Election won’t matter to economy

WASHINGTON – Despite the stark differences in economic plans from President Bush and Sen. John Kerry, growth and job creation should turn out pretty much the same no matter who takes the White House.

Private economists also say the federal budget deficit, mentioned infrequently during the campaign, will bedevil the winner of the Nov. 2 election.

Experts who have analyzed the spending and tax proposals of both candidates say the plans, if enacted by Congress, would have a similar effect on growth, but the gains would come in different ways.

“If both candidates were to follow through on everything they have promised, then the economy would be roughly the same four years from now under either plan,” said Mark Zandi, head of Economy.com, a private forecasting company.

Global Insight, an economic consulting firm that has fed the details of the two economic plans into a computer forecasting model, reached the same conclusion.

“The economic impacts of the Bush and Kerry budget plans are so close as to be almost indistinguishable,” said Nariman Behravesh, the firm’s chief economist.

Under the Economy.com analysis, the economy as measured by the gross domestic product will have average growth rates of 3.1 percent over the next 10 years under the Bush plan and 3.2 percent under the Kerry plan.

Global Insight forecasts growth rates of 2.9 percent under both plans.

Zandi projects that Kerry’s plan will create an average of 1.5 million jobs each year over the next decade, compared with 1.3 million for Bush’s.

The Global Insight model puts the figure at 1.4 million, resulting in 146 million jobs by 2014.

All of those forecasts would represent an improvement over the actual experience of the past four years in which the economy, struggling with a recession and then weak job growth, has seen a net job loss of 821,000 since January 2001.

The growth predicted for the plans would come about from different approaches.

Bush’s centerpiece proposal is to make the tax cuts of his first term permanent, at a 10-year cost of nearly $1 trillion. That would increase growth by promoting higher capital spending through a more attractive investment climate.

Kerry’s plan would rely on greater government spending, in part from spending $653 billion to expand health care coverage.

“The Bush plan helps boost the stock market, profits and capital spending while the Kerry plan provides a bigger boost to government spending,” Behravesh said.

The wealthy would not be treated the same under the Bush and Kerry plans.

The Democratic senator from Massachusetts is campaigning on a pledge to roll back the rate cuts for households earning more than $200,000 per year.

Clint Stretch, director of tax policy at Deloitte Tax in Washington, said a family of four earning $40,000 annually, was saving $2,000 under the Bush tax cuts and would continue to see those savings under Kerry’s plan.

Stretch estimated that a family with earnings of $575,000 annually is now saving $19,300 under Bush’s tax cuts, but would lose about 70 percent of that relief and see its tax bill increase by $13,700 under Kerry’s plan.

Private economists see both candidates failing to control the federal deficit.

The Republican incumbent and his challenger are campaigning on a pledge to cut the deficit in half by 2009. Analysts, however, do not see either man coming close to achieving that pledge.

The deficit set a record in dollar terms of $413 billion in the just completed 2004 budget year.

Global Insight forecasts that the deficit would climb to $451 billion in 2009 under Kerry’s programs, while dipping only slightly to $384 billion under Bush.

Looking out five more years, the deficit figures grow even more ominous as the retirement of the baby boomers starts to put severe strains on Social Security and Medicare.

Global Insight projects a 2014 deficit of $633 billion under Kerry’s programs and $570 billion under Bush.

Economic plans

Important elements of the economic plans of President Bush and Democrat John Kerry. All figures are totals for the 10 years ending in 2014 unless otherwise indicated.

KERRY

Initiatives

* Expand health care coverage, $653 billion.

* Education, $207 billion.

* 5 percent corporate tax cut, $120 billion.

* Veterans and military families, $55 billion.

* Temporary jobs stimulus, $47 billion.

* Energy and environment, $35 billion.

Savings

* Repeal Bush tax cuts on people earning more than $200,000 annually, $860 billion.

* Create a commission to recommend ways to reduce federal payments to corporations and enact those proposals, $300 billion.

* Better disease management by companies and other health savings, $300 billion.

