Forum: Bill of Rights’ guarantees come with limits and duties

The rights it offers each citizen, such as the Second Amendment, are balanced against the rights of others.

By Dennis Doolittle / Herald Forum

Although it’s true the Bill of Rights embodies us all with certain guaranteed rights, those rights are not unlimited, as some mistakenly believe. I can’t help but think that the author of one recent Forum essay may believe as such.

If I may, our freedom of speech can be restricted as to time, place or manner by government. Speech that is not protected includes incitement, defamation, fraud, obscenity, child pornography, certain threats, libel, slander and hate speech. Podcaster Alex Jones learned this the hard way.

Our freedom of religion does not protect the use of illegal drugs, not having to pay taxes, discrimination in employment, polygamy or refusing to testify in court or being drafted without exception. It does come with two provisions though, the Establishment and Free Exercise Clauses to protect against a state-sponsored religion and to protect public health and safety, such as requiring child inoculations respectively.

We can protest, yet it must be peacefully. We can’t legally protest on others’ private property, in the street without a permit, at any time desired, block access to public sidewalks and buildings or physically disrupt counter-protesters.

It’s rather ironic the author uses the threat that regulating the Second Amendment opens the door to losing other rights, as this is the same warning by those against this Supreme Court’s recent overturning of Roe w. Wade, which had regulations. The thing is, no one’s threatening to take away all guns. Additionally, it’s interesting that an unwillingness to have government politicians having control over one’s rights is also now shared by the vast majority of women across this country.

I’m not allowed enough words here to adequately address Justice Antonin Scalia’s faulty Heller decision in 2008, suffice to say that for the first time in the Court’s history he rejected the long- held precedence of a “collective” interpretation in favor of an “individual” one. I submit a third interpretation of the Second Amendment to mean that it ensures a “civic duty” and seems closer to the Preamble’s intent of providing for the common defense by addressing an agreed weakness of the earlier Articles of Confederation. But the Court’s misinterpretation isn’t really my main point.

More to the subject at hand, it should be duly noted Scalia also wrote “the right to bear arms has never been unlimited; it plainly is not a right to have and carry any weapon in any manner for any purpose.” Fun fact: We’ve had a long history of gun regulations dating back to colonial times and the country’s still in one piece, if barely.

It’s vital to everyone’s freedoms to realize when two or more citizens are involved, rights also carry responsibilities and consequences. Hopefully all of this clears up the notion that we are free to do whatever, whenever and wherever to whomever we want.

Dennis Doolittle lives in Arlington.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

A Sabey Corporation data center in East Wenatchee, Wash., on Nov. 3, 2024. The rural region is changing fast as electricians from around the country plug the tech industry’s new, giant data centers into its ample power supply. (Jovelle Tamayo/The New York Times)
Editorial: Protect utililty ratepayers as data centers ramp up

State lawmakers should move ahead with guardrails for electricity and water use by the ‘cloud’ and AI.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Monday, Feb. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Coment: Ice not just breaking the law; it’s trying to rewrite it

It’s interpretation allows warrantless arrests not intended by the law. Courts will need to end this abuse.

Dowd: What ‘Melania’ reveals about the first lady isn’t a shocker

Aside from some warm thoughts about immigration that ignore her husband’s policies, any care is about self-care.

Comment: German leader Trump most resembles isn’t who you think

Kaiser Wilhem, who led Germany into World War I, had a lust for flattery and an indifference to others’ welfare.

Murray must play hardball with GOP over DHS and ICE funding

On Jan. 29, Sen. Patty Murray voted to split off Homeland Security… Continue reading

Governor should have been more cautious on ICE protests

In his Jan. 26 press conference, Gov. Bob Ferguson made a call… Continue reading

Advocates for people with intellectual and developmental disabilities rallied on the state capitol steps on Jan. 17. The group asked for rate increases for support staff and more funding for affordable housing. (Laurel Demkovich/Washington State Standard)
Editorial: Limit redundant reviews of those providing care

If lawmakers can’t boost funding for supported living, they can cut red tape that costs time.

FILE — Federal agents arrest a protester during an active immigration enforcement operation in a Minneapolis neighborhood, Jan. 13, 2026. The chief federal judge in Minnesota excoriated Immigration and Customs Enforcement on Wednesday, Jan. 28, saying it had violated nearly 100 court orders stemming from its aggressive crackdown in the state and had disobeyed more judicial directives in January alone than “some federal agencies have violated in their entire existence.” (David Guttenfelder/The New York Times)
Editorial: Ban on face masks assures police accountability

Concerns for officer safety can be addressed with investigation of threats and charges for assaults.

Robotic hand playing hopscotch on a keyboard. Artifical intelligence, text generators, ai and job issues concept. Vector illustration.
Editorial: Help the county write rules for AI’s robots

A civic assembly of 40 volunteers will be asked to draft policy for AI use in county government.

Bad Bunny on stage during his residency at the Coliseo de Puerto Rico José Miguel Agrelot in San Juan, Puerto Rico, Aug. 9, 2025. Bad Bunny’s three-month concert series in San Juan is spurring a short-term surge in Puerto Rico’s economy. (Amy Lombard/The New York Times)
Comment: NFL suits up Bad Bunny in long drive for global appeal

President Trump and others don’t like the halftime choice, but the NFL’s bet is that Latinos will.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.