What next for John Walker?

By Richard T. Cooper

The Los Angeles Times

WASHINGTON — Three months ago, as Americans plunged into the war on terrorism, this was not the face they expected to see when the smoke cleared — a gaunt, 20-year-old California kid with the defiant manners of a teen and two frightened parents struggling in his wake.

John Walker Lindh, who turned up unexpectedly among the Taliban fighters who survived a bloody prison revolt near Mazar-e-Sharif, immediately became the subject of vigorous debate across the United States: Who is he? What should be done with him?

Is he a prisoner of war, protected by the Geneva Convention? Is he a traitor, fit to be tried and even executed? A terrorist who should go before a military tribunal? Or just a latter-day Patty Hearst?

And beyond statutes and legal precedents, Walker’s case seemed to raise larger questions as well: How does the country feel about a young man who ended up in a terrible place, but got there by a path that is all too familiar to millions of American parents?

Walker’s progress from a teen-age obsession with Islam to a battered Afghan fortress may be unique in its details. Yet for many, there was something hauntingly familiar about a middle-class youth engaged in a personal pilgrimage that carried him onto dangerous ground, deaf to all entreaties by family or friends.

Even President Bush, who has been relentless in denouncing the Taliban and its al-Qaida allies, reacted in personal, not legal terms when asked about the Walker case.

"We’re just trying to learn the facts about this poor fellow," he told ABC News. "Obviously he has — uh, been misled, it appears to me. …

"He thought he was going to fight for a great cause and in fact he was going to support a government that was one of the most repressive governments in the history of mankind. … Surely he was raised better."

U.S. officials, still trying to pull together the facts about Walker, walked on tiptoes in describing his status. They said only that he was being held in Afghanistan and would be accorded all appropriate legal rights.

Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld said it remained unclear how the Pentagon would deal with Walker. As Bush’s decree authorizing military tribunals now stands, he said, it appears that no U.S. citizen, even one fighting side by side with the Taliban, can be tried in such a proceeding.

Although he declined to call Walker a "traitor," the secretary pointedly left open the possibility that he would be prosecuted.

"We found a person who says he’s an American, with an AK-47, in a prison with a bunch of al-Qaida and Taliban fighters," Rumsfeld said. "And you can be certain he will have all the rights he is due. We are looking at the various options at the present time."

Jim Brosnahan, a prominent San Francisco trial lawyer, said he would represent Walker. Rumsfeld said Pentagon officials had not spoken to the attorney.

Privately, some Pentagon officials speculated that Walker could be tried as an accessory to the murder of a CIA officer who was killed during the prison uprising in which several U.S. Special Forces troops were injured and hundreds of Taliban fighters were killed.

In matters of policy as well as law, experts disagreed on what could or should be done. Some took a hard line, while others saw a murkier situation.

Dwight H. Sullivan, a former Marine Corps lawyer who is now managing attorney for the American Civil Liberties Union in Baltimore, said, "It’s not clear to me that he has violated any criminal law. It is certainly not treason, which has a very precise definition.

"If he committed a war crime of some type, then he certainly could be tried in federal court. But the question is, what are they going to charge him with?"

And veteran Washington defense attorney Plato Cacheris said, "I don’t know what they might charge him with. Nothing jumps out at me. It’s certainly not treason because legally we’re not at war, even though we’re involved in hostilities. The Patty Hearst defense? Well, he wasn’t kidnapped. Was he brainwashed? We just don’t know yet."

Tom Palmer, a senior fellow with the Cato Institute in Washington, saw the issues differently.

"People say this young man is just a boy of 20," Palmer said. "Well, my father was 17 when he went off to fight the Nazis in World War II. I think if you go off to fight with a regime that espouses terrorism, like this young man did, you ought to face the full consequences. Otherwise we’re sending the wrong message to our youth."

William Webster, a former federal judge who headed the FBI and the CIA, said, "I’m sure they can think of 17 different things to charge him with."

Federal law forbids anyone owing allegiance to the United States, which includes all who hold U.S. citizenship, from levying war against the country or giving aid and comfort to its enemies, he noted.

"Given the fact that we have treated the Taliban as our enemy, this is a hard one to pass by," said Philip B. Heyman, a former Watergate prosecutor and deputy attorney general now on the Harvard Law school faculty. "I would try very hard to find some way to prosecute."