* Close loopholes on taxes owed by companies overseas, $120 billion.

* Cut 100,000 federal contractors, $50 billion.

* Cut federal electric bill by 20 percent, $14 billion.

BUSH

Initiatives

* Extend tax cuts enacted in 2001 and 2003, which otherwise expire by 2010, $979 billion.

* Tax cuts and spending increases for health care, economic development, education and jobs, $74 billion.

* Other tax cuts for education, charitable giving, other items, $199 billion.

* Other initiatives for which White House has provided only five-year numbers: Defense and domestic security, $185 billion.

Savings, cost over five years:

* All other domestic programs, excluding automatic benefits such as Social Security, $115 billion.

* Medicaid and other benefit programs, $33 billion.

Associated Press

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

LifeWise local co-directors Darcie Hammer and Sarah Sweeny talk about what a typical classroom routine looks like on Monday, April 14, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett off-campus Bible program draws mixed reaction from parents

The weekly optional program, LifeWise Academy, takes children out of public school during the day for religious lessons.

Protesters line Broadway in Everett for Main Street USA rally

Thousands turn out to protest President Trump on Saturday in Everett, joining hundreds of other towns and cities.

An EcoRemedy employee checks a control panel of their equipment at the Edmonds Wastewater Treatment Plant on Thursday, April 17, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Edmonds launches technology to destroy PFAS

Edmonds is the first city in the country to implement… Continue reading

Over a dozen parents and some Snohomish School District students gather outside of the district office to protest and discuss safety concerns after an incident with a student at Machias Elementary School on Friday, April 18, 2025 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Parents protest handling of alleged weapon incident at Machias Elementary

Families say district failed to communicate clearly; some have kept kids home for weeks.

Irene Pfister, left, holds a sign reading “Justice for Jonathan” next to another protester with a sign that says “Major Crimes Needs to Investigate,” during a call to action Saturday, April 12, 2025, in Arlington. (Aspen Anderson / The Herald)
Arlington community rallies, a family waits for news on missing man

Family and neighbors say more can be done in the search for Jonathan Hoang. The sheriff’s office says all leads are being pursued.

Mary Ann Karber, 101, spins the wheel during Wheel of Forunte at Washington Oakes on Tuesday, April 1, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lunch and Wheel of Fortune with some Everett swinging seniors

She’s 101 and he’s 76. At Washington Oakes, fun and friendship are on the menu.

Connect Casino Road Director Alvaro Gullien speaks at an Everett City Council meeting to share community thoughts regarding affordable housing and preventing displacement of those that live along Casino Road on Wednesday, April 16, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
How will Everett’s comprehensive plan work in Casino Road?

Residents in the diverse, tight-knit neighborhood want “Investment without displacement.” The city’s plan will help achieve that, staff say.

Henry M. Jackson High School’s FIRST Robotics Competition championship robotics Team 2910 Jack in the Bot on Thursday, April 24, 2025 in Mill Creek, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Mill Creek robotics team celebrates world championship win

The team — known as “Jack in the Bot” — came in first place above about 600 others at a Texas world championship event last week.

Trees and foliage grow at the Rockport State Park on Wednesday, April 3, 2024 in Rockport, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Washington Legislature approves hiking Discover Pass price to $45

The price for a Washington state Discover Pass would rise by $15… Continue reading

The Washington state Capitol on April 18, 2025. (Photo by Jacquelyn Jimenez Romero/Washington State Standard)
Parental rights overhaul gains final approval in WA Legislature

The bill was among the most controversial of this year’s session.

Snohomish firefighters appeal vaccine suspensions to Ninth Circuit

Despite lower court’s decision, eight men maintain their department did not properly accommodate their religious beliefs during COVID.

A rental sign seen in Everett. Saturday, May 23, 2020 (Sue Misao / Herald file)
Compromise reached on Washington bill to cap rent increases

Under a version released Thursday, rent hikes would be limited to 7% plus inflation, or 10%, whichever is lower.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.