Socialism is scary — always has been, always will be

A new essay, “Socialism Is Not a Scary Word,” is long on sarcasm and low on reasoned argument.

David Bentley Hart recently has written an essay entitled “Socialism Is Not a Scary Word.” He is a distinguished scholar, a terrific writer and masterful debater.

The title is correct in the technical sense. The word itself is not scary. However, the reality of socialism and its history is scary enough to bring on nightmares for those still in contact with reality.

The essay uses a traditional debate in the opening phase: demeaning and mocking your opponent and, more generally, those holding views different from yours. Nearly two centuries ago, Sen. Daniel Webster notably used it in his rebuttal of a speech made by Sen. Robert Hayne, a states’ rights advocate.

Unfortunately, the current essay on socialism never really escapes from this initial mode and becomes preoccupied with mocking those who are suspicious that socialism might not work out so well in our country. It mocks conservative Ben Stein for possessing “the effervescent charm of a despondent tree sloth.” It then blames Stein and the “excitable right” for linking socialism to the rise of Hitler and Stalin.

The linkage, though, is not held only by the excitable right. Hitler was the head of the Nazi government, and Nazi is the abbreviation for “Nationalsozialist” – socialism with a “z.” And Stalin was the head of a “Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.” Socialism, because it destroys competition, was essential to their rise to leadership,

Both Hitler and Stalin were dictators, as was Fidel Castro. Why is it a comic level of excitability, then, to see socialism as a chapter in a book that ends in dictatorship, chaos and impoverishment? The late Hugo Chavez, president of Venezuela, saw Fidel Castro as his role model and socialism as his desired economic system. He succeeded in transforming the most successful economy in South America into a poverty-stricken, barely functional system. According to the essay, though, seeing socialism’s role in today’s chaos in Venezuela is somehow “amusing.”

The essay is correct when it calls Venezuela a “military kleptocracy.” Unfettered capitalism combined with a powerful and ambitious military establishment represent a major threat to democracy, capitalism, freedom, and everything we hold as precious in our lives. In 1961, President Dwight D. Eisenhower warned us of the dangers of what he called the “military-industrial complex” in our country for just that reason.

If you can ignore its ladled-on sarcasm the essay is also right when it discusses health care. It is clear that our present system is broken, but it is far from obvious that the solution is socialized medicine. Part of the problem there is where should the limits of socialized medicine be? Should it control medical schools, practitioners’ incomes, techniques and skill levels, or simply pay the bills?

The United States is a very different country from any other, and what works for Europe may not work satisfactorily here. Some of their ideas don’t even work there anymore as their open borders policy gave them a more diverse population to deal with.

Size is also a factor. There is no country in Europe that has an economy anywhere near the size of ours. It doesn’t make socialism impossible here, but it is a hurdle that must be addressed. The U.S. military, for example, has had many experiences of building and training successful elite, small-unit programs that proved to be disappointing when expanded.

Our government has never demonstrated any talent for managing anything. And since all economic programs and systems break down eventually if relentlessly subjected to poor management, ours would be no exception.

Additionally, socialist programs in the U.S. are, as operations of the federal government, subject to Congress’s penchant for meddling. Our legislative body also can be overly responsive to the media-backed whining industry, and this encourages its worst meddling urges.

Our size, population diversity, and management structure are formidable obstacles to an efficient socialized medicine system, but not unsurmountable if addressed honestly and effectively. And, especially when it comes to health care, capitalism without compassion is not a worthy goal.

Ultimately the essay is disappointing because the mocking seems to take over until it resembles the sad one-liners in the last days of the tired format, unfunny celebrity “roasts” that once filled time on TV.

The definitive work on the general subject, and an excellent starting place, remains Joseph A. Schumpeter’s book, “Capitalism, Socialism, and Democracy.” Originally published in 1952, and still in print — which says something by itself — it provides an un-politicized analysis and perspective on how the forces released by those systems interact.

The motto of the Notre Dame Institute for Advanced Study, where Dr. Hart is an affiliated scholar, is “Let us engage in discourse that matters.” Good idea. Let us begin.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Business

Simreet Dhaliwal speaks after winning during the 2024 Snohomish County Emerging Leaders Awards Presentation on Wednesday, April 17, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Simreet Dhaliwal wins The Herald’s 2024 Emerging Leaders Award

Dhaliwal, an economic development and tourism specialist, was one of 12 finalists for the award celebrating young leaders in Snohomish County.

New Jersey company acquires Lynnwood Land Rover dealership

Land Rover Seattle, now Land Rover Lynnwood, has been purchased by Holman, a 100-year-old company.

Szabella Psaztor is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Szabella Pasztor: Change begins at a grassroots level

As development director at Farmer Frog, Pasztor supports social justice, equity and community empowerment.

Simreet Dhaliwal is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Simreet Dhaliwal: A deep-seated commitment to justice

The Snohomish County tourism and economic specialist is determined to steer change and make a meaningful impact.

Nathanael Engen, founder of Black Forest Mushrooms, an Everett gourmet mushroom growing operation is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Nathanael Engen: Growing and sharing gourmet mushrooms

More than just providing nutritious food, the owner of Black Forest Mushrooms aims to uplift and educate the community.

Owner and founder of Moe's Coffee in Arlington Kaitlyn Davis poses for a photo at the Everett Herald on March 22, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Kaitlyn Davis: Bringing economic vitality to Arlington

More than just coffee, Davis has created community gathering spaces where all can feel welcome.

Emerging Leader John Michael Graves. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
John Michael Graves: Champion for diversity and inclusion

Graves leads training sessions on Israel, Jewish history and the Holocaust and identifying antisemitic hate crimes.

Gracelynn Shibayama, the events coordinator at the Edmonds Center for the Arts, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Gracelynn Shibayama: Connecting people through the arts and culture

The Edmonds Center for the Arts coordinator strives to create a more connected and empathetic community.

Eric Jimenez, a supervisor at Cocoon House, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Eric Jimenez: Team player and advocate for youth

As an advocate for the Latino community, sharing and preserving its traditions is central to Jimenez’ identity.

Molbak's Garden + Home in Woodinville, Washington closed on Jan. 28 2024. (Photo courtesy of Molbak's)
Molbak’s, former Woodinville garden store, hopes for a comeback

Molbak’s wants to create a “hub” for retailers and community groups at its former Woodinville store. But first it must raise $2.5 million.

DJ Lockwood, a Unit Director at the Arlington Boys & Girls Club, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
DJ Lockwood: Helping the community care for its kids

As director of the Arlington Boys & Girls Club, Lockwood has extended the club’s programs to more locations and more kids.

Alex Tadio, the admissions director at WSU Everett, is an Emerging Leader. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Alex Tadio: A passion for education and equality

As admissions director at WSU Everett, he hopes to give more local students the chance to attend college.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.