Was Oso mudslide nature’s mystery or man’s mistake?

OSO — Nearly a year after the worst disaster in modern Snohomish County history, a legal battle continues to take shape over whether somebody should be held responsible.

Was the March 22, 2014, mudslide near Oso a tragic display of natural forces reshaping the land, or a calamity caused by human hands?

Did local governments have a duty to discourage people from making their homes along the banks of the North Fork Stillaguamish River beneath a slide-prone hill, a place where 43 people later lost their lives?

So far, four lawsuits have been brought in King County Superior Court by those who lost family and homes. Three of the cases, representing the bulk of the plaintiffs, have been consolidated for a single trial, now scheduled for October.

Defendants include Snohomish County, the state of Washington and Grandy Lake Forest Associates, LLC. The Skagit County-based timber company not only owned part of the hill that fell but also engaged in limited logging there years before.

Seattle attorneys Corrie Yackulic and John Phillips represent the largest bloc of families. Yackulic can’t say much about what her team has learned. By March 23, she and the other plaintiffs’ attorneys are expected to tell the court which experts they’ll be relying on to help make their case.

“We are working really hard,” Yackulic said.

So far, there have been 20 depositions. Another 50 are expected, said Jason Cummings, the county’s chief civil deputy prosecutor.

Attorneys also have gathered up and pored over hundreds of thousands of pages of public records, scientific reports and other documents.

“This isn’t a sprint. This is a marathon,” Cummings said.

While the litigation promises to focus heavily on earth sciences, land-use policy and forest practices, attorneys are mindful that people are at the core of the case.

“Our hearts go out to the families of all those affected by the slide,” Cummings said.

The legal arguments

The theories advanced by the plaintiffs in court pleadings are nuanced and complex. Still, they could be summarized something like this: Logging on the bench above the hillside allegedly allowed unnatural amounts of water to seep into the slope, lubricating already slippery soils. Gravity and the gnawing river below worked to repeatedly bring down blocks of earth. Over decades, state and county officials responded with ineffective measures. They allowed more trees to be cut, more homes to be built nearby and put the greatest emphasis on fighting flooding and protecting fish. Those who lived nearby were reassured they were safe, the plaintiffs allege, particularly when work was done to control erosion after a large slide in 2006 that blocked the river.

The defendants’ legal responses could be boiled down this way: the slide was an act of of God or nature; officials acted in good faith and made decisions protected by law, particularly in response to flood risks; if mistakes were made, not all the defendants are equally to blame; and the plaintiffs’ own actions may have contributed to the harm.

This “case is being litigated as if it were — as one would expect it to be — a very large case,” attorney Elaine Spencer of Seattle said in court papers filed on behalf of her client, Grandy Lake.

The logging company is challenging allegations that it is partly responsible for the tragedy. It also maintains those claims should not be heard by a King County jury, but by people from Skagit or Snohomish counties, where it does business. That argument so far has found no traction with the King County judge. Grandy Lake has asked the state Court of Appeals to review the pre-trial ruling.

Pleadings demonstrate little agreement among the lawyers on the significance and meaning of scientific reports prepared prior to the slide. Plaintiffs maintain the reports were filled with red flags. Defendants counter that people have cherry picked information and presented it out of context to butress claims not supported by science.

Much remains unknown.

A January report released by a team of U.S. Geological Survey scientists determined that months of near-record rainfall played a key role in the hill’s collapse. The super soggy soil also added to the slide’s destructive power. The report made clear that more work needs to be done to understand how water entered and moved around the bluff.

Likewise, given the evidence of past slides near Oso, dating back eons, renewed activity should come as no surprise from a “geological perspective,” the report’s authors found. But they made clear that’s different from having the data necessary to forecast the slide’s timing and the mobility of the 10.8 million cubic yards of debris it unleashed.

To do so “would have required knowledge that was unavailable,” the report found.

