Prevention not always cheapest medicine

The word “prevention” has a nice ring in any health-care discussion. Thus, many politicians argue that programs to stop smoking, improve diets and otherwise promote wholesome living save money in the long run. A healthier population at less cost — sounds like a win-win situation.

Unfortunately, that formulation is a pleasant fantasy.

Medical economists agree that cancer screenings and gym classes can lead to physical well-being and longer lives. But in the interests of honest accounting, they add that prevention does not reduce overall health-care spending. On the contrary.

Let’s put it bluntly: Longer lives cost more money.

Those who make it to 90 thanks to exercise and six daily servings of vegetables are more likely to suffer the expensive ravages of old age. Everyone dies of something. So he who avoids a fatal heart attack at 70 is more at risk of cancer at 80. Those extra 10 years can mean extra CT scans, hip replacements and physical therapy, even for those in relative good health.

Despite this reality, the cost-saving virtues of wellness programs echo along the presidential campaign trail. Democrats Hillary Clinton and John Edwards talked them up — as did Republican Mike Huckabee. The presumptive major-party nominees, Democrat Barack Obama and Republican John McCain, both include “prevention” in their health-care proposals.

“Prevention is absolutely the right thing to do,” Arthur Garson Jr., the provost at the University of Virginia Medical School, told me. “The issue is, do not expect to get to the end of the day and have enough money from prevention savings to pay for the uninsured.”

Author of the book “Health Care Half Truths,” Garson cites a recently published study on the high cost of healthy people. Dutch researchers found that medical spending on those who smoke, who died at an average age of 77, was $100,000 less than on non-smokers who were thin and died at 84.

Companies that include wellness programs in their employee benefits may indeed see a savings in lower medical costs and absenteeism resulting from sickness. But what they have done, really, is delay the onset of serious illness during the employees’ working years and pass it onto Medicare, which is when the taxpayers take over.

A study reported in The New England Journal of Medicine finds that only 19 percent of preventive interventions save money. Their value depends on the particular intervention and the sort of people who get it. “For example, drugs used to treat high cholesterol yield much greater value for the money if the targeted population is at high risk for coronary heart disease,” write the authors, Joshua T. Cohen, Peter J. Neumann and Milton C. Weinstein.

Rapidly rising prices for health care also add to the expense of moving big-ticket medical procedures into later years, explains Garson, a cardiologist. “In today’s world, where the rate of medical care inflation is twice the rate of regular inflation, anything done 10 years from now is, in real dollars, 25 percent more expensive.”

There are two ways to deal with that problem, according to Garson. Get medical costs down, and “keep people as healthy as possible as long as possible so that they don’t spend as much money being sick.”

The best kind of aging, he says, is to “have early old age last as long as possible and late old age last 15 minutes.”

Yes, preventive care is a good thing because a long and healthy life is a good thing. We shouldn’t lose sight of that big picture. But let’s not deceive ourselves into believing that wellness programs can reduce medical spending over the long haul. That may come off as an attractive selling point for a health-care plan, but it’s not so.

Froma Harrop is a Providence Journal columnist. Her e-mail address is fharrop@projo.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, May 17

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Wildfire smoke builds over Darrington on Friday, Sept. 11, 2020 in Darrington, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Loss of research funds threat to climate resilience

The Trump administration’s end of a grant for climate research threatens solutions communities need.

Among the programs sponsored by Humanities Washington was a Prime Time Family Reading Event at the Granite Falls Sno-Isle Library in March. (Rachel Jacobson)
Comment: Loss of humanities grants robs us of connections

The loss of $10 million in humanities funding in the state diminishes what celebrates human creativity.

Comment: Democrats’ tax plan aimed at ‘villain,’ hit consumers

The governor should veto a B&O tax increase that will hit food prices at stores and restaurants.

Comment: Compare tax choices of 3 states and watch what happens

Idaho and Montana cut their taxes. Washington raised taxes to historic levels. Will an exodus result?

Forum: Know how to reach out and help someone in crisis

Mental Health Awareness Month offers an opportunity to learn how to help those in need of services.

For its Day of Service, Everett’s VFW Post 2100 delivered subs — Heroes for Heroes — to first responders in the city.
Forum: Everett VFW post delivers ‘Heroes for Heroes’ for Day of Service

Honoring the city’s first responders, hero sandwiches were delivered to fire, police and 911 facilities.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, May 16

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Sarah Weiser / The Herald
Air Force One touches ground Friday morning at Boeing in Everett.
PHOTO SHOT 02172012
Editorial: There’s no free lunch and no free Air Force One

Qatar’s offer of a 747 to President Trump solves nothing and leaves the nation beholden.

The Buzz: What do you get for the man who wants everything?

If you’re looking to impress President Trump, better have a well-appointed luxury 747 on hand.

Schwab: Taken for a ride by the high plane grifter

A 747 from Qatari royals. Cyrpto-kleptocracy. And trade ‘deals’ that shift with Trump’s whims.

Saunders: Saudi visit puts Trump’s foreign policy on display

Like it or not, embracing the Saudis and who they are makes more sense than driving them elsewhere.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.