Sparks fly at I-976 debate: Eyman vs. a mayor and a senator

Dishonesty was a prevalent theme at a Herald forum on the car-tabs ballot measure.

EVERETT — In a sometimes-heated debate Thursday night, anti-tax activist Tim Eyman squared off with Everett’s mayor and a state senator over Initiative 976, which would reduce car tab fees to $30 for most vehicles.

The measure on the Nov. 5 ballot would lower the annual vehicle registration fee while stripping the state, cities and transit agencies of a key source of funding.

Initiative sponsor Eyman faced Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin and state Sen. Steve Hobbs, D-Lake Stevens, at a forum moderated by Daily Herald opinion editor Jon Bauer and political reporter Jerry Cornfield. About 100 people attended the event at Washington State University’s North Puget Sound campus in Everett, and the event was broadcast live by TVW.

Honesty was a prevalent theme for both sides as they sparred over Sound Transit and state transportation funding.

“Taxing a $10,000 vehicle as if it’s worth $25,000 is dishonest,” Eyman said, referring to vehicle valuation formulas that drive some car-tab fees. “Our initiative actually gives voters a chance to get rid of this dishonest tax.”

Franklin and Hobbs returned time and again to the argument that voters have already spoken by approving the Sound Transit 3 mass-transit package in 2016.

“Seven hundred thousand people decided in 2016 to invest in transportation infrastructure,” Hobbs said. “It was decided by the voters.”

A near tripling of the vehicle excise tax rate approved in 2016 to fund light rail expansion more commonly known as ST3 was the catalyst for this year’s ballot fight. Initiative backers think the transit agency should switch to a depreciation schedule that more accurately calibrates a vehicle’s worth.

If I-976 passes, there would be impacts beyond Sound Transit. It would eliminate $58.2 million in transportation benefit district license fees from local budgets across the state. Many Snohomish County cities rely on for a large chuck of money to maintain roads.

Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin (center) and Steve Hobbs (right), the Democratic chairman of the state Senate Transportation Committee, listen as initiative sponsor Tim Eyman makes the case in favor of I-976 at a Herald forum Thursday night at Washington State University’s North Puget Sound campus in Everett. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)

Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin (center) and Steve Hobbs (right), the Democratic chairman of the state Senate Transportation Committee, listen as initiative sponsor Tim Eyman makes the case in favor of I-976 at a Herald forum Thursday night at Washington State University’s North Puget Sound campus in Everett. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)

Hobbs, who is chairman of the Senate Transportation Committee, said the potential loss of revenue keeps him up at night. He acknowledged he has not developed a plan for how to proceed should I-976 pass. To start, he said, the fair thing to do would probably be to look at cuts across the board.

Having to reevaluate state transportation spending might not be a bad thing, Eyman said. “Every single program that is currently funded by this dishonest tax is going to have to justify their very existence, their effectiveness. This is essentially a performance audit.”

In Everett, the city could lose out on $1.5 million, which makes up about half of the pavement maintenance budget, a loss Franklin said would be “devastating.” With the city facing up to a $20 million budget deficit, that gap would remain unfilled, Franklin said.

“If we can’t invest in maintenance, the roads will deteriorate — it will lead to potholes and a much more expensive rebuild of that road,” Franklin said. “This initiative takes away our opportunity to use local transportation dollars to solve local transportation problems.”

Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin (left) speaks in opposition to Initiative 976 at a Herald forum regarding the ballot measure at Washington State University’s North Puget Sound campus Thursday in Everett. Steve Hobbs (center), the Democratic chairman of the state Senate Transportation Committee, and initiative proponent Tim Eyman listen. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)

Everett Mayor Cassie Franklin (left) speaks in opposition to Initiative 976 at a Herald forum regarding the ballot measure at Washington State University’s North Puget Sound campus Thursday in Everett. Steve Hobbs (center), the Democratic chairman of the state Senate Transportation Committee, and initiative proponent Tim Eyman listen. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)

The cost to Everett wouldn’t end with maintenance. I-976 would affect the Everett Transit budget and put light rail, set to arrive in 2036, in jeopardy, Franklin said.

