Forum: The attributes shared by jazz and American culture

Jazz is stupid. So, perhaps, is our culture. But both also offer freeing and spontaneous conversations.

By Jim Strickland / Herald Forum

There is an episode of “The Office” where Angela is distraught after discovering that one of her closest co-workers is having an affair with her husband. It goes something like this:

Angela: I feel so stupid. I sit next to him every day.

Dwight: You’re not stupid. Jazz is stupid.

Angela: (sobbing) Jazz is stupid. I mean, just play the right notes!

Dwight: I know.

My wife gets a kick out of this and reminds me of it every time I turn on my favorite jazz radio station. It probably resonates with some of you as well.

What is it about jazz that makes some people think of it as “stupid”? Well, jazz is not always melodic or predictable. It is expressive, creative, improvisational, responsive; maybe not always easy to hum along with or dance to.

I’ve heard jazz musicians say that the only way to listen to jazz is live. Jazz is a conversation among musicians, their instruments, each other, and the listening audience. It never goes to the same place twice. A prerecorded version is just not a true jazz experience.

I think American culture has a lot in common with jazz, emphasizing freedom, spontaneity, creative expression, responsiveness. There is a scaffolding of tune or melody, but a lot of wiggle room around that scaffolding for improvising and innovating. That is why it is so difficult to define American culture. It is a living, breathing, changing thing that is not simply handed down intact from generation to generation. It is real people responding in real time to each other, to situations, to problems, and to opportunities with creative thinking and action.

And American culture is not just a conversation between individuals, but among other cultures, groups, faiths, and ideas as well. When this conversation happens honestly, openly, and in good faith, we all learn and are better for the experience. It is something beautiful and amazing.

So maybe jazz is not stupid after all. Maybe jazz is art in the truest sense of the word. And maybe that art is America itself.

Jim Strickland is a teacher at Marysville Getchell High School and lives in Marysville.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Getty Images
Window cleaner using a squeegee to wash a window with clear blue sky
Editorial: Auditor’s Office tools provide view into government

Good government depends on transparency into its actions. We need to make use of that window.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Aug. 9

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Eco-nomics: Facing similar flood threat, two counties respond

A look at Kerr County, Texas, and Snohomish County shows the value of planning for climate resiliency.

Comment: Efforts in this Washington offer hope for civic health

Several state and local efforts are championing civil discourse. And they’re seeking your help.

Edie Everette
Forum: Why pick up a penny when it’s only worth a thought?

A dusty penny finds purchase in thoughts of growing up poor, luck and kindness to the next person.

Forum: The attributes shared by jazz and American culture

Jazz is stupid. So, perhaps, is our culture. But both also offer freeing and spontaneous conversations.

Comment: RFK Jr.’s mRNA vaccine decision most terrifying yet

The HHS secretary used falsehoods to justify ending research funding for breakthrough vaccine tech.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Aug. 8

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Schwab: Just (ignore) the facts, ma’am. Or you’re fired.

When the numbers contradict Trump’s claims or his math, the facts are about to get pink-slipped.

Ending EPA’s clean air rule will poison environment

On July 29, Lee Zeldin, head of Trump’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA),… Continue reading

Officials won’t stop urban sprawl, like Eastview Village

I support the community members who are appealing the approval of the… Continue reading

Mukilteo’s speed cameras aren’t very friendly

The recent installation of speed cameras in so called “Park Zones” in… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.