‘The Reader’: Winslet worthiest thing in deathly serious ‘Reader’

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Wednesday, December 24, 2008 1:11pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

Bernhard Schlink’s novel “The Reader” was a No. 1 bestseller and a much-admired literary event. But in the movie version, it takes a great actress to animate some strangely lifeless surroundings.

That actress is Kate Winslet — and this isn’t even her best performance. But she’s the worthiest thing about “The Reader,” a year-end prestige picture. Alas, the movie has more prestige than guts.

Part of the story takes place in Germany in 1957, where a teenager named Michael (David Kross) begins an affair after an accidental meeting with a 40ish woman, Hanna (Winslet).

Their sexual intensity is interrupted only by his habit of reading books aloud to her. The average audience member will figure out long before Michael does (it takes him years) that this is more than just an endearing little post-coital game.

We know that Michael will grow up to become a commitment-phobic lawyer, played by Ralph Fiennes. Between these poles is a sequence that reveals to the younger Michael (a few years after the affair) the shadow of Nazi war crimes and how it might fall across Hanna.

Director Stephen Daldry (“The Hours”) takes a dead-serious approach to the material, which is the only way into it, unless you’re Mel Brooks. A series of moral questions — some at the feet of Hanna, some on Michael — form the film’s backbone.

These are somewhat puzzlingly developed. For instance, you might assume that Hanna’s wartime experiences would hold a bigger place in the drama than the issue of reading. Yet the emotional weight of the story actually tilts in the direction of the title.

The issues are interesting, but the dry approach of Daldry and adapter David Hare puts the film too frequently into the stiffer realms of the arthouse. It comes to life only during the affair, and the tender evocation of 1957 Germany.

Those scenes burn with Kate Winslet’s particular gravity and intelligence. Everything else in the movie seems bleached compared to the hothouse atmosphere within her modest apartment, or the couple’s occasional forays into the world (including a day in the country where Hanna is mistaken for Michael’s mother).

In the end, the exceedingly literary approach, the respectable tastefulness of the ideas here, the impeccable art direction, all combine to smother the movie. And even Kate Winslet can’t break the crust.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

This weekend, enjoy live music by the beach in Mukilteo, see a free movie in Everett or take in short plays in Edmonds.

Pleasant and progressive, Oslo puts its people first

Every time I come to Norway, I’m fascinated by their experiment in big government, and how little people are bothered by high taxes.

My Apple Vacations voucher doesn’t work! Can I get a refund?

A travel advisor offers Cathy Balsewich an expried $200 credit at a hotel in the Turks and Caicos. Who is responsible?

Dresden detour: Spend a day strolling this vibrant, historic German city

While its streets paint a portrait of its highest highs and lowest lows, Dresden today is in an era of cultural rebirth.

Show, don’t tell: Mindful parents set kids up to learn through experiences

How might the decisions I make for my children today set the stage for their skills, knowledge and attitudes as adults?

Homeowner Ryan Anderson sits on the bunk beds in the ferry quarters at Ferry Cove, the latest feature in the 5-bedroom waterfront vacation rental in Clinton. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
This Whidbey rental is like walking onto a state ferry

This 5-bedroom beachfront Airbnb has rooms patterned after “The Parent Trap,” “The African Queen” and the ferry Tokitae.

Photo Credit: Erik Kabik Photography/ erikkabik.com
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Everett’s Music at the Marina kicks off with Nite Wave tonight, and Harry Connick Jr. comes to Chateau Ste. Michelle this weekend.

Snohomish County PUD takes risk of wildfires seriously. You should, too.

Already this summer, wildfires have burned acres of timber in Spokane, Yakima, Chelan and British Columbia.

A real moose would gobble up your garden. Not this life-sized replica.

This zinc figure, which sold for $3,328 at auction, might even spook other wild creatures keen on eating your plants.

Great Plant Pick: Smooth hydrangea

known as smooth hydrangea or hydrangea arborescens ‘Annabelle’… Continue reading

Beautiful Pink and Blue Hydrangea Flowers in the Garden on Sunny Summer Day
Take your summer garden to new heights with long-blooming hydrangeas

Old-fashioned mopheads and lacecaps abound, but newer cultivars bloom more and longer. Here’s how to shop for these shrubs.

Fallen soldiers are remembered during the Fourth of July parade in downtown Everett, Washington, on Tuesday, July 4, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Take in the Fourth of July in all it’s star-spangled glory, then catch country artists in Monroe and a boys chorus in Edmonds.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.