Ian Simmers, of Kent, sued the city of Bothell and several law enforcement officers after spending about 23 years in prison for a murder he didn’t commit. (Mark Klaas / Kent Reporter file)

Ian Simmers, of Kent, sued the city of Bothell and several law enforcement officers after spending about 23 years in prison for a murder he didn’t commit. (Mark Klaas / Kent Reporter file)

Judge tosses lawsuit filed for man wrongfully convicted of Bothell murder

Ian Simmers spent decades in prison for a 1995 stabbing. In 2019, concerns about his confession and other evidence led to his release.

By Mike Carter / The Seattle Times

BOTHELL — A federal judge in Seattle has dismissed the remaining claims alleging civil rights violations and malicious prosecution by the estate of a man who spent 23 years in prison for a murder he didn’t commit.

After extensive briefing in Ian Simmers’ federal lawsuit, U.S. District Judge Barbara Rothstein in a May 31 order concluded Simmers’ estate had failed to show that detectives and prosecutors intentionally conspired to convict the then-16-year-old of the 1995 stabbing death of 35-year-old Rodney Gochanour and then led him into a false confession.

Simmers, who was released from prison in 2019 when his conviction was overturned, died in a crash last July. His estate, represented by his mother, Donna Berube, continued the litigation.

Simmers in 2021 sued the city of Bothell, King County and several officers and detectives involved in the investigation, alleging violations of his Fourth Amendment protections against illegal seizure, malicious prosecution, negligence, manufacturing of false evidence and withholding exculpatory evidence.

In a 49-page order, Rothstein rejected Simmers’ claims detectives coerced him into a false confession over a 10-hour interrogation without a lawyer or his mother present. The lawsuit claimed the detectives used coercive tactics and fed him details of the crime to encourage a confession.

“This Court has … determined that Plaintiff has failed to present evidence sufficient to allow a reasonable jury to conclude that Defendants knowingly violated Simmers’ constitutional rights,” Rothstein wrote.

David B. Owens, the Seattle attorney who represents Simmers’ estate, said he will appeal the judge’s order to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.

“We are deeply troubled and disappointed by the Court’s order,” he said in a statement last week. “Ian Simmers faced decades of wrongful imprisonment as a result of a legal system that failed, and now the legal system has failed him again.”

Owens added the order credits the officers’ word and disregards Simmers’ account — a decision he said should be left to a jury.

Shannon Ragonesi, the attorney representing the city of Bothell and its officers, praised Rothstein’s decision.

“The Court gave close and careful consideration to this case … and made the correct decision,” she said.

Simmers was arrested March 15, 1995, with a friend after a string of burglaries, arsons and other property crimes along the Burke-Gilman Trail in Bothell. He often bragged about being a gangster and exaggerated his criminal lifestyle, according to court pleadings. While being questioned, he boasted to the officers he committed 13 other murders, according to the pleadings.

When two detectives asked Simmers’ 14-year-old accomplice in the burglaries about the Gochanour killings, the boy allegedly broke down and implicated Simmers, saying he had stolen a knife during one of their criminal forays.

In her order, Rothstein noted Simmers had been in frequent trouble with the law — he had gotten out of juvenile detention the previous day — and knew the system and what he was doing when he talked to the detectives following his arrest.

While acknowledging police used “deceptive tactics” and other common investigative techniques in obtaining the confession, the judge said they were not coercive and “did not overbear Simmers’ will,” and she concluded that Simmers “knowingly and voluntarily confessed to murdering Gochanour” even if the confession was false.

“There is no doubt that he understood the potential consequences of providing a taped confession because he testified that he wanted to be charged with and tried for murder” to beef up his street credibility, Rothstein wrote.

While there is some evidence the 16-year-old’s actions that day “showed some susceptibility to police coercion,” the judge concluded “their relevance pales in comparison to Simmers’ stated desire to confess to Gochanour’s murder to cement his reputation as a gangster.”

