Taraji P. Henson plays a sports agent who gains the ability to hear men’s thoughts in the comedy “What Men Want.” (Paramount Pictures)

Taraji P. Henson plays a sports agent who gains the ability to hear men’s thoughts in the comedy “What Men Want.” (Paramount Pictures)

‘What Men Want’: Good moments lost in the noise

An overabundance of plot strands mutes the funny bits — which include a fun performance by The Boz.

If you stick around long enough, you find yourself crafting sentences you never dreamed you’d write.

Here’s one: “Brian Bosworth gives a fine performance.”

It’s true: the onetime flamboyant Seahawks washout is quite good in “What Men Want,” playing the boss of a sports agency. The Boz has maintained a fitful career in B-movie action fare, but in his first really legit role he’s convincing and actually kind of fun.

If only “What Men Want” — a gender-reversal of “What Women Want,” the 2000 Mel Gibson hit — had more surprises like this. In this take on the material, type-A sports agent Ali Davis (Taraji P. Henson) suddenly acquires the ability to hear men’s thoughts.

Panic ensues, but Ali realizes that her mind-reading gift might be an advantage in her testosterone-fueled office. She’s regularly passed over for a coveted partnership because she’s a woman; now she’s got an edge.

Her biggest goal is to sign a hotshot prospect (Shane Paul McGhie) about to enter the NBA draft, which means impressing his goofball dad (Tracy Morgan). Meanwhile, Ali meets a kind bartender (Aldis Hodge) and exploits him to her professional advantage.

Will Ali learn valuable life lessons from her supernatural experience? I think you know the answer to that.

A more pressing question is whether the film offers enough diversion along the way. Veering from heartwarming sentiment to raunchy sex jokes (who thought an R rating was a good idea here?), “What Men Want” has so many characters and so many plot threads it exhausts itself.

Worse, Henson and director Adam Shankman (“Rock of Ages”) have decided that Ali’s mode should be more Jim Carrey than Mel Gibson. Henson (coming off of hot streak that includes “Hidden Figures” and the TV show “Empire”) is always a capable actress, but she’s so frantic here the film never seems to calm down.

Along with the Boz (and a parade of real-life sports stars playing themselves), there are some bright supporting turns. Erykah Badu gets some fun witchiness going as the fortune teller who causes Ali’s problems, Richard Roundtree (yes, the original “Shaft”) is likable as Ali’s boxer father, and Josh Brener nails the stock role of Ali’s gay assistant.

Of course, any time you have Tracy Morgan wandering around spouting non sequiturs, there’s usually a few laughs to be had. Does anybody actually write dialogue for him, or does he just show up and free-associate?

The good moments in “What Men Want” tend to be lost in the noise. This kind of comedy should look effortless, but everybody here is working very, very hard.

“What Men Want” (2½ stars)

A gender-reversal of the Mel Gibson hit “What Men Want,” this one casts Taraji P. Henson as a sports agent who can suddenly read men’s minds. Some funny moments along the way, but there are so many plot strands going on that the movie exhausts itself, and the usually reliable Henson goes way over the top. With Tracy Morgan.

Rating: R, for language, subject matter

Showing: Alderwood, Alderwood Mall, Cinebarre Mountlake Terrace, Everett Stadium, Galaxy Monroe, Marysville, Meridian, Pacific Place, Seattle 10, Thornton Place, Woodinville, Cascade Mall

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

Are you an overthinker?

Every day, families make difficult decisions, often without expert guidance. This spring,… Continue reading

2025 Toyota Camry midsize sedan. The XSE AWD model is shown here (Photo provided by Toyota).
2025 Toyota Camry is all new, all hybrid

Ninth-generation version of the long-lived sedan offers AWD on all models

X2 xDrive 28i photo provided by BMW Media
BMW Pushes Envelope With Second-Generation, 2024 X2

Premium, Compact, Sports Activity Coupe Designed With Younger Buyers In Mind

2025 MINI Cooper S photo provided by MINI USA
New MINI Cooper S delivers old-fashioned simplicity and fun

Sub-compact, hatchback is a driver’s car pure and simple

2024 Hyundai Sonata midsize sedan. The N Line model is shown here (Provided by Hyundai).
2024 Hyundai Sonata’s five models target all types of drivers

Value-conscious, sport-driven, AWD fan or hybrid enthusiast. There’s a Sonata for that.

2025 Lucid Air Pure (Photo provided by Lucid)
2025 Lucid Air Pure Performance

Electric vehicles are the future, and they’re not exclusive to the Big… Continue reading

The 2024 Land Rover Defender luxury SUV. (Photo provided by Land Rover)
2024 Land Rover Defender excels off road and on the street

This luxury SUV is like having two vehicles in one.

2024 Genesis GV60 AWD Performance
2024 Genesis GV60 AWD Performance

It’s happening folks. Whether we like it or not. The inexorable march… Continue reading

The 2024 BMW i4 is a five-passenger luxury electric sedan with a rear liftgate. The eDrive40 model is shown here.
Photo Credit: Provided by BMW
2024 BMW i4 luxury sedan has plenty of all-electric power

For the top-tier model, thrust is off the charts.

Small is big.

Holidays inspire big expressions of love: birthdays, Christmas, Chanukah, Valentine’s Day, and… Continue reading

Hyundai Kona Limited Electric (Photo provided by Hyundai)
2024 Hyundai Kona Limited Electric Review

The small SUV segment is an extremely popular market niche, and among… Continue reading

A photo illustration of iconic Herald reporter Andrea Brown's "What's Up With That?" junk drawer. (Kate Erickson & Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Columnist Andrea Brown says goodbye after 12 years: What’s up with that?

For the past decade, she’s dug up Snohomish County’s weirdest, most fanciful characters. And more than a few Bigfoots.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.