or let it rest every few minutes.

Reinhart says he uses the machine for the first four minutes, then finishes the dough by hand so he can get a feel for the dough.

Proofing

Once the bagels are shaped, they are allowed to rise, or proof, at room temperature for 20 minutes. This generally is enough time and the bagels then can be refrigerated overnight for slow fermentation before cooking.

If you’d like to test the bagels to be sure they have proofed long enough, drop one in a bowl of cool water. If the bagels are ready, it should float within 10 seconds.

If it doesn’t, dry the bagel and return it to the pan for another 10 to 20 minutes.

Refrigeration

Reinhart says it’s impossible to get authentic bagel flavor without refrigerating the dough overnight. This allows the bagels to slowly ferment, which gives the natural enzymes in the dough time to release flavors.

The bagels also can be kept at this stage for two days. Consider prepping the dough Friday, then baking it in two batches, one each morning of the weekend.

During testing, batches allowed to refrigerate up to four days were not significantly affected.

Cooking

The first step of cooking is a boiling water bath for two minutes. Baking soda is added to the water. This alkalizes the water, which helps the bagels brown during baking. Shops use food-grade lye, but baking soda is much easier (and safer) for home use.

Once boiled, the bagels are baked in two steps. First, for five minutes at 500 degrees, then another five minutes at 450 degrees.

Bagels

1teaspoon instant yeast

4cups unbleached white bread flour

21/2cups water, room temperature

1/2teaspoon instant yeast

33/4cups unbleached white bread flour

23/4teaspoons salt

1tablespoon barley malt syrup or honey

1tablespoon baking soda

Cornmeal or semolina flour, for dusting

Sesame seeds, poppy seeds, kosher salt or other toppings

To make the sponge, combine the yeast and flour in the bowl of a stand mixer. Add the water and mix together with a spoon until it forms a sticky batter. Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and leave at room temperature about 2 hours, or until foamy and bubbly. The mixture should nearly double in size and collapse when the bowl is tapped on the counter.

To make the dough, set the bowl with the sponge in the mixer with the dough hook attachment. With the mixer on low, add the yeast, then 3 cups of the flour and all of the salt and malt syrup or honey. Mix on low speed until the ingredients form a ball, slowly adding remaining 3/4 cup flour.

Let the mixer knead the dough for six minutes. The dough should be pliable and smooth, and feel satiny but not tacky. Add a few drops of water or a bit of flour as needed to get desired texture.

Wipe down a clean work surface with a damp cloth. Transfer the dough to the work surface, then divide into 12 pieces (for large bagels) or 24 pieces (for mini bagels).

One at a time, cup each piece in your hand and firmly press it into the counter. Move your hand in a circular fashion while pressing the dough against the table. The dough soon should form a tight ball.

Cover the dough balls with a damp towel and let them rest 20 minutes. Meanwhile, line two baking pans with parchment paper. Lightly mist the parchment with cooking spray.

To shape the bagels, pick the dough pieces up one at a time and push your thumb through the center. Gently rotate your thumb around the hole to stretch it to about 21/2 inches wide (slightly less for smaller bagels). Try to keep the bagel evenly shaped (no thick or thin parts).

Arrange the bagels on the prepared baking sheets 2 inches apart. Mist them lightly with cooking spray, then cover loosely with plastic wrap and let them sit at room temperature another 20 minutes.

Refrigerate the bagels overnight (or up to two days).

When ready to bake the bagels, arrange the oven racks in the middle of the oven and preheat to 500 degrees. Bring a large pot of water to a boil and add the baking soda. Have a slotted spoon ready.

Remove the bagels from the refrigerator and gently place two or three (or as many as will comfortably fit) into the boiling water. After one minute, flip the bagels and boil another minute. If you prefer chewy bagels, extend boiling to two minutes per side.

While the bagels boil, sprinkle the same parchment-lined pans with cornmeal or semolina flour. As the bagels finish boiling, return them to the baking sheets. If you want to top the bagels, do it as soon as they come out of the water.

When all the bagels have been boiled, place the pans in the oven and bake for five minutes. Rotate the pans 180 degrees, switching shelves, lower heat to 450 degrees and bake an additional five minutes, or until they are a light golden brown.

Let the bagels cool on a rack for at least 15 minutes before serving.

Makes 12 large bagels or 24 small bagels.

Recipe from Peter Reinhart’s “The Bread Baker’s Apprentice”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

Auston James / Village Theatre
“Jersey Boys” plays at Village Theatre in Everett through May 25.
A&E Calendar for May 15

Send calendar submissions for print and online to features@heraldnet.com. To ensure your… Continue reading

Kyle Parker paddles his canoe along the Snohomish River next to Langus Riverfront Park on Thursday, May 8, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Tip to Tip: Kyle Parker begins his canoe journey across the country

The 24-year-old canoe fanatic started in Neah Bay and is making his way up the Skykomish River.

Photo courtesy of Historic Everett Theatre
The Elvis Challenge takes place Saturday at the Historic Everett Theatre.
A&E Calendar for May 8

Send calendar submissions to features@heraldnet.com. To ensure your item is seen by… Continue reading

Former Herald writer Melissa Slager’s new book was 14-year project

The 520-page historical novel “Contests of Strength” covers the 1700 earthquake and tsunami on Makah lands.

The 2025 Mercedes-Benz GLC 350e plug-in hybrid compact luxury SUV, shown here in the European version (Provided by Mercedes-Benz).
2025 Mercedes-Benz GLC 350e PHEV has a 54-mile range

The plug-in hybrid compact luxury SUV goes a class-leading distance in full electric mode.

RAV4 Hybrid XSE AWD photo provided by Toyota USA Newsroom
2025 Toyota RAV4 Hybrid Provides 39 MPG And 566-Mile Range

Versatile And Functional Compact SUV A Family Pleaser

Photo provided by Subaru U.S. Media Center
Subaru Adds Bronze And Onyx Trims to 2025 Ascent

Three-Row Family SUV Delivers Equal Parts Safety And Comfort

The 2025 Hyundai Santa Fe Hybrid SUV (Provided by Hyundai).
2025 Hyundai Santa Fe Hybrid evokes outdoor adventure

Boxy styling leaves lots of room for gear. A refined ride ensures comfort around town.

The 2025 Toyota Sienna minivan in the top-level Platinum grade (Provided by Toyota).
2025 Toyota Sienna maintains reputation for fuel efficiency

Every model in the minivan’s lineup has a hybrid powertrain.

An autumn-themed display at Wagner Jewelers in Marysville. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Shine bright with Snohomish County’s top jewelry finds

Three dazzling shops where elegance, craft, and sparkle come together.

The 2025 Lexus TX 350 is a three-row luxury SUV. It’s offered in Base, Premium, Luxury, and F Sport Handling grades (Provided by Lexus).
2025 Lexus TX 350 welcomes new F Sport Handling model

Unique exterior highlights, a glass roof and sport-tuned suspension are among the attractions.

Hybrid Touring Photo Provided by Subaru U.S. Media Center
2025 Subaru Forester Hybrid Increases Fuel Economy And Range

Sixth-Generation Model Receives Complete Refresh

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.