Final Oso mudslide wrongful-death lawsuit heads toward trial

A judge says the state and a timber company must defend themselves in a Seattle courtroom.

Steve Hadaway (John Hadaway)

Steve Hadaway (John Hadaway)

SEATTLE — The final wrongful death lawsuit from the Oso mudslide can go to trial later this year, a judge has ruled.

The family of Steven Hadaway, one of 43 people killed in the slide, is suing the state of Washington and a private timber company. A ruling that King County Superior Court Judge Roger Rogoff issued Thursday will allow attorneys for Hadaway’s estate to argue most of their points in court. Among other issues, a jury could decide whether state officials made the hillside less stable by allowing the construction of a crib wall at its base years earlier. The wall was intended to help shore up the slope.

“Plaintiff has presented enough evidence from which a jury can decide whether (the) defendant state of Washington’s alleged failures to monitor, correct and warn about a potential landslide caused plaintiff’s injuries,” Rogoff wrote.

Attorneys for the other side had tried to persuade the judge to throw out the case, or at least major parts of it.

A trial is scheduled to begin in Seattle on Oct. 28. The case has been assigned to Rogoff, who has overseen the other lawsuits stemming from the disaster. If the case isn’t resolved beforehand, it would be the only Oso mudslide-related lawsuit to go to trial.

The slide struck on a Saturday morning in March 2014, destroying the Steelhead Haven neighborhood, a stretch of Highway 530 and other nearby areas.

Hadaway, a 53-year-old Marine Corps veteran from Darrington, was at work that day. He had gone to a home near the North Fork Stillaguamish River to install a satellite dish. Also killed at the home were an electrician and plumber. So was the homeowner, a nurse who recently moved in.

Hadaway’s body was the second-to-last found, two months after the catastrophe.

About two dozen other plaintiffs filed an earlier group of lawsuits. They settled with the state and Mount Vernon-based Grandy Lake Forest Associates, LLC for a combined $60 million in 2016.

Snohomish County originally was a defendant, but the judge dismissed it from the case. That decision is under appeal.

In 2017, on the eve of the statute of limitations running out, a smaller group of families sued. That included the claim filed by Hadaway’s widow, Margaret Hadaway, on behalf of his estate and his two daughters.

The other claims in that group were settled in April with the state and Grandy Lake. They were due to receive a combined $11.5 million. The settlement included other deaths, as well as people who survived the slide with injuries, psychological trauma or property loss.

Under the judge’s ruling from last week, jurors could hear evidence about the pain and suffering Hadaway experienced in the moments before his death, but not about his family’s grief or anguish.

The lawsuits have attempted to link the deadly mudslide to a 2005 timber harvest on Grandy Lake’s property. The company’s expert witnesses have opined that logging did not make the slope below more vulnerable to landslides.

Rogoff denied Grandy Lake’s motions for summary judgment. The company had argued that as a private landowner, it had no functional ability to warn visitors, such as Hadaway, about potential dangers on nearby property. Grandy Lake contends it owns none of the land where the crib wall was built in 2006.

The plaintiffs contend the crib wall and sediment ponds on state land helped make the soil wetter and added to the mudslide’s destructive power.

Noah Haglund: 425-339-3465; nhaglund @herald net.com. Twitter: @NWhaglund.

Talk to us

More in Local News

The parking lot of a Lynnwood apartment complex in the 19800 block of 50th Avenue West where a man was allegedly stabbed Friday night. (Lynnwood Police)
Lynnwood man arrested for allegedly stabbing acquaintance

They were arguing at an apartment complex and began fighting.

A storm Sunday caused damage to power lines like this on Woods Creek Road in Monroe across Snohomish County. Another storm was projected for later Monday. (Snohomish County PUD)
PUD restores power and braces for new windy problems

About 55,000 Snohomish County PUD customers lost power Sunday. Most of them had their power restored by the next day.

Top row (L-R): Brian Saulsman, Jeremiah Campbell and Mary Reule. Bottom row (L-R): Molly Barnes, Janine Burkhardt and Sarah Johnson. Not pictured (and running unopposed): Jennifer Bumpus.
Mandates, critical race theory steal spotlight in Monroe school races

In Snohomish County, school board races have become a proxy for ideological battles. Monroe is a prime example.

Woman, 60, shot after neighbor dispute near Everett

The suspect, 19, confronted the woman with a shotgun, and allegedly shot her.

Top row (L-R): Kim Daughtry, Michele Hampton, Gary Petershagen, Joyce Copley. Bottom row (L-R): Jessica Wadhams, Steve Ewing, Marcus A. Tageant, Joseph Jensen.
In growing Lake Stevens, controversy frames council races

The city is booming with development. Now four incumbents look to fend off challengers.

Top (L-R): Judy Schwab, Peter Swardstrom. Bottom (L-R): Jayme Lee Vail, Charles Hauck.
Masks? Sex ed? Where do Mukilteo school board candidates stand?

Three newcomers are in races for two seats. In each case, there’s a candidate calling for a “back to basics” approach.

Top (L-R): Alicia Crank, Kristiana Johnson, Janelle Cass. Bottom (L-R): Will Chen, Neil Tibbott, Adrienne Fraley-Monillas.
Q&A: Edmonds candidates talk policy on hot-button issues

Six candidates are running for three City Council seats. The Daily Herald quizzed them on housing, tree code and more.

Caregiver charged with raping Everett woman with dementia

A DNA sample found “very strong support” that Kelvin Njeru was the suspect, prosecutors allege.

Top (L-R): Nate Nehring, Nicole Ng-A-Qui, Jared M. Mead. Bottom (L-R): Brenda Carrington, Sam Low, Brandy Donaghy.
3 challengers face long-shot odds in County Council races

Each race has a clear political divide. And each Snohomish County district reliably leans either red or blue.

Most Read