Squeamish in Seattle: The commercial consequences of unrest

When vandalism and arson are persistent dangers, insurers notice — and doing business gets expensive.

Tom Hoban

Tom Hoban

Since April, three of the nation’s top 30 most expensive construction site fires were in the Puget Sound area, two of which were in Seattle. One was confirmed as arson and the other two are still under investigation, but arson is suspected. No other U.S. city has had more than one.

Seattle’s experiment with the so-called Capitol Hill Occupied Protest (CHOP) has led to a class-action lawsuit alleging that when the city surrendered a multiple-block area to protesters, it effectively denied businesses, residents and patrons public access to their private properties. The plaintiffs are seeking damages. The first couple of legal decisions have gone their way, so this might prove to be a very expensive hit to taxpayers. The summer’s events also have fed insurers’ concerns about risk in certain Seattle neighborhoods where unrest and vandalism have persisted.

If it continues, there is a real risk that insurers might make their policies too expensive for businesses and real estate owners in hard-hit neighborhoods. An insidious decline begins when enterprises start to pull out. The downward spiral can be very hard to reverse as storefronts remain vacant and crime settles in.

Neighboring communities are watching closely, including those in Snohomish County. It’s a contrast of approaches in many ways. While the Seattle City Council was voting to defund their police, Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin was lobbying her city council to add officers to the police force through a federal grant. After an initial no vote, Everett’s council changed course and the grant was approved.

The Seattle situation was entirely avoidable, and groups at the neighborhood level are waking up and taking action.

Solutions can include forming volunteer watch groups, sharing with neighbors the expense for private security, creating new business associations and forming new taxing authorities or business improvement districts to counter police budget cuts.

The Downtown Seattle Association is a good example of a group taking quick action in the face of these new realities. The organization is becoming politically active and forthright about the issues constituents are facing. Partnering with the tourism and convention industry — they face a major brand problem about the safety of the city — is one of the many strategies.

Neighborhoods or cities without an apparatus already in place may need to form one soon or risk losing out.

Canaries are uniquely susceptible to carbon monoxide gas, so miners brought them into the mines and watched them for early signs of trouble. If a canary died, miners knew the air was getting bad and they were next.

Insurers in Seattle are the canary. The bird is still alive, but it’s listless and lethargic. Neighborhoods that recognize the problem early have some time to course-correct.

Occasional contributor Tom Hoban is chairman and co-founder of Hoban Family Office, a real estate investment and services enterprise in Everett.

Talk to us

More in Herald Business Journal

MyMyToyStore.com owner Tom Harrison at his brick and mortar storefront on Tuesday, Sept. 6, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Near-death experience planted seeds for downtown Everett toy store

Former attorney Tom Harrison survived 9/11. It caused him to ask what’s important in life. Today, he runs MyMyToyStore.

Sean Jones, membership executive of Everett's Freedom Boat Club, helps club member Carolyn Duncan load equipment onto her boat before she and a friend head out crabbing onThursday, Aug. 11, 2022, at the Port of Everett in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
New Everett franchise offers boats at Everett Marina

Freedom Boat Club’s newest Washington location is in Everett, with six boats available to its members.

Devin Ryan, left to right, talks with Donald Whitley and Drew Yager before a test ride at Bicycle Centres Wednesday in Everett, Washington on August 24, 2022.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
New hands take the handlebars for Bicycle Centres

Longtime employees Devin Ryan, Aron Chaudiere and Ryan Brown bought the business that’s been around since 1976.

A truck drives past a sign displaying fuel prices on Friday, Sept. 2, 2022 in Arlington, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Diesel prices stay high for truckers, farmers

Gas prices have fallen steadily this summer, but diesel costs have started to climb again.

FILE - Test engineer Jacob Wilcox pulls his arm out of a glove box used for processing sodium at TerraPower, a company developing and building small nuclear reactors, Jan. 13, 2022, in Everett, Wash. A major economic bill headed to the president has “game-changing” incentives for the nuclear energy industry, experts say, and those tax credits are even more substantial if a facility is sited in a community where a coal plant is closing. Bill Gates' company, TerraPower, plans to build an advanced, nontraditional nuclear reactor and employ workers from a local coal-fired power plant scheduled to close soon. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Everett nuclear research facility gets $750 million infusion

Bellevue’s TerraPower, which operates an Everett facility, got a hefty investment to fund research.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Business briefs: Leadership Snohomish County names new executive director

Plus a new short-term, career programs at Edmonds College, state grants for small businesses and more.

Tim Leonard, owner of the Machine Shop, is closing the arcade this fall. (Photo by David Welton)
Arcade owner to pull plug on beloved Whidbey Island business

Tim Leonard, owner of the Machine Shop in Langley, recently decided he’ll call it quits this fall.

Jennifer Sadinsky is the owner of Grayhorse Mercantile, one of Langley’s newest stores. (David Welton)
Shopkeeper brings taste of Europe to Whidbey Island

A first-time business owner’s dream of opening a cheese shop became a reality this year.

Eviation's all-electric plane in flight Tuesday morning in Moses Lake, Washington, on Sept. 27, 2022. (Eviation)
Arlington’s all-electric plane, Alice, takes first test flight

Eviation Aircraft’s battery-powered plane logs successful first flight from Grant County International Airport in Moses Lake.

At two stores – in Edmonds and Renton – Wide Shoes Only store owner Dominic Ahn offers more than 600 styles of shoes for people with wide feet. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
These Edmonds and Renton shoe stores could change your life

Wide Shoes Only: Huge selection, expert fitting and superior customer service

Amber Weaver, who has worked at the Lakewood Crossing Starbucks for 5 years, with her daughter Melody, outside of her workplace on Thursday, Sept. 22, 2022 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Complaint accuses Starbucks of anti-union threats in Marysville

Meanwhile, a mother of two said Thursday that Starbucks refused to accommodate her schedule when she returned from maternity leave.

Snoop Dogg in a video announces the opening of 'Tha Dogg House' in January 2023. (Screenshot).
Dogg toyz: Funko, rapper Snoop Dogg greenlight new retail venture

“Tha Dogg House” opening next year in Inglewood, California, will be Funko’s third U.S. retail store.