Scott North: 425-339-3431; north@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @snorthnews

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Snohomish residents Barbara Bailey, right, and Beth Jarvis sit on a gate atop a levee on Bailey’s property on Monday, May 13, 2024, at Bailey Farm in Snohomish, Washington. Bailey is concerned the expansion of nearby Harvey Field Airport will lead to levee failures during future flood events due to a reduction of space for floodwater to safely go. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Harvey Field seeks to reroute runway in floodplain, faces new pushback

Snohomish farmers and neighbors worry the project will be disruptive and worsen flooding. Ownership advised people to “read the science.”

IAM District 751 machinists join the picket line to support Boeing firefighters during their lockout from the company on Thursday, May 16, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Amid lockout, Boeing, union firefighters return to bargaining table

The firefighters and the planemaker held limited negotiations this week: They plan to meet again Monday, but a lockout continues.

A mountain goats in the North Cascades east of Marblemount in August 2017. (Caleb Hutton / The Herald)
Ahead of grizzly arrival, wildlife advocates assess past translocations

Moving animals has helped struggling populations to rebound. And advocates point to past examples as evidence that “it’s not ethical to do nothing.”

Julie Timm
Sound Transit’s $375K payout to ex-CEO didn’t buy help

Board members said Julie Timm would give professional advice to them or a future CEO after leaving, but she hasn’t been called upon.

FILE -- An engine on a Boeing 767 jet aircraft, at a Boeing facility in Everett, Wash., March 7, 2012. The Boeing 737 engine that failed on Southwest Flight 1380 is not the only one that has caught the eye of regulators: Engines on Boeing's 787 Dreamliner and 767 have also failed, prompting questions about their design and inspection procedures. (Stuart Isett/The New York Times)
Boeing 767, built in Everett, gets 5-year lifeline from Congress

Boeing would have been forced to end production of the 767 Freighter in 2027 due to new emissions rules if not for the extension.

Snohomish County Jail. (Herald file)
Inmate, 51, dies at Snohomish County Jail

Around 3 p.m., corrections staff called 911 about an inmate, who became unresponsive as firefighters arrived. He died at the scene.

With the Olympic mountains in the background, Boeing's 777x lifts off from Paine Field on its first flight, to Boeing Field in Seattle, on Saturday, Jan. 25, 2020 in Everett, Wash. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
1 dead, dozens injured after turbulence on Boeing plane

A Singapore Airlines flight from London was diverted to Bangkok, where more than 70 people were being treated for injuries.

Two people fight on the side of I-5 neat Marysville. (Photo provided by WSDOT)
Idaho man identified in fatal trooper shooting on I-5 near Everett

The deceased man was Marvin Arellano, 31, of Nampa, Idaho, according to the Snohomish County Medical Examiner’s Office.

State Sen. Mark Mullet, left, and Attorney General Bob Ferguson, are both running as Democrats for governor in 2024. (Photos provided)
Did Bob Ferguson go too far responding to fellow Fergusons?

Ferguson wanted the secretary of state to redo the ballot. Mark Mullet, a Democratic rival, says such a move would’ve broken the law.

Photo by Gina Shields of GM Photography
Whidbey Island to salute the fallen for Memorial Day

All are invited to honor those who have fallen at three events on Whidbey Island.

Boeing firefighters and supporters hold an informational picket at Airport Road and Kasch Park Road on Monday, April 29, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Boeing union firefighters to vote on new contract proposal

The company made the offer after “a productive session” of bargaining and reported the amended contract includes an “improved wage growth schedule.”

Catholic Community Services NW Director of Housing Services and Everett Family Center Director Rita Jo Case, right, speaks to a man who asked to remain anonymous, left, during a point-in-time count of people facing homelessness in Everett, Washington on Tuesday, Jan. 24, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Homelessness down nearly 10% in Snohomish County, annual count shows

The county identified 1,161 people without permanent housing, down from 1,285 last year. But lack of resources is still a problem, advocates said.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.