‘The Reader’: Winslet worthiest thing in deathly serious ‘Reader’

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Wednesday, December 24, 2008 1:11pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

Bernhard Schlink’s novel “The Reader” was a No. 1 bestseller and a much-admired literary event. But in the movie version, it takes a great actress to animate some strangely lifeless surroundings.

That actress is Kate Winslet — and this isn’t even her best performance. But she’s the worthiest thing about “The Reader,” a year-end prestige picture. Alas, the movie has more prestige than guts.

Part of the story takes place in Germany in 1957, where a teenager named Michael (David Kross) begins an affair after an accidental meeting with a 40ish woman, Hanna (Winslet).

Their sexual intensity is interrupted only by his habit of reading books aloud to her. The average audience member will figure out long before Michael does (it takes him years) that this is more than just an endearing little post-coital game.

We know that Michael will grow up to become a commitment-phobic lawyer, played by Ralph Fiennes. Between these poles is a sequence that reveals to the younger Michael (a few years after the affair) the shadow of Nazi war crimes and how it might fall across Hanna.

Director Stephen Daldry (“The Hours”) takes a dead-serious approach to the material, which is the only way into it, unless you’re Mel Brooks. A series of moral questions — some at the feet of Hanna, some on Michael — form the film’s backbone.

These are somewhat puzzlingly developed. For instance, you might assume that Hanna’s wartime experiences would hold a bigger place in the drama than the issue of reading. Yet the emotional weight of the story actually tilts in the direction of the title.

The issues are interesting, but the dry approach of Daldry and adapter David Hare puts the film too frequently into the stiffer realms of the arthouse. It comes to life only during the affair, and the tender evocation of 1957 Germany.

Those scenes burn with Kate Winslet’s particular gravity and intelligence. Everything else in the movie seems bleached compared to the hothouse atmosphere within her modest apartment, or the couple’s occasional forays into the world (including a day in the country where Hanna is mistaken for Michael’s mother).

In the end, the exceedingly literary approach, the respectable tastefulness of the ideas here, the impeccable art direction, all combine to smother the movie. And even Kate Winslet can’t break the crust.

Talk to us

More in Life

Jerry Wennstrom with “Lightning,” a multi-layered sculpture. Wennstrom’s second body of artistic work consists of several tall, wooden sculptures resembling women that are meant to represent complex themes of birth and death, good and evil, femininity and masculinity. (David Welton)
Meet a Whidbey sculptor who makes interactive, eccentric art

Jerry Wennstrom publishes a book detailing his artistic body of work, which emphasizes feminine figures.

FILE - This 1972 file photo shows Elvis Presley during a performance. The AP reported on July 14, 2017, that a story claiming a dead homeless man in San Diego was identified as Presley is a hoax. Presley died in 1977. (AP Photo, File)
Who was cooler: Elvis or the Beatles?

It depends on which generation you ask — but don’t ask the author’s kids. They’re into Nirvana.

Even if you haven’t watered your landscape in the past 100 days, or watered very little, get outside and give your plants a good soak. (Getty Images)
It’s dry out there, so water your yard — please!

After 100 days of no precipitation, your garden badly needs a drink. So grab a hose and get to work — it’s well worth the slightly higher water bills.

The fortified ghost town of Vathia, on Greece’s Mani Peninsula, was once as wild as our Wild West.
Rick Steves: The best way to spend two weeks in Greece

The nation’s true joy and character can be found outside of touristy Athens and the islands.

The all-new Kia Sportage X-Pro model comes standard with all-terrain tires and 17-inch matte black off-road wheels. (Kia)
2023 Kia Sportage has two new models aimed at the outdoorsy

The X-Pro and X-Pro Prestige have all-terrain tires, all-wheel drive, and all kinds of ground clearance.

Women came from all over the Pacific Northwest to “glamp” and raise money to send girls to Girl Scout Camp from Sept. 16-18. The next opportunity to glamp at Camp River Ranch will be Sept. 8-10, 2023. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Women’s glamping retreat raises money to send local girls to camp

I’ve been the camper, the counselor, the Girl Scout leader and the mom. Now, I was the glamper.

Effective discipline: Why rewards work better than punishment

Rewarding positive behavior, whenever it appears, can be a very powerful tool for encouraging cooperation.

Air Canada voucher for $528 has been missing for three months

Where is Herb Sharpe’s $528 flight voucher from Air Canada? He’s been waiting for more than three months, but the airline hasn’t sent it yet.

Abelia 'Edward Goucher' (Richie Steffen)
Great Plant Pick: Abelia ‘Edward Goucher’

This shrub blooms from summer to late autumn, which will make the pollinators happy.

Most Read