She said “there is no evidence” the detectives were aware of his desire or “implanted Simmers’ ill-conceived plan.”

Based primarily on his confession, Simmers was convicted by a jury of Gochanour’s murder and was in prison until the King County Prosecutor’s Office was convinced to take a second look at the case. Concerns about the confession, case inconsistencies and new DNA evidence cast doubts on his conviction, and Simmers was ordered released from custody in 2019.

Police described the murder as a thrill-kill and never offered another motive. The lawsuit alleges detectives failed to investigate other leads, including an angry ex-boyfriend of Gochanour’s girlfriend, or talk to several people to whom he owed money.

Faced with these issues and the difficulties of retrying a two-decade-old case, prosecutors dismissed the case entirely. Simmers subsequently filed the civil rights claim alleging he had been framed for the murder and coerced into confessing.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

A big decision for Boeing’s next CEO: Is it time for a new plane?

As Boeing faces increased competition from Airbus, the company is expected to appoint a new CEO by the end of the year.

A Mukilteo Speedway sign hangs at an intersection along the road in Mukilteo. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Mukilteo Speedway name change is off to a bumpy start

The city’s initial crack at renaming the main drag got over 1,500 responses. Most want to keep the name.

Two workers walk past a train following a press event at the Lynnwood City Center Link Station on Friday, June 7, 2024, in Lynnwood, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Trains up and running on Lynnwood Link — but no passengers quite yet

Officials held an event at the Lynnwood station announcing the start of “pre-revenue” service. Passengers still have to wait till August.

Nedra Vranish, left, and Karen Thordarson, right browse colorful glass flowers at Fuse4U during Sorticulture on Friday, June 7, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
A promenade through Everett’s popular Sorticulture garden festival

Check out a gallery of the festival’s first day.

Left to right, Everett Pride board members Ashley Turner, Bryce Laake, and Kevin Daniels pose for a photo at South Fork Bakery in Everett, Washington on Sunday, May 26, 2024. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Second Everett Pride aims for even bigger rainbow of festivities

Organizers estimated about 3,000 people attended the first block party in Everett. This year, they’re aiming for 10,000.

Everett Herald staff gather and talk in the newsroom after layoff announcements on Wednesday, June 19, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘This breaks my heart’: Over half of Everett Herald news staff laid off

A dozen journalists were handed walking papers Wednesday, in a wave of layoffs mandated by new owners, Carpenter Media Group.

The I-5, Highway 529 and the BNSF railroad bridges cross over Union Slough as the main roadways for north and southbound traffic between Everett and Marysville. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Highway 529 squeeze starts now between Everett, Marysville

Following a full closure for a night, starting late Sunday, Highway 529 will slim down to two lanes for months near the Snohomish River Bridge.

A Mukilteo Speedway sign hangs at an intersection along the road on Sunday, April 21, 2024, in Mukilteo, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Long live the Speedway! Mukilteo’s main drag won’t be renamed

The public shot down the mayor’s idea to change the name: 77% voted ‘No’ in an online survey, with 95% opposed on Facebook.

Motorcyclist dies in crash on East Marine View Drive in Everett

Around 8 p.m. Tuesday, a motorcycle and a vehicle crashed into each other at the intersection of 11th street and East Marine View Drive.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Darrington in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Motorcyclist dies in crash on Highway 530

Jeremy Doyle, 46, was riding east near Darrington when he crashed into the side of a car that was turning left.

The Marysville School District office on Thursday, Aug. 31, 2023 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘Financially insolvent’ Marysville schools to get unprecedented oversight

Superintendent Chris Reykdal will convene a first-of-its-kind Financial Oversight Committee, he wrote in a letter Tuesday.

Woodside Elementary Principal Betty Cobbs on Monday, June 17, 2024 in Bothell, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett’s first Black principal retires after 51 years

In her office, Betty Cobbs kept a black-and-white photo of herself at age 5: “I am right there, with dreams of becoming an educator.”

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.