A magazine ad from the 1930s uses an illustration of a physician who recommends Lucky Strike cigarettes as "less irritating."

Editorial: Reject Big Tobacco’s plea to clear nicotine’s name

Altria wants the FDA to help it promote new products as ‘healthier’ alternatives to smoking.

By The Herald Editorial Board

Many of us have seen — or may even remember — advertising from the 1930s through 1950s in which a family doctor — in a white coat, spectacles and a friendly smile — prescribes a particular brand of cigarettes as “less irritating” if not just plain healthier for his patients.

It was no coincidence, of course, that the “physician-approved” ad campaigns came along as mounting research confirmed the health concerns about cigarettes and the dangers of smoking, even before the days of the Surgeon General’s Warning on every pack regarding the clear threats of cancer and heart and lung diseases.

So, while today you might find a doctor who smokes, you won’t find many who would recommend cigarettes or any tobacco product for their patients. And you certainly don’t see those ads anymore, except as a look back at antiquated ideas of what passed for good advice on health. The more than 480,000 annual U.S. deaths attributed to cigarette smoking and tobacco have been effective in countering that message.

Not that a similar marketing idea hasn’t occurred to at least one tobacco company.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Tobacco giant Altria Group isn’t making a pitch to doctors to again tout the health benefits of nicotine, the addictive agent in tobacco products. No, it’s seeking the help of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

Altria, reports Bloomberg, is asking the FDA to use its considerable public information reach to help correct the impression among three-fourths of U.S. adults who falsely believe that nicotine causes cancer. The makers of Marlboro cigarettes, in a letter to the FDA, want to persuade the agency to assist in switching cigarette smokers to “healthier” ways of delivering nicotine’s dopamine punch, methods that merely heat the tobacco, rather than burning it, which produces the more than 60 well-known cancer-causing agents inhaled in tobacco smoke.

Altria’s letter said the FDA’s help would aid the agency’s own goals of encouraging better health outcomes by getting more smokers to use non-combustible products that “may present lower health risk.”

In response to the request, the FDA wasn’t exactly reaching for its white coat and spectacles; it declined to comment, Bloomberg reported.

It’s true that nicotine — on its own — isn’t a carcinogen; but neither is it an elixir of health.

“Nicotine isn’t benign,” Eric Lindblom, a former senior adviser to the FDA’s Center for Tobacco Products, and now a senior scholar at Georgetown University, told Bloomberg. Studies show that it can interfere with brain development and birth outcomes, he said. “It’s an agricultural poison in large doses.”

The U.S. Surgeon General declared in 2010 that nicotine is one of the most addictive agents known; as addictive as cocaine and heroin. By stimulating the brain’s transmission of dopamine, the nicotine inhaled by tobacco users — including those who use the vaping devices most popular with youths — can produce addiction after smoking less than 100 times, the FDA has reported.

As for youths, whose brains still are developing, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention warn that nicotine can be harmful, contributing to problems with concentration, learning, memory and impulse control. The rise in vaping’s popularity — and youths’ own misunderstanding about what they are inhaling when using e-cigarettes — leaves them open to nicotine addiction and a range of harmful chemicals and metals, including lead, nickel and tin, linked to lung disease.

Research published in 2015, by the National Institutes of Health, found that while nicotine isn’t a carcinogen itself, it can work with other carcinogens by causing DNA mutations and combining with cancer-causing agents from vehicle exhaust, wood smoke and cigarettes to shorten the development time of cancers, including lung, pancreatic and breast cancers.

Other DNA mutations caused by nicotine can pass along genes for nicotine dependence from mothers to their children.

Nicotine isn’t completely without merit. A 2014 article in Harvard Health Publishing, reports that it can have beneficial uses and even healing properties. Researchers are testing nicotine for treatments in Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, ADHD and other conditions; and health practitioners have long noticed the increased use of tobacco by patients with schizophrenia, depression and anxiety disorders who may be using it to self-medicate.

But that research is reason to continue studying the possible pharmaceutical uses of nicotine; it’s not justification to promote the use of nicotine among the general public.

Altria still has much invested in the cigarette smokers it has hooked. It generated 86 percent of its $20.8 billion in annual revenue from cigarettes and cigars, Bloomberg reported.

But that market is declining — when it isn’t dying off — and Altria and other tobacco companies are desperate to move smokers to new ways of using their tobacco, hence its stake in Juul, the maker of e-cigarettes. Tobacco companies are especially keen to adapt as the FDA has considered regulations that could mandate lower allowable levels of nicotine in their products; the stuff that keeps customers coming back for more.

The vintage ads of family docs — temples graying with wisdom and experience — advocating for a “less irritating” brand of cigarettes are good for a laugh now. Altria’s request to the FDA merits only an irritated hoot.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, June 14

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

AP government students at Henry M. Jackson High School visited the state Capitol this spring and watched as a resolution they helped draft was adopted in the Senate as part of the Building Bridges Future Leaders Academy. (Josh Estes / Building Bridges)
Comment: Future leaders learn engineering of building bridges

Here’s what Jackson High government students learned with the help of local officials and lawmakers.

Comment: Early cancer diagnosis can be key in saving lives

An act in Congress would allow Medicare coverage for early-detection tests for a range of cancers.

Comment: In wildfire crisis, options for forests, communities

By thinning threatened forests, mass timber can use that material for homes, businesses and more.

Forum: Everett’s land-use plan should keep affordable housing tool

Its comprehensive plan should keep inclusionary zoning, setting aside housing for working families.

Forum: Advice to young adults, focus on your best ‘person’

Past generations focused on the character aspects of gender roles, but something more basic is necessary.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, June 13

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

In a gathering similar to many others across the nation on Presidents Day, hundreds lined Broadway with their signs and chants to protest the Trump administration Monday evening in Everett. (Aaron Kennedy / Daily Herald)
Editorial: Let’s remember the ‘peaceably’ part of First Amendment

Most of us understand the responsibilities of free speech; here’s how we remind President Trump.

The Buzz: ‘Your majesty, the peasants are revolting!’

Well, that’s a little harsh, but we’re sure the ‘No Kings’ protesters clean up well after their marches.

Schwab: Why keep up nonviolent protests? Because they work

Our greatest democratic victories came on the heels of massive, nationwide demonstrations.

Bouie: Trump’s weaknesses show through theater of strength

His inability to calmly confront opposition and respond with force betrays brittleness and insecurity.

Add your voice to protect freedoms at No Kings Day protests

Imagine it’s 2045. Nationwide, women have been fully stripped of rights to… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.