At the same time, he said, "A lot of parents have had kids go into extreme religious groups of one sort or another. I wouldn’t excuse the kid for that reason. On the other hand, I wouldn’t treat him as the world’s worst criminal."

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

A Cessna 150 crashed north of Paine Field on Friday evening, Feb. 16, 2024, in Mukilteo, Washington. The pilot survived without serious injury. (Courtesy of Richard Newman.)
‘I’m stuck in the trees’: 911 call recounts plane crash near Paine Field

Asad Ali was coming in for a landing in a Cessna 150 when he crashed into woods south of Mukilteo. Then he called 911 — for 48 minutes.

Snohomish County likely to feel more like winter, beginning Monday

Get ready for a mix of rain and snow this week, along with cooler temperatures.

Anthony Boggess
Arlington man sentenced for killing roommate who offered shelter

Anthony Boggess, 33, reported hearing the voices of “demons” the night he strangled James Thrower, 65.

Snohomish County pharmacy tech accused of stealing 2,500 opioid pills

Rachel Langdon stole oxycodone while working at a Snohomish County pharmacy, according to state Department of Health allegations.

Sen. John McCoy, D-Tulalip, left, a member of the Tulalip Tribes of Washington, speaks Wednesday, Feb. 22, 2017, as Washington Gov. Jay Inslee, right, looks on at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash. After the speech, Inslee signed a bill sponsored by McCoy that seeks to improve oral health on Indian reservations in Washington state. The measure is the first bill the governor has signed this legislative session and it allows tribes to use federal funding for dental therapists. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Curriculum on state tribes to be renamed after late Tulalip legislator

On Tuesday, John McCoy’s former colleagues in the Senate honored the late lawmaker by passing House Bill 1879.

Man stabbed, killed inside Lynnwood-area condo

Detectives were looking to identify suspects in a killing Monday night at the Brio Condominiums.

Everett Housing Authority is asking for city approval for it’s proposed development of 16 acres of land currently occupied by the vacant Baker Heights public housing development on Tuesday, Oct. 18, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
North Everett housing project plan gets taller with 15-story buildings

The original plans for the Park District called for 12-story apartments. Another public hearing is set for March 5.

Mt. Pilchuck covered in snow is barely visible through the clouds as the sun breaks through illuminating raindrops as they fall off of the Mountain Loop Highway on Wednesday, Feb. 7, 2024 in Granite Falls, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘Active’ weather brings rain, snow, hail, fresh powder to Snohomish County

Up to an inch of snow could accumulate in the lowlands. Three inches of rain could fall in Darrington. And Stevens Pass is “doing quite well.”

Cousins Penny Leslie and Sidney Baker work together on a mural inside a jail cell at the Mukilteo Police Department on Sunday, Feb. 18, 2024, in Mukilteo, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
No more staring at blank canvas in Mukilteo police holding cells

Bright murals now adorn the walls. The artwork is intended to calm and relax detainees.

Joanne Fisher, right, a meat wrapper with the Marysville Albertsons, hands a leaflet to a shopper during an informational campaign on  Wednesday, Nov. 9, 2022. Fisher was one of about a dozen grocery store workers handing out leaflets to shoppers about the proposed merger between Albertsons and Kroger. (Mike Henneke / The Herald)
US sues to block merger of grocery giants Kroger, Albertsons

Grocery workers in Snohomish County and elsewhere have argued the merger would stymie competition and hurt workers.

The Senate Ways and Means Committee during its meeting on Monday, Feb. 26, 2024, where the panel indicated it would not move ahead with legislation to cap residential rent increases at 7%. The move effectively killed the bill for the 2024 legislative session. (Bill Lucia/Washington State Standard)
Plan for 7% statewide cap on rent increases fails in Olympia

State Sen. June Robinson, D-Everett, told reporters the bill did not have enough support to move it forward.

Shoppers cross Alderwood Mall Parkway after leaving the mall and walking through its parking lot on Thursday, Feb. 15, 2024, in Lynnwood, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Lynnwood police seek 3 suspects after pursuit, brief shootout

The driver of a stolen car intentionally hit a teen boy Sunday, officers said. Police pursued the suspects near I-5.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.