Haley Lu Richardson and Cole Sprouse can’t get too close in “Five Feet Apart.” (CBS Films)

Haley Lu Richardson and Cole Sprouse can’t get too close in “Five Feet Apart.” (CBS Films)

Teens with cystic fibrosis find love — at a distance

‘Five Feet Apart’ starts strong, but goes off the rails with melodrama and dumb plotting.

It isn’t actually adapted from a Young Adult novel, but “Five Feet Apart” definitely has the mood of the more serious offerings from that literary shelf.

And like “The Fault in Our Stars,” this film deals with teenagers who are sick. So sick that 95 percent of the story takes place inside a hospital.

For most of the film, this limitation is no problem; what we see is funny and well-acted. Then — well, we’ll get to that.

In the opening scene we meet Stella (Haley Lu Richardson), who’s back in the hospital for her umpteenth visit. She lives with cystic fibrosis, the illness that produces an overabundance of mucus in the body.

Occupying the room next door is her childhood pal Poe (funny Moises Arias, from “The Kings of Summer”). As fellow “C-effers,” they know the ups and downs of the condition.

The new kid in the hospital block is Will (Cole Sprouse, who plays Jughead on “Riverdale”). He’s skeptical about his new treatment, and likes to talk about the inevitability of death.

Will is tall, handsome and brooding; Stella is short, pretty and upbeat. How long will it take for these two to put aside their differences and get together?

But the almost surreally sad reality, as the script by Mikki Daughtry and Tobias Iaconis goes to great lengths to explain, is that people with CF (at least these two people) dare not get into close proximity. If they touch, they might exchange the wrong kind of bacteria and become mortally sick.

This means Stella and Will can’t hold hands, let alone kiss. Director Justin Baldoni makes good use of the widescreen frame, keeping these two on separate sides of the screen, so we never forget the physical gulf between them.

It’s a poignant situation, and the film’s rough-edged, unsentimental attitude prevents the material from getting cloying or clinical — the kids have been sick so long they’ve developed shared jokes to keep pity at bay. The hospital wing becomes a world unto itself, where the young patients create their own special community.

Haley Lu Richardson, from “Edge of Seventeen” and “Support the Girls,” gives a rich performance — she creates an authentic, deglamorized human being. But not a saint: Stella has her own pushy personality, which includes her need to control everybody else’s treatment.

Having built this scenario, “Five Feet Apart” goes seriously wrong in its final act, ginning up melodrama and having the characters do dumb things to further the plot. It’s a shame — the very specific characters we’ve come to know deserve better.

Talk to us

More in Life

CloZee performs during the second day of Summer Meltdown on Saturday, Aug. 3, 2019 in Darrington, Wash. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
The psychedelic fest Summer Meltdown is back — and in Monroe

The music and camping event is on for July 28-31, with a new venue along the Skykomish River.

Gardening at spring. Planting tree in garden. Senior man watering planted fruit tree at his backyard
Bare root trees and roses have arrived for spring planting

They’re only available from January through March, so shop early for the tree or rose you want.

Veteran Keith F. Reyes, 64, gets his monthly pedicure at Nail Flare on Tuesday, Dec. 21, 2021 in Stanwood, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
No more gnarly feet: This ‘Wounded Warrior’ gets pedicures

Keith Reyes, 64, visits a Stanwood nail salon for “foot treatments” that help soothe blast injuries.

Photo Caption: A coal scuttle wasn't always used for coal; it could hold logs or collect ashes. This one from about 1900 sold for $125 at DuMouchelles in Detroit.
(c) 2022 by Cowles Syndicate Inc.
Coal scuttles of days long gone by now used for fire logs

This circa 1900 coal scuttle is made of oak with brass trim, and sold for $125 at auction.

Enumclaw, the band
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Most of these venues require proof of vaccination against COVID-19 or negative… Continue reading

Does this ring a “Belle”? Storied anime writer-director Mamoru Hosoda’s newest resets “Beauty and the Beast” in a musical, virtual environment — among other modern twists. (GKIDS/TNS)
‘Belle’ is striking virtual reality riff on ‘Beauty and the Beast’

In it, ‘Beauty’ is the charismatic online avatar of a moody teenager that attracts the attention of a bruised and brooding Beast

"Redeeming Love"
Movie review: ‘Redeeming Love’ doesn’t yield cinematic riches

The story, about a sex worker “redeemed” by a folksy farmer in Gold Rush-era California, is creepy “tradwife” fan fiction.

Eggs Florentine
Baked Eggs Florentine: A brunch favorite inspired by a queen

The kitchen manager at Quil Ceda Creek Casino shares a dish that pays homage to a spinach-crazy 16th century monarch.

This easy-to-make spinach and mushroom quiche is perfect for a light dinner or fancy brunch. (Gretchen McKay/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette/TNS)
Gretchen’s table: A spinach-mushroom quiche with cheesy goodness

The savory egg custard baked in a pie crust is easy to make — especially if you use a refrigerated crust.

Most Read