John Reed takes the stand on Friday in Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett. (Caleb Hutton / Herald file)

John Reed takes the stand on Friday in Snohomish County Superior Court in Everett. (Caleb Hutton / Herald file)

Jurors begin deliberations in John Reed murder trial

They are considering first-degree murder charges in the deaths of Monique Patenaude and Patrick Shunn.

EVERETT — John Reed had a choice, according to prosecutors.

Monique Patenaude was shot in the arm. She was unlikely to fight back. Reed could have stopped there.

If so, he would have been charged with assault instead of aggravated murder, deputy prosecutor Andrew Alsdorf said Tuesday in closing arguments in Snohomish County Superior Court.

“He was committed between shot No. 1 and shot No. 2 that killed Monique,” Alsdorf said.

“Monique did not have to die.”

Prosecutors allege Reed acted with premeditation in the shootings of Patenaude, 46, and her husband, Patrick Shunn, 45. They say Shunn was executed hours after his wife, as he returned home from work on April 11, 2016.

Reed has admitted to killing the couple, saying they attacked him and he defended himself. The trio had a long-standing feud over property lines and driveway access.

In a full day of testimony Friday, Reed told jurors he “panicked” after the confrontation and hid the bodies, vehicles and cellphones in the woods.

“What you saw on Friday was a cynical and calculated effort to make up a story … ” said Craig Matheson, the county’s chief criminal deputy prosecutor. “Like most lies, you go a layer or two deep and the facts just don’t support it.”

Autopsy results counter Reed’s claim that Patenaude was intoxicated, Matheson said.

Reed’s defense attorney, Phil Sayles, said the alleged coverup would have been “the worst plan ever.” Reed said much of the evidence against him — such as leaving behind black gloves with DNA inside and shooting up the couple’s laptop that was linked to a trail camera — was the result of him not knowing what he was doing.

Sayles accused prosecutors of overloading jurors with details about the couple’s pets and the plastic sheeting from the crime scenes, while adding “bombastic inferences.” His client admitted to a lot of “stupid decisions,” but not to murder, he said.

“My guy sits here an innocent man. … Did they establish anything to make him a guilty man?” he asked. “I propose there’s nothing here.”

Alsdorf argued that people don’t cover up self-defense.

Patenaude and Shunn repeatedly had reported concerns about Reed to the authorities, including police, since at least 2013. Never had they been violent toward him, Alsdorf said.

When Reed and Patenaude last crossed paths, he was supposed to be moving away from Oso. He could have left the dispute — and the neighbors — behind, Alsdorf said. Instead, Patenaude was shot, setting off the chain of events that led Reed to leave the country.

“Since John Reed fled to Mexico, he’s been thinking of this day. What would he say on Friday?” Alsdorf said. “He knew what he was doing when he took that life.”

Jurors began deliberations Tuesday afternoon. Reed, 55, faces life in prison if convicted.

Rikki King: 425-339-3449; rking@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @rikkiking.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Local COVID-19 cases might have peaked, health official says

“There is light at the end of the tunnel,” said Dr. Chris Spitters of the Snohomish Health District.

Community Transit cuts routes further as ridership plummets

Some routes had zero passengers for days, and a dozen employees have tested positive for COVID-19.

Habib backs Liias to succeed him as lieutenant governor

The state senator picks up key endorsement as Congressman Heck considers entering the race

1.2 million students won’t return to classrooms anytime soon

The governor has extended a statewide closure through June 19 in response to the COVID-19 pandemic.

COVID-19 claims Kona Kitchen’s matriarch and her husband

Liz Mar was beloved for her hospitality and graciousness at the Hawaiian restaurant in Lynnwood.

COVID-19 and cloth face covers

Public Health Essentials! A blog by the Snohomish Health District.

Lynnwood settles with man who was jailed over stolen coffee

The city paid $20,000 to the legally deaf man, who claimed he was wrongfully imprisoned and beaten.

Stave off stay-at-home boredom and go for a drive

With the roads so empty and few entertainment options outside the house, it’s time for a joyride.

2 Everett postal workers have tested positive for COVID-19

There’s no evidence the virus can spread through the mail. But delivery services are taking precautions.

Most Read