Puget Sound communities, such as Edmonds, aren’t likely to build a seawall to prepare for rising seas, but some properties and infrastructure will require investment to protect them. (Daniel Johnson /Herald file photo)

Puget Sound communities, such as Edmonds, aren’t likely to build a seawall to prepare for rising seas, but some properties and infrastructure will require investment to protect them. (Daniel Johnson /Herald file photo)

Editorial: Measuring the costs of preparing for rising seas

A new report estimates the costs of seawalls. They’re not a good fit for Puget Sound, but what is?

By The Herald Editorial Board

The wall we ought to be building isn’t along the U.S. southern border with Mexico but along more than 50,000 miles of coastal shoreline in 22 states, according to a recent report on sea-level rise.

And its costs would dwarf anything so far proposed for President Trump’s wall, regardless of who’s paying: $400 billion in the next 20 years, an amount that would nearly rival what was spent to build the interstate highway system.

Last month, the Center for Climate Integrity, affiliated with the Canadian-based Institute for Governance and Sustainability, released its report, “The High Tide Tax,” a comprehensive analysis of the costs of addressing sea-level rise along the coastline of the contiguous United States between now and 2040.

The report says its intention is to encourage the public and elected representatives to honestly face and begin preparing for the massive costs ahead in responding and adapting to global warming and the resulting changes in climate. Even assuming the U.S. and other large producers of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases might eventually slow those emissions and avoid the worst temperature increases, the slow nature of the physics behind sea-level rise would mean oceans and inland seas will continue to rise regardless.

The report bases its costs estimates on predictions of sea-level rise coupled with flooding from a one-year storm event, the type of storm seen as typical each year.

In Florida, with nearly 8,500 miles of coastline, the report estimates it would cost about $75.9 billion to build enough seawall to protect near-shore property and infrastructure, a figure that rises to $109.4 billion to offer the protection necessary by 2100.

With more than 3,000 miles of coastline, Washington state’s bill would be about a third of Florida’s: $23.9 billion to protect 1,651 miles of shoreline by 2040, most of that within the Puget Sound region.

The report drills down even further, offering cost estimates by congressional district, county and even one for Possession Sound’s Hat Island. Offering estimates for per-capita costs for select communities, the report estimates that protections for Hat Island’s threatened properties would amount to $2.1 million per person, based on the island’s few dozen residents. That’s a bargain next to Junction City in Gray’s Harbor County along the Washington coast, where the per capita cost was pegged at $7.2 million, the highest per capita cost cited in the report.

For Snohomish County — with shoreline communities that include Stanwood, the Tulalip reservation, Marysville, Everett, Lynnwood and Edmonds — the projected seawall costs are $1.1 billion.

Those communities, in the county and throughout the Puget Sound region, however, aren’t going to rush to raise the bulwarks anytime within in the next 20 years. If anything, the move in recent years — in response to the obligation to improve habitat for salmon and other marine wildlife — has been to breach dikes and other barriers.

In Snohomish County, work continues near Smith Island to restore more than 1,200 acres of marine estuary — part of a 2005 salmon recovery plan for the Snohomish River basin — by breaching dikes that were built in the first half of the 20th century and earlier to create agricultural land. That work is similar to a project by the Tulalip Tribes at the Qwuloolt Estuary and the Port of Everett’s Blue Heron Slough project, which begins this year.

The ethic in Western Washington, pointed out in a story in Crosscut about the CCI report, has been to recognize the damage that seawalls, bulkheads and other barriers have done to marine habitats, seeking to limit and mitigate their impacts if not remove them.

The report’s estimate of seawall costs, CCI responded to Crosscut, was offered as a way to measure the costs of a range of responses across the nation to sea-level rise, as opposed to advising a single cure.

That comparison, however, may be of limited value.

“I don’t know if it’s a good proxy for the cost of adaptation,” Guillame Mauger, with the Washington Coastal Resilience Project, told Crosscut. “I can think of some cases where the damages due to flooding, in the absence of a seawall, could be comparable or greater than the expense of building a seawall. In the long run, on the other hand, I would expect ‘nonstructural approaches’ [like] buyouts and retreat would be less expensive.”

What is of value, however, is the recognition of the threat that sea-level rise in the next 20 years and beyond poses to property and infrastructure and what preparations must be made to answer that threat.

Add to that the even higher costs that will be incurred if those preparations aren’t made.

Washington state, according to WCRP projections, can expect an average of about 5 inches of sea-level rise by 2040 and more than a foot by 2100. The hazard increases during storm events that can push water onshore or flooding that comes down river, jeopardizing what’s near shore or in the path of a flood, including homes, businesses, roads, sewage lines and treatment plants, ports and marinas, roads, schools, hospitals, nursing homes, gas stations, parks and military bases, to name a few.

Even if we aren’t likely to build that wall, it doesn’t mean we can escape the costs of preparing for rising seas and climate change.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

FILE - In this undated photo, provided by NY Governor's Press Office on Saturday March 27, 2021, is the new "Excelsior Pass" app, a digital pass that people can download to show proof of vaccination or a negative COVID-19 test. Vaccine passports being developed to verify COVID-19 immunization status and allow inoculated people to more freely travel, shop and dine have become the latest flash point in America’s perpetual political wars, with Republicans portraying them as a heavy-handed intrusion into personal freedom and private health choices. (NY Governor's Press Office via AP, File)
Editorial: Vaccine passports can nudge more toward immunity

Used to persuade rather than exclude, the passports could increase access to businesses and venues.

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, April 14

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Eric Brossard displays his commemorative Drug Court graduation coin that reads, "I came with hope, worked and learned. I have a new life. A life that I've earned." (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Court ruling requires focus on addiction treatment

A court decision allows for a more effective and affordable solution to substance use disorder.

An architectual illustration shows the proposed Learning Resource Center at Everett Community College. The centerAn architectual illustration shows the proposed Learning Resource Center at Everett Community College. The center would replace the college's Libary Media Center, built in 1988. The Senate capital budget proposal allocates $48 million for its construction, while the House budget includes no funding for it. (Courtesy of Everett Community College) would replace the college's
Editorial: Capital budget a bipartisan boost for communities

House and Senate proposals are substantial and needed, but final talks should secure an EvCC project.

Ian Terry / The Herald

Glass art by Merrilee Moore is seen at the Sorticulture Festival in Everett on Friday, June 9, 2017.

Photo taken on 06092017
Editorial: A return to live events if covid’s spell is broken

Everett’s Sorticulture, July 4th and other events are on the calendar, but infections need better control.

Comment: Build-to-rent could be affordable housing solution

Building neighborhoods of single-family and higher-density homes could get past NIMBY objections.

Comment: Media again key to ending voting rights filibuster

TV newsman Roger Mudd’s daily reports in 1964 kept the Civil Rights Act filibuster in public view.

Edmonds school levy will fund important building upgrades

Last year was extraordinarily challenging, so I’m glad to see students and… Continue reading

Rants and raves over the crisis at the southern border

Rant to border officials who tried to prevent pictures of the current… Continue reading

Most Read