Oso mudslide civil trial set to start this week in Seattle

OSO — Testimony is expected to begin this week in a civil trial that aims to decide whether anyone should be held responsible for the human suffering connected to the Oso mudslide.

King County Superior Court Judge Roger Rogoff last week told lawyers to plan on making their opening statements in the case Wednesday.

The largest wrongful death case in state history, the trial is scheduled to play out in a Seattle courtroom in front of jurors selected from King County. It will explore the carnage that resulted March 22, 2014, when a wall of mud and trees slammed into the Steelhead Haven neighborhood and raced across the North Fork Stillaguamish Valley. In all, 43 people died and millions of dollars in property damage occurred.

Attorneys representing people harmed in the disaster are suing the state of Washington and Grandy Lake Forest Associates timber company.

They allege the defendants are responsible by making the area more dangerous: the state by approving construction of a crib wall to contain debris from earlier, smaller slides, a project designed to protect fish from silt; the timber company by allowing logging to occur above the area where the hill fell.

Snohomish County was to have been a defendant at the trial, too, but it was dismissed in mid-September. The action came after a series of pretrial rulings by Rogoff that significantly limited the plaintiffs’ ability to claim county officials were negligent in how they responded to the risk of slides, particularly a 2006 event that blocked the river. The plaintiffs say they plan to appeal the rulings that weakened their claims against the county.

Rogoff has yet to decide numerous legal questions related to evidence he’ll allow at trial. Attorneys are scheduled to address those motions Monday.

The judge also has not announced what sanctions, if any, he’ll impose against the state and its attorneys for a secret plan that routinely saw emails deleted among the scientists and engineers, who were hired to offer expert opinions on the results of drilling and other efforts made to determine the disaster’s cause.

Rogoff already has ruled the plaintiffs’ case was prejudiced by not having access to the experts’ emails. He earlier said he needed more information — including review of emails between state lawyers — before deciding the level of harm.

The state’s lawyers insist the deleting was an honest mistake, and that the plaintiffs’ lawyers haven’t been kept from critical information.

Those representing mudslide victims, however, have asked the judge to decide the case in their favor without a trial. In the alternative, they’ve suggested the state be precluded from offering testimony from its experts.

If that happened, jurors would not be told about the results of roughly $3 million worth of scientific studies, including information from the first-ever investigative drilling on the hill.

State experts have submitted reports questioning claims that logging over decades made the hillside prone to collapse. They say drilling shows any increased runoff from harvesting trees in the area didn’t flow toward the slide area as many have long assumed.

They also contend the crib wall had nothing to do with the hill’s collapse, again because drilling shows the soil fractured in an area hundreds of feet away and three stories above the structure. Meanwhile, they argue there was no way to reasonably predict within a human lifetime the timing of a slide like the one unleashed in 2014. Studies since the disaster have found signs of similar mudslide repeatedly racing across the valley for thousands of years.

The plaintiffs have accused the state’s experts of tailoring their findings to insulate the state against liability. They also contend the crib wall contributed to making the soil in the area wetter. The mud contributed to the slide’s size and destruction, independent experts say.

The plaintiffs disagree among themselves on whether sufficient evidence exists to explain how the slide occurred. The lack of agreement means jurors likely will be presented alternate theories of the case, not only from the state and timber company, but also from the different plaintiffs’ attorneys.

Scott North: 425-339-3431; north@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @snorthnews.

Talk to us

More in Local News

A few weeks before what could be her final professional UFC fight, Miranda Granger grimaces as she pushes a 45-pound plate up her driveway on Tuesday, July 12, 2022, in Lake Stevens, Washington. Her daughter Austin, age 11 months, is strapped to her back. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Daily Herald staff wins 5 honors at annual journalism competition

The Herald got one first-place win and four runner-up spots in SPJ’s Northwest Excellence in Journalism contest.

Panelists from different areas of mental health care speak at the Herald Forum about mental health care on Wednesday, May 31, 2023 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
At panel, mental health experts brainstorm answers to staff shortages

Workforce shortages, insurance coverage and crisis response were in focus at the Snohomish forum hosted by The Daily Herald.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Snohomish in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Report of downed hot air balloon turns up farmer’s tarp near Snohomish

Two 911 callers believed they saw a hot air balloon crash, leading to a major search-and-rescue response. It was a false alarm.

People gather for a color throw at Stanwood and Camano’s first-ever Pride celebration on Saturday, June 4, 2022. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘We’ve at least come a little ways’: Snohomish to host first Pride event

A 10 a.m. parade on First Street will be followed by a pop-up market with 60 vendors, a downtown wine walk, queer cabaret and more.

The site of a former 76 gas station and a handful of century old buildings will be the location for new apartments buildings at the corner of Pacific and Rucker on Wednesday, May 31, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Old gas station demolished for apartments in downtown Everett

A 200-unit apartment complex between three and seven stories tall is proposed at Pacific and Rucker avenues.

Kamiak High School is pictured Friday, July 8, 2022, in Mukilteo, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Kamiak football coach fired amid sexual misconduct investigation

Police believe Julian Willis, 34, sexually abused the student in portable classrooms on Kamiak High School’s campus.

Marysville
Police: Marysville man fist-bumped cop, exposing tattoos of wanted robber

The suspect told police he robbed three stores to pay off a drug debt. He’d just been released from federal prison for another armed robbery.

Everett
Cat killed, 9 people displaced after duplex fire in Everett

None of the people were injured in the fire reported around 1:15 a.m. in the 11500 block of Meridian Avenue S.

Gabriela Kelpe at her home on Friday, June 2, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Long waits, big bills: Everett mom’s painful search for dental care

When she learned she needed a root canal, Gabriela Kelpe read an infection could go to her unborn baby. But she struggled to get affordable care.

Most Read