A fiscal analysis prepared by the state Office of Financial Management predicts the initiative would drain $475 million from transportation and transit accounts in the next two-year budget.

“Projects will not go forward, some bridges will not be maintained, transit will be cut and these are huge problems across the state,” said Hobbs.

Eyman argued the state could use a current budget surplus to pay for transportation projects, which Hobbs disputed.

The only agreement of the night was the need to revamp the vehicle valuation system used by Sound Transit to determine license renewal fees.

“It needs to be fixed, but you can’t gut our transportation system in the meantime,” Franklin said.

This isn’t the first time voters have had the chance to reduce car tab fees. Similar measures passed in 1999 and 2002. And I-976 wouldn’t preclude the cost of car tabs rising again. Any new fees — from the state, a local government or Sound Transit — would require approval by voters.

Lizz Giordano: 425-374-4165; egiordano@heraldnet.com; Twitter: @lizzgior.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Employees and patrons of the Everett Mall signed a timeline mural that traces the history of the 51-year-old indoor mall that was once considered the premier place to go shopping in the city. Thursday, March 20, 2025 (Aaron Kennedy / The Herald)
Mall mural offers nostalgic trip into the past

Past and present Everett Mall employees joined customers Thursday to view an artistic timeline of the once popular shopping mecca.

Edmonds Mayor Mike Rosen gives his State of the City address on Thursday, March 20 in Edmonds, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Edmonds mayor talks budget at 2025 State of the City

Mayor Mike Rosen discussed the city’s deficit and highlights from his first year in office.

Public’s help needed to find missing Arlington man

The 21-year-old left the house Sunday night without his shoes, cell phone or a jacket, and was reported missing the following morning.

The Marysville Tulalip Campus on the Tulalip Reservation, where Legacy High School is located. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Marysville board votes to keep Legacy High at current location

The move rolls back a decision the school board made in January to move the alternative high school at the start of next school year.

The former Marysville City Hall building along State Avenue on Tuesday, April 30, 2024 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
City of Marysville, school board amend property exchange

The city will relocate its public works facility to the district’s current headquarters, which will move to the former City Hall.

Snohomish County Elections employees Alice Salcido, left and Joseph Rzeckowski, right, pull full bins of ballots from the Snohomish County Campus ballot drop box on Monday, Nov. 4, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
County to mail ballots for Edmonds, Brier elections

Registered voters should receive their ballots by April 9 for the April 22 special election.

A stormwater diversion structure which has been given a notice for repairs along a section of the Perrinville Creek north of Stamm Overlook Park that flows into Browns Bay in Edmonds, Washington on Thursday, July 18, 2024. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Edmonds Hearing Examiner decides on Perrinville Creek saga

The examiner revoked the city’s Determination of Non-Significance, forcing Edmonds to address infrastructure issues on the creek

Don Sharrett talks John Wrice through his trimming technique on Friday, March 14, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett barber school offers $5 haircuts — if you’re brave enough

Students get hands-on practice. Willing clients get a sweet deal.

Our Lady of Hope Fr. Joseph Altenhofen outside of his parish’s building that will be the new home of Hope ‘N Wellness on Wednesday, March 5, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
New Hope ‘N Wellness location to open Wednesday in Everett

Our Lady of Hope Church will host the social service organization at 2617 Cedar St. in Everett.

Amtrak Cascades train 517 to Portland departs from Everett Station on Saturday, Sep. 2, 2023, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Limited train service to resume on Amtrak Cascades

Trains will have less capacity for now, but service is expected to resume for some routes as early as Tuesday.

Marysville
Police: 66-year-old Marysville man dead from fatal stabbing

A neighbor found the man unconscious on the sidewalk as the result of an apparent stabbing. Police said they are looking for suspects.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Driver, suspected of DUI, hits WSP vehicle on I-5 near Everett

The trooper was blocking the HOV lane for a previous collision when his vehicle was struck Saturday morning.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.