The Seattle Mariners’ Felix Hernandez walks off the field after being relieved during the third inning of a baseball game against the Boston Red Sox in Boston, Saturday, May 11, 2019. (AP Photo/Michael Dwyer)

The Seattle Mariners’ Felix Hernandez walks off the field after being relieved during the third inning of a baseball game against the Boston Red Sox in Boston, Saturday, May 11, 2019. (AP Photo/Michael Dwyer)

POLL RESULTS: Mariners shouldn’t re-sign Hernandez

Nearly two-thirds of responders said they wouldn’t bring Felix back next season on a low-cost deal.

It seems Seattle Mariners fans’ feelings a bout Felix Hernandez gravitate more toward practicality than sentimentality.

This week’s Seattle Sidelines poll concerned the Mariners’ longtime ace pitcher. Hernandez, who has spent the past 15 seasons in Seattle and owns most of the franchise’s career pitching records, becomes a free agent this offseason, and there’s been no indication the Mariners are interested in re-signing the 33-year-old, who’s been in steady decline since 2015. Hernandez may be a former American League Cy Young Award winner and six-time All-Star, but his profile doesn’t fit into Seattle’s rebuilding plan.

However, Felix’s struggles in recent years have some speculating he may have difficulty getting any substantial offers this offseason. Therefore, he may be available on the cheap, and if that ends up being true I can see a case being made for the Mariners bringing Hernandez back on a low-cost deal, particularly because of the loyalty Hernandez has shown to Seattle.

Therefore, this week’s poll put the readers into general manager Jerry Dipoto’s shoes. If you were Dipoto, would you re-sign Hernandez on a low-investment deal? Here’s how you voted:


Add the two together and 63 percent of the voters said they would not re-sign Hernandez to a low-investment deal, while 37 percent said they would. The numbers were consistent between the Twitter poll and the blog poll, so this would seem to be an accurate take on how the fans feel.

It wasn’t a complete landslide. Thirty-seven percents is still a significant number, so there’s a substantial section of the Mariners fan base that remains loyal to Hernandez. And if one were to look at the potential rotation members for next season’s team, there aren’t a lot of options. You have Marco Gonzales and Yusei Kikuchi under contract, and the team has an option on Wade Leblanc. But after that you’re looking at young pitchers like Justus Sheffield and Erik Swanson, who have yet to show effectiveness at the major-league level, along with whoever might be available as free agents. Given the Mariners are smack dab in the middle of rebuilding, it’s hard to see them committing heavy financial resources in starting pitching this offseason. Could that make Hernandez an option as an innings eater if he can be retained that the right price?

Of course, to be an innings eater a pitcher needs to be healthy, and that’s not something Hernandez has been in recent years. This season, though he’s set to return this weekend from a lat strain, he’s made just eight starts and thrown just 38.2 innings. In 2018 he made 28 starts and tossed 155.2 innings, but the year before that it was just 16 starts and 86.2 innings. So while the Mariners may be OK with having someone in next season’s rotation who is just taking up space, there’s no guarantee that even if Hernandez is re-signed he’d be able to give the Mariners that.

It’s been a sad end to “The King’s” tenure with the Mariners. For so long Hernandez was the player who was loyal, staying with Seattle through all the losing seasons, sticking with the Mariners despite failing to see the postseason in 15 years. Every five days the King’s Court would be in session, and the fans with yellow t-shirts and K cards would be in full voice. But the last few years we’ve watched Hernandez diminish, and it seems the majority of fans are ready for the relationship to come to an end.

Talk to us

More in Sports

Former Washington football coach Jim Lambright dies at 77

He spent nearly four decades with the Husky program as a player, assistant coach and head coach.

In this Feb. 21, 2001, file photo, Seattle Mariners’ manager Lou Piniella puts his arm around Japanese player Ichiro Suzuki as workouts begin at their spring training camp in Peoria, Ariz. (AP Photo/Lenny Ignelzi)
POLL: Which Mariners season generates the best memories?

With the start of baseball season delayed, we conjure up positives from past Seattle seasons.

A shining moment in UW history is often forgotten

10 years later, Quincy Pondexter’s game-winner against Marquette in the NCAA tournament is lost in time.

Analysis: Seahawks have added depth to 2020 offensive line

Taking a look at all the o-linemen signed for next season and where they might fit on Seattle’s roster.

She’s 101 and bowled a 159 before coronavirus shut the lanes

Carol Perry can’t celebrate her 102nd birthday bowling Tuesday. But maybe her kids will get her a Wii.

Opening day comes and goes with no baseball

M’s fans, and employees, are left with a feeling of emptiness as the country battles a pandemic.

Edmonds-Woodway grad Hardy has Tommy John surgery

The relief pitcher, who signed with the Twins in the offseason, is expected to miss the 2020 season.

Indianapolis 500 postponed until August because of COVID-19

The historic IndyCar race won’t run on Memorial Day weekend for the first time since 1946.

Storm’s Bird still plans to compete in 2021 Olympics

The WNBA legend, who turns 40 in October, still plans to play despite the Games being delayed.

Silvertips sign forward prospect Ben Hemmerling

The 2004-born forward was Everett’s third-round pick in the 2019 WHL bantam draft.

Wichita State’s Stevenson transferring to Washington

The shooting guard, who starred at Timberline, averaged 11.1 points per game last season.

Locals named to Associated Press all-state teams

Two local players earned all-state nods and six others were honorable